Underage work in summer: what do businesses and parents need to know?

 

Summer holidays are a time when many pupils and students are looking for temporary work to gain experience, earn money and spend their time productively. Summer jobs for minors are becoming increasingly popular. Laurynas Staniulis, partner at AVOCAD, reminds businesses and parents who employ minors about what they need to know.

According to the lawyer, Lithuanian legislation strictly defines the working conditions of minors and seeks to ensure that their working environment is safe and their working hours are reasonably limited. This is necessary to protect the health and development of young people. Employers offering temporary jobs to minors must comply with strict rules and requirements to ensure that the work experience is not only rewarding but also harmless.

 

What must be included in the employment contract?

Fixed-term contracts are a popular way of employing minors during the summer. These contracts are usually for a limited period of time and stipulate specific working conditions and duration. Lithuanian law stipulates that minors can work from the age of 14, but the hours and nature of their work are strictly regulated. Outside the school year, minors under 16 can work up to 6 hours a day, 30 hours a week. During the school year, up to 12 hours per week. Meanwhile, adolescents aged 16 and over may work up to a maximum of 8 hours per day and 40 hours per week. The nature of the work must be light and without risk to health.

The employment contract must clearly state the duration of the work, the pay, the duties and the conditions of work. It is also important that the employer provides a safe working environment and all the necessary information and training on workplace safety.

The lawyer also points out that minors aged between 14 and 16 need the written consent of a parent or other representative of the child. The employer must provide the child with a medical certificate issued by a health authority stating that the child is fit for the job in question. During the school year, minors aged between 14 and 16 need written consent not only from their parents but also from the school where the child is studying. From the age of 16, neither consent is required.

Regulation and protection

Minors' work is regulated by the Labour Code and other legislation, which details working conditions, working hours and ensuring that working conditions comply with safety and health requirements. Employers who fail to comply with these requirements can face serious consequences, including fines and other legal action. The State Labour Inspectorate carries out regular inspections to ensure that employers comply with all legal provisions and that minors work in appropriate conditions. In addition, minors and their parents have the right to contact the labour inspectorate or other responsible authorities if they consider that working conditions are inadequate or that their rights are being violated.

 

What minors cannot do?

Lawyer Laurynas Staniulis points out that the general rule is that children are not allowed to work, except in light work that is compatible with their physical abilities and that does not adversely affect the child's safety, health, physical, mental, moral or social development. For example, they are not allowed to work in jobs involving alcohol.

When employing minors and providing them with safe and healthy working conditions, the employer must be aware that minors are prohibited from working in work that is harmful to their health or dangerous.

It is also important to remember the working hours of children in light work. During the school year, minors under 16 can work up to 6 hours a day, 30 hours a week. During the school year, up to 12 hours per week. Meanwhile, adolescents aged 16 and over may work up to a maximum of 8 hours per day and 40 hours per week.

Summer work for minors can be a great opportunity to gain valuable work experience, but it must be regulated and safe. This is the only way to ensure that young people can fulfil their potential and prepare for their future careers without harming their health or their education.

 

If you have bought a faulty item, don't forget your right to compensation for the costs of rectifying the fault

Today, consumerism is an integral part of everyday life. We are constantly exposed to new products, services and advertisements. Along with this abundance comes new challenges that force consumers to be vigilant.

According to Dainius Antanaitis, an attorney at AVOCAD, knowing one's rights as a consumer allows you to use the market more effectively, avoid scams and seek justice in unfair situations.

Commenting on recent case law, the lawyer recalls the main rules of the legal relationship between a trader and a consumer, which relate to the quality of the goods sold to the consumer.

First, the object sold must be of good quality, i.e. the characteristics of the object must be in conformity with the consumer contract. The fitness for the intended use of the object must not be understood as meaning that it is possible to use the object, even if this entails considerable inconvenience, disturbance of various kinds or additional costs.

Second, if a defect in the quality of the goods becomes apparent, the Buyer only needs to prove the defect itself. However, the existing presumption of the seller's liability for the quality of the goods to be sold obliges the trader (the seller) to prove that the defects in the goods occurred after the delivery of the goods to the buyer, due to the fault of the buyer.

Third, the seller, having information about the condition or characteristics of the thing to be sold which is relevant to the conclusion of the contract and in the exercise of his duty to ensure the quality of the thing, is under a duty of good faith to disclose that information to the buyer, whether or not the buyer requests such information. Failure to disclose that information to the buyer shall be regarded as bad faith on the part of the seller and, if the undisclosed condition or features of the object subsequently come to light, which make the use of the object inconvenient or impair the usefulness of the object, such condition or features shall be regarded as latent defects in the object.

Thus, if the consumer, having purchased the object, discovers defects in the object which, although they allow the object to be used for its intended purpose, cause inconvenience, disturbance or additional costs, it is sufficient for the consumer to provide evidence of the existence of the defects and not to have to prove the reasons for their occurrence, and even if the trader starts to defend that the consumer should have been aware of the fact that the object is being sold with such features, if the consumer was not previously aware of such features, they are considered to be latent defects.

How can the consumer resolve the problem of quality defects in this situation?

If the goods do not meet the quality requirements, the Civil Code gives the consumer the right to demand that:

  • the product is repaired or replaced;
  • a proportional reduction in the price of the product;
  • unilaterally terminate the contract, return the goods and collect the price paid.

Each of these remedies has its own conditions of application. However, the consumer will choose one of these remedies not only on the basis of these conditions, but also on the basis of his needs and wishes.

For example, a consumer decides to buy a specific home because of its location and architectural choices, and then furnishes, integrates appliances and furnishes it according to his needs.

However, the consumer's joy in their new home was overshadowed by the various shortcomings in the quality of the house (e.g. unusually high heat energy losses during the cold season, resulting in higher heating costs, leaking windows, the façade not only not maintaining its aesthetic appearance, but also the possibility of the house's protective function due to the normal forces of nature, etc.).

If the trader refuses or fails to remedy these deficiencies, the alternatives are to reduce the price or terminate the contract and refund the price. Thus, in the event that the consumer does not want to leave his new home and does not want to terminate the contract, he can opt for a price reduction.

In the case-law of the Court of Cassation, this remedy means that if the value of the defective item actually delivered is lower than the value of the quality item, this difference in value constitutes the amount of the price reduction available for the claim. In such a case, the seller should pay the buyer this difference in value.

However, in this context, another remedy is also available, which is provided for in the general provisions of the Civil Code on sale and purchase contracts, which provide that the buyer has the right to claim reimbursement of the buyer's costs incurred by the buyer for the rectification of the defects, if the defects were decided by the buyer to be rectified by the buyer.

It is therefore worth remembering that if a consumer receives a faulty item, he can either ask for a reduction in the price of the item, or for reimbursement of the costs incurred by the consumer in rectifying the faulty quality of the item.

 

Lover, cheat or business partner? How can I protect my investment in a jointly created business?

A scandal centred on a famous sports trainer has been in the public domain lately. He has, according to women, defrauded a number of them and extorted significant sums of money, of varying amounts, under the guise of romantic promises and relationships.

The latter story is illustrative of the many variations of The Tinder Swindler. However, in the "Lithuanian" case, the situation is more ingenious - the protagonist not only took advantage of a romantic relationship to swindle the money, but also promised to use it for a specific purpose - to set up a joint business with the victims.

The story ended with no love, no money and no promised business, and the victims were left with financial losses and non-material damage to their mental and emotional health. According to publicly available information, the law enforcement authorities refused to open a pre-trial investigation.

The situation is aggravated by the fact that the money was extorted not only by promising to set up a business together, but also by the fact that such plans were laced with promises of love, which objectively makes it more difficult for the victims to weigh up the situation, the risks and the dangers logically.

So what legal options are there to protect your investment in a jointly created business?", says Karolina Laura Briliūtė, Associate at AVOCAD .

First of all, the decision of the law enforcement authorities to refuse to open a pre-trial investigation is not surprising in this case. It is likely and most similar to the fact that a pre-trial investigation for fraud was requested. According to the Criminal Code, fraud is the fraudulent acquisition, evasion or avoidance of an asset or property right, or the avoidance or cancellation of a financial obligation, for the benefit of oneself or others. Fraud is used with the intention of deceiving the owner, manager or person in whose possession the property is located, who, having been deceived, voluntarily transfers the property or property right to the perpetrator, believing that the latter has the right to receive it, or cancels the perpetrator's property obligation.

Although the situation is superficially similar to fraud, it should be borne in mind that criminal law and criminal sanctions are only used as an ultima ratio (last resort), when other legal means of restoring the right violated have been exhausted. Moreover, in the present case, the victims themselves freely contributed money to the perpetrator, incurred expenses for the purchase of various items, and rented premises for the filming and production of the content, and these circumstances should therefore be viewed unfavourably in the context of the decision on the application of criminal measures.

Moreover, circumstances such as shared holidays, travel and spending money together, in the eyes of the law enforcement authorities, are reasonably more likely to suggest a purely romantic relationship, where one of the persons invests more money in the relationship than the other. However, in such a case, there is naturally no legal basis for interfering in the relationship between the two individuals.

Firstly, if the other person proposes to start a business together and asks for funding to start the business (for example, as in this case, to buy certain clothes, items, film equipment, rent an apartment), the relationship is similar to a legal relationship of joint activity.

A joint venture/partnership agreement commits two or more persons (partners) to act jointly, by pooling their property, labour or knowledge, for a specific purpose or activity that is not contrary to the law. The legal form of a joint venture/partnership agreement can take a wide variety of civil relationships - any commitment between several persons, not contrary to law, to engage in a common activity or to pursue a common purpose by cooperating in a joint activity or to pursue a common purpose by cooperating in the use of property or intangible assets. The essential features of a joint venture agreement are: the co-operation of the property, intellectual or labour resources (contributions) of several persons; an obligation to use the co-operated resources to act jointly; and a common purpose and interest of the participants in the development of an activity or the pursuit of an objective.

It should be borne in mind here that a joint venture/partnership agreement must be in writing and, in cases provided for by law, in notarial form. Failure to comply with the form of the agreement renders the agreement null and void. Therefore, in cases where a romantic or other entity proposes to invest finances in a joint venture, it is advisable to initiate the signing of such an agreement, thus protecting oneself against potentially fraudulent actions.

In practice, there have been cases where a court has been asked to declare that a joint venture relationship existed between the parties and that a joint venture agreement had been concluded (certain documents existed, but were not formalised as a single contract). The courts refused to uphold such a claim without finding that there was a unanimous and purposeful intention of the parties to establish and develop a business relationship. Such interpretations only confirm that, even in a romantic relationship, the risks should be weighed and the contract should be drafted in a way that best reflects the intention of the parties in order to best protect the investment.

Finally, if the worst-case scenario were to be the case, where money was invested, but the love ended and the joint venture did not materialise, it is considered that the injured party would be able to rely on the defence of unjust enrichment.

According to the Civil Code, a person who, without legal justification, has acquired by his own acts or otherwise, intentionally or negligently, what he could not and should not have received, is obliged to return it to the person at whose expense it was acquired, except for the exceptions set out in this Code. A person who has been unjustly enriched at the expense of another person without legal justification shall be liable to compensate the latter for damages to the extent of the unjust enrichment.

These rules give effect to one of the fundamental principles of civil law - that no one can be enriched at the expense of another without a basis in law or contract. At the same time, it implies the right to recover from another person what he has unjustly saved or otherwise benefited at the expense of the creditor. In order for the obligation to repay to arise, the person must first have acquired the property without legal justification, i.e. the receipt of the object or money cannot be justified either by law or by a transaction.

In summary, for this remedy to be effective, the person must be prepared to prove that he or she has incurred the expenditure (buying things, renting an apartment, renting a car, etc.), not for romantic purposes, but as a result of material misrepresentation and deception, in the hope that he or she will derive a benefit from the transfer of the money, in this case, the proceeds of the joint business. It is well known that the law does not interfere in the personal (romantic) relationships of individuals, so the person who loses the funds must also be prepared for the risk that the courts may decide that the expenses were incurred in the interests of the couple and not award such losses.

Cancellation of a trip due to force majeure: are you sure you don't have to pay cancellation fees?

Summer is the time for travelling. The fast pace of life is stressful and requires the extra cost of making your own travel arrangements. To simplify the whole process, we often opt for the services of a travel agency, which makes it easier to organise and saves time.

Once you have planned your trip with a tour operator, you sign a travel contract in which the tour operator undertakes to provide you with a holiday. And then life happens - you can't go.

Viktorija Dubovskienė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, points out that under the Civil Code, a traveller has the right to terminate an organised tourist travel contract without paying a termination fee:

  • if the tour operator changes the terms of the package travel contract before the start of the package tour;
  • if, because of the defects pointed out by the traveller, the package travel contract cannot be continued and the tour operator fails to remedy the defects within a reasonable period of time set by the traveller;
  • if force majeure events occur at or very close to the place of destination of the package tour, which may make it impossible to carry out the package tour or to take the travellers to the place of destination of the package tour.

Let's look more closely at the third case, where the contract with the tour operator is terminated due to force majeure circumstances at or very close to the destination, which make it impossible to carry out the trip and to take the tourists to their destination.

According to the lawyer, the case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania states that the following features qualify the circumstances of force majeure (unavoidable and extraordinary):

  • First, these circumstances must exist on the date of termination. These circumstances did not exist at the time of the conclusion of the package travel contract, were not known to the traveller at the time of the conclusion of the contract and could not have been foreseen by the traveller.
  • Second, the force majeure circumstances must have a substantial effect on the execution of the package tour or on the transport of the tourists to the destination of the package tour. Substantial effect on the performance of the organised tourist trip or on the taking of tourists to the place of the organised tourist trip. This includes not only circumstances which render the performance of the contract impossible in general, but also circumstances which, without precluding such performance, make it impossible to perform the contract without endangering the health and safety of the travellers concerned, taking into account, where appropriate, personal factors relating to the individual situation of those travellers. This assessment shall be made on the basis of a prediction that, at the date of termination, the performance of the package travel contract in question is likely to be significantly affected from the consumer's point of view.

The assessment in question is necessarily prospective in nature, as the impact will only be fully realised through the implementation of the package travel contract. Moreover, the assessment must be objective and not be based solely on the consumer's fears, anxieties or feelings of apprehension.

  • Thirdly, force majeure circumstances can only justify the decision of the traveller concerned to cancel the contract without financial loss if they occur at the place of destination or in the immediate vicinity of the destination.
  • Fourthly, the tourist who relies on force majeure could not have controlled those circumstances and avoided their consequences, even if he had taken all reasonable measures within his power. This qualifying factor is to be decided in the light of the nature of the circumstance relied upon for the withdrawal (e.g. security disturbances - military, political, terrorist acts), a problem involving a serious risk to human health (outbreak of a serious disease) or a natural disaster (flood, earthquake or meteorological conditions).

The occurrence of force majeure does not require an official recommendation by the competent authorities to refrain travellers from entering the area concerned or an official decision classifying the area as a risk zone. However, if the competent authorities have issued such a recommendation, this shall constitute proof of force majeure.

If the establishment of the existence of the circumstances in question were to be linked only to the publication of official recommendations and decisions, i.e. if it were to be assumed that the right of the tourist to terminate the package travel contract is only triggered by the publication of such official recommendations (e.g. not to go to certain countries) and decisions (e.g, The right of a tourist to cancel a tourist travel contract when the circumstances of force majeure may make it impossible to carry out the trip (making it impossible to travel safely as agreed in the contract) would be unduly narrow and generally meaningless, which would be contrary to the principle of efficiency as well as to the principle of consumer protection.

Therefore, despite the fact that you are no longer able to go on the trip you want to go on due to what you consider to be force majeure circumstances which have a material impact on the performance of the package tour, you will have to weigh the above-mentioned indications in order for the termination of the contract with the travel agency to be considered justified and for you to have the right to claim a refund of the money paid for the package tour.

Joint and several liability for competition infringements. What do businesses need to know?

In today's economy, the observance and enforcement of fair competition is not only essential to guarantee the protection of consumers' interests, but it is also a crucial process for market operators and national economic indicators," says Domantas Velykis, Junior Associate at AVOCAD.

According to him, unfair competition law infringements must be subject to proportionate and dissuasive penalties. And when is joint and several liability applicable for competition infringements?

In practice, it is not uncommon for a company that owns all the shares of another company to exercise decisive influence over such a subsidiary, which may result in the parent company taking decisions that determine the subsidiary's actions on the market, which may meet the criteria for an infringement of competition law. In order to ensure that a parent company exercising decisive influence and taking decisions for a subsidiary does not escape liability, the Court of Justice of the European Union (" CJEU") has established the rule that, once the circumstances of decisive influence have been established and proven, such companies are considered to be a single economic entity and, therefore, the parent company and the subsidiary are held jointly and severally liable for infringements of competition law.

In the EU, competition law is characterised by strict levels of fines and the application of joint and several fines. The scope for joint and several liability has been particularly extended by the CJEU in the 2021 case The Goldman Sachs Group Inc. v Commission. The parent company owned only 33% of the shares in the subsidiary, but these shares conferred 100% of the voting rights. This subsidiary owned the shares of two other companies which committed competition law infringements by participating in the electricity cable cartel. The European Commission's investigation of the infringement revealed that the parent company was able to exercise a decisive influence over the two infringing subsidiaries, resulting in a joint and several fine of as much as €37,303,000 being imposed on the three legal entities. Following an appeal against the imposition of such a penalty, both the General Court of the European Union and the Court of Justice of the European Union upheld the lawfulness of the imposition of such a joint penalty.

In Lithuania, the legal regulation establishing the right of the Competition Council to impose joint and several liability has entered into force only at the end of 2020. The Competition Law provides that where two or more natural or legal persons carrying out economic activities act as a single economic entity, the parent company and the subsidiary shall be jointly and severally liable for infringements of this Law, as well as the other persons carrying out economic activities forming the economic entity. This aligned the national legal framework with the application of joint and several liability inherent in European Union competition law and the case law of the CJEU interpreting it.

Until this period, the possibility of joint and several liability for competition law infringements had been established exclusively in case law, first by the CJEU and later, with exceptions, by the Lithuanian administrative courts.

The CJEU has established the rule that the concept of an economic entity covers all entities engaged in an economic activity, irrespective of that entity's legal status and the way it is financed, and must be understood as meaning an economic unit, even if that unit is legally composed of several natural or legal persons, so that, if a legal person constituting an economic unit commits an infringement of competition law, the other legal persons constituting the economic unit may also be jointly and severally liable for the infringement.

Of particular importance for the application of joint and several liability is the development of the presumption of decisive influence in the case law of the CJEU - where a parent company owns all or almost all of the shares of a subsidiary that has committed an infringement of the competition rules, the parent company is able to exercise a decisive influence over the market behaviour of the subsidiary, and therefore there is a rebuttable presumption that the parent company in question does in fact exercise a decisive influence over the behaviour of its subsidiary.

In order to impose joint and several liability for competition law infringements, it is sufficient to establish and prove that the parent company owns the entire capital of the subsidiary, and the burden of proving that the presumption of decisive influence is rebuttable rests with the infringing parties. In order to rebut this presumption, the person liable must rebut the actual exercise of decisive influence not only by reference to the relationships within the scope of company law, but also by assessing all relevant economic, organisational, legal and even personal relationships. The grounds for rebuttal of such a presumption are problematic, but are recognised as proportionate to the objectives of joint and several liability for competition law infringements.

Having examined the case law of the administrative courts, the most important conclusions for businesses when joint and several liability for competition law infringements is excluded, which are not directly related to the rebuttal of the presumption of decisive influence, are as follows:

  • when considering the application of joint and several liability for infringements committed before the amendment to the Competition Law entered into force on 1 November 2020, the administrative courts have systematically stated that at the time the infringements were committed, the Lithuanian legislation did not provide for the possibility of applying joint and several liability, and that therefore, joint and several liability is not applicable, in accordance with the principle provision of the Constitution that punishment may be imposed or applied only on the basis of the law;
  • if the competition law infringement committed before 1 November 2020 does not fall within the scope of Article 101 TFEU, i.e. The courts may not rely on the case law of the CJEU, which in such a case has only the value of an additional, non-binding source of interpretation of the law, and therefore, the courts of the Republic of Lithuania may interpret the application of joint and several liability in competition law in the national context, in accordance with the court's prerogative to individually develop the practice of application of joint and several liability in the Republic of Lithuania for infringements of the law on competition;
  • in the case of an infringement of competition law committed before 1 November 2020, i.e. when this type of liability is not provided for by the law, the application of joint and several liability to an undertaking, for example, a parent company and a subsidiary, violates the principle of individualisation of the fine, as the provisions of Articles 35 and 36 of the Law on Competition in force at the time of the commission of the infringement could not be interpreted in such a way that the legal entities constituting the undertaking could be subject to a joint (joint) fine rather than an individual fine.

In view of the above amendment to the Competition Act, which will enter into force at the end of 2020, administrative courts will not be able to apply the above reasons for not imposing joint and several liability on competition law infringements committed after 1 November 2020. Therefore, it should be appreciated that parent companies seeking to avoid joint and several liability for infringements of competition law committed by their subsidiaries later than 1 November 2020 will, in principle, only have the possibility to seek to rebut the presumption of decisive influence by proving that the subsidiary was not subject to decisive influence. However, the case-law of the administrative courts on the application of joint and several liability for competition law infringements committed after 1 November 2020 has not yet been established, and it is therefore left to await such case-law.

Employee protection or medieval inquisition?

Unemployment in Lithuania has been declining steadily over the past decade, except during the pandemic. The number of job vacancies has also increased steadily. Increasingly, what we hear in the public sphere is not about workers' difficulties in finding a job, but about employers' challenges in attracting or retaining workers.

Teleworking, incentive travel, health insurance - these are just a few of the ways employers try to "please" their employees. The advantage of timely and official salaries, highlighted by employers, has become a mockery of the dawn of independence.

"Meanwhile, the Labour Code of the Republic of Lithuaniacontinues to live successfully in the spirit of the early 21st century, when it was necessary to use extremely harsh measures to protect the "weak and abused" worker. Today's labour market makes it necessary to seriously reconsider the concept of the employee as a weak party," says Laurynas Staniulis, partner at the law firm AVOCAD.

One of the most serious problems in today's labour market is the employer's ability to dismiss an employee. Dismissal of an employee is one of the most difficult or expensive risks to manage and can cost more than 12 months' salary.

The LC provides that if the dismissal of a worker is found to be unfair, the worker is entitled to compensation for the entire period during which the dispute between the worker and the employer over the lawfulness of the dismissal is pending, up to a maximum of 12 months. As court proceedings in Lithuania are not fast, as a rule, the case almost always takes more than a year to be heard. As a result, if an employee's dismissal is found to be unfair, the compensation awarded to the employee is usually 12 months' salary, regardless of whether or not the employee worked during that period.

This is fundamentally at odds with the essence of compensation, which aims to cover the loss of income suffered by the worker when he or she is dismissed and loses income. In the meantime, it is rare for anyone not to have found a new job, and often to have been employed practically since the dismissal. In such a case, if the court awards the employee the maximum compensation, the question arises - is it compensation for the employee or a penalty for the employer?

It is not the institution of compensation itself that is being questioned, but the need for a personalised approach to cases. If the court were to take into account the fact that the worker was unfairly dismissed but found a new position relatively quickly, the compensation to be awarded should be calculated exclusively for the period during which the worker had no earnings, thus compensating the worker for the damage suffered by him.

Inflexible interpretation of the provisions of the Labour Code on compensation to an employee in case of unfair dismissal, contrary to the objective of preventing employer abuse, often creates room for employers who seek ways to avoid dismissal of an employee at the initiative of the employer and to "force" the employee to submit a request themselves. Such attempts can take the form of worsening working conditions, mobbing, etc. Meanwhile, honest employers, whose values and business ethics do not allow them to use similar methods, are forced to risk being penalised for dismissing an employee under the Labour Code if some procedural irregularity leads to the dismissal being found inappropriate.

Data from the State Labour Inspectorate for the first quarter of 2024 show that, although dismissal disputes account for only 8% of the total number of labour disputes, labour disputes concerning the unlawful dismissal of an employee are the second most frequent. This only confirms that the problem is of great importance.

Is it not time to adapt the regulation, interpretation and application of labour relations to today's rapidly changing labour market?

The modern company director: legal challenges and risks

Endless geopolitical tensions and military conflicts, shifting trade patterns and significant economic fluctuations are the challenges of modern business. Maximising profits without serious legal concerns is the ultimate goal of today's managers. Does everyone manage to break even and where are the biggest risks? Egidijus Langys, Managing Partner of AVOCAD, talks more about this and the limits of a manager's responsibility .

The Chief Executive Officer is the decision-maker who first organises the day-to-day running of the company. He or she hires and fires employees, concludes and terminates their contracts of employment, gives them incentives and imposes penalties. The manager acts on behalf of the company and has the right to conclude transactions, except where the company's articles of association provide for quantitative representation of the company. In short, he/she is responsible for the organisation of the company's activities and the achievement of its objectives.

Must act honestly and reasonably, with loyalty and confidentiality

As well as ensuring the day-to-day running of the company, a manager must also fulfil fiduciary duties of loyalty and care. "This means that a manager must act honestly and reasonably towards the legal entity and other members of the legal entity's organs, be loyal to the company and observe confidentiality. He must avoid situations where his personal interests conflict or may conflict with the interests of the legal person. A director should not confuse the assets of the legal entity with his or her own assets, use them or information obtained in his or her capacity as a member of an organ of the legal entity for personal benefit or for the benefit of a third party without the consent of the members of the legal entity, etc. The duty of a director is to act solely in the interests of the company," the lawyer stresses.

According to Mr Langis, a company's CEO must meet the objective criteria of a careful and qualified businessman. According to the lawyer, the duties of care and loyalty will not be breached if the decision is made in good faith - without conflict of interest, after having investigated the information about the possible consequences of the decision, after having been provided with all the necessary information, and after having evaluated whether the business decision does not exceed a reasonable commercial risk. In making decisions, the manager must also consider the normal business and commercial activities and the nature of the business of the company, taking into account the degree of risk tolerance of the company.

The manager and the creditor do not have a direct contractual relationship, and the manager's fiduciary duties to take into account the interests of creditors when taking decisions relating to the company's business activities only arise when the company's financial situation deteriorates. "The manager's liability to creditors arises only if the company is unable to satisfy the creditor's claims on its own," notes Langys.

Creditor's right to bring a direct action for damages against a company's director

A creditor can bring a direct action against the directors and shareholders of a company in two cases: where there is direct damage to the creditor and where the bankruptcy is declared intentional and the directors or shareholders are found to be guilty of intentional bankruptcy.

Liability of the manager can only arise if it is established that the manager of the company has acted unlawfully in order to infringe the rights of a particular creditor (misrepresentation, misrepresentation in the conclusion of a contract between the company and a particular creditor, or other unfair acts directed at a particular creditor). A director is also liable where those acts have caused damage to the creditor and the company is unable to meet the creditor's claims itself. Moreover, damage does not include the general insolvency of the company or a reduction in its solvency, which affects the individual creditor and other creditors of the company equally.

According to the lawyer, if a direct action against the manager is brought by the tax authorities, the unpaid taxes can be considered as damage caused to the creditor, as the taxes are only legally due to the creditor. If the manager evades the payment of tax, his actions must be regarded as directed against the creditor in question. "A very important point in such situations is whether the company would have been able to pay the tax at the time when it should have been calculated and paid," points out Mr Langys.

Risks and legitimacy of business decision-making

Langys points out that a business transaction that ends in a loss does not automatically mean that the manager has acted unlawfully. Liability is not for the negative economic result of the action, but for the legality of the actions taken at the time of the decision. "A business decision taken without breaching the duty of care and loyalty is considered lawful, even if it is detrimental to the company", says the lawyer.

The lawyer points out that all managers must be aware of the possible consequences of their decisions, which can range from damages to disqualification from holding the office of manager of a public or private legal person or from being a member of a collegiate management body for a period of 1 to 5 years. Improper decisions by a manager may also lead to administrative and criminal liability.

 

 

 

 

­­­

 

 

Persecution. Do we have effective tools to protect ourselves from it?

There is a common perception that only public, famous and popular figures are most likely to face persecution. However, this latent illegality is quite widespread in society and almost anyone can be a victim of stalking.

Persecutors can not only be those who have experienced an unhappy love or marriage, but also, for example, parents towards their children. According to the Lithuanian Centre for Human Rights, almost one in ten people will be persecuted in 2021. Persecution has long been beyond social status or gender. Social space and various media platforms are a particularly favourable and comfortable environment for persecution.

What should we do when such intense attention may prove to be not only unwanted, but also cause negative experiences, discomfort, and ultimately the risk of a real threat, and do we have effective legal means to protect ourselves from such actions?", says Karolina Laura Briliūtė, lawyer at AVOCAD .

Stalking is generally understood as repeated, unwanted behaviour directed at a specific person. The Criminal Code elaborates on the elements of this offence in more detail: stalking is understood as an act of systematically carrying out, against a person's express will and without lawful justification, a series of acts which have the effect of forcing the victim to change his or her place of residence or work or educational institution or have any other negative impact on his or her social life or emotional state.

Although the Criminal Code used to criminalize acts of stalking (systematic intimidation), the criminalisation of stalking as such is relatively recent, dating back to 2021. In 2024, a draft amendment to this article was registered, with a view to strengthening the liability and introducing imprisonment of up to three years as an alternative punishment. However, a glance at the explanatory memorandum of the amending law shows that the assumptions behind the need to increase liability are exclusively related to maintaining the consistency of the Penal Code, the norms, the sanctions for the commission of offences, but not to taking into account the widespread extent of persecution in society, the investigation and trial of such acts in the courts, and the corresponding assessment of the need to increase liability.

How is persecution treated in case law?

Since the amendment of the Criminal Code, the Court of First Instance has heard 5 cases in which people have been found guilty of persecution. In a number of cases, other offences have been committed in connection with persecution. In the light of these court decisions, it is clear that, in order to be found guilty, the person experiencing the unlawful acts should, at the time of their occurrence, keep a record of the acts in the following ways: 1) keep correspondence, calls, record calls if possible, take screenshots; 2) film and photograph unwanted visits; and 3) tell the people around them and their relatives as much as possible about the acts of persecution, in order to be able to confirm them in the pretrial investigation and in the courts if needed.

However, although there are court decisions finding individuals guilty of persecution, there are several important points to bear in mind: on the one hand, the court decisions reviewed do not reflect the reality that a significant number of individuals are victims of persecution and are afraid or avoid going to the pre-trial investigation authorities; on the other hand, criminal measures should only be seen as a last resort. It is therefore certain that there are a number of cases where pre-trial investigators refuse to open pre-trial investigations because of the possibility of prosecution. Thus, persons subjected to acts of persecution continue to be immune from such acts being used against them.

As a conditional alternative, the Protection from Domestic Violence Act provides for the possibility of obtaining a domestic violence protection order, which is designed to protect people at risk of violence if there is a sufficient risk that domestic violence may be used.

Under the scope of the law, acts of harassment could fall within the definition of violence (intentional mental exposure resulting in non-pecuniary damage). Such a warrant could, inter alia, order the person carrying out the stalking to stay away from a specified distance, to refrain from communication and to refrain from seeking contact. However, this option also has several drawbacks: firstly, such a warrant, even if issued, would only be issued for a period of 15 days; secondly, the warrant could only be issued to persons living in close proximity, which excludes persons who are not known to the applicant, or who are not well-known, and who are carrying out such unlawful acts.

Thus, an assessment of the legal framework for protection against persecution shows that it is not sufficient to fully protect those suffering from such acts. This is all the more so when the acts of victimisation are not only physical but also extend to social media and, moreover, go beyond the immediate environment. Often, such unlawful acts are not always sufficient to trigger a prosecution or criminal measures.

Given the prevalence of this act and in order to protect individuals, amendments to the Law on Protection against Domestic Violence could be initiated. Namely, by providing for additional cases in which a protection order against domestic violence could be issued, broadening the range of persons against whom it could be issued. Accordingly, it is likely that, once a warrant of this kind has been issued in respect of a particular person, and if the indications of persecution persist and a pre-trial investigation is requested and the case is brought before a court, the fact that a warrant has been issued would be seen as an additional circumstance in support of the persecutor's guilt.

 

 

Household consumers and small businesses can terminate their energy supply contract without any termination fee

According to recent case law, it is clearly established that household consumers, micro-enterprises and small enterprises have the right to unilaterally terminate their electricity sales contract and switch to an independent supplier free of charge from 15 July 2021, without paying any termination fees.

According to Mantas Baigis, Senior Associate at AVOCAD, the Lithuanian Court of Appeals has recently issued a very important decision rejecting a claim of more than EUR 1 million for the payment of termination fees.

"Until now, both household consumers and small businesses have been afraid to initiate the termination of uneconomic electricity contracts and change electricity supplier, because electricity suppliers demand huge termination fees for terminating contracts," Mantas Baigys notes.

Directive (EU) 2019/944 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 5 June 2019 concerning common rules for the internal market in electricity and amending Directive 2012/27/EU (Directive 2019/944) provided for an obligation for Member States to ensure that unreasonable switching charges are not levied, and for the Member States to ensure, by their proactive action, that relevant unreasonable charges (i.e., switching-only charges that are unrelated to a specific loss of the supplier) are not levied against household consumers and small businesses.

Legislator 01 June 2023 The Energy Law of the Republic of Lithuania established that household consumers, micro-enterprises and small enterprises as defined in the Law on Small and Medium Business Development of the Republic of Lithuania shall have the right to unilaterally terminate the contract for the sale and purchase of electricity or the contract for the sale and purchase of electricity and provision of the transmission service to an independent supplier, and shall have the right to change the independent supplier.

According to the legislator, it is prohibited to provide for termination fees, switching fees and penalties to be charged to the consumers referred to in this paragraph for the unilateral termination of a contract for the sale and purchase of electricity or a contract for the sale and purchase of electricity and the provision of a transmission service.

Recent case law has clarified that the provisions of Directive (EU) 2019/944 have been properly transposed into the Lithuanian legal system since the adoption of Law No XIV-483 of 30 June 2021, which meant that as of 15 July 2021, it was ensured that household consumers and small businesses would not pay any switching fees when unilaterally terminating their contracts.

In other words, even if the termination fee was provided for in the contract between the parties in the electricity sales contracts concluded after 15 July 2021, it cannot be applied to the termination of the contract in accordance with the legal framework. Even if a termination fee has been paid (on or after 15 July 2021), you have the right to claim its reimbursement.

According to the lawyer, both ordinary consumers and businesses (micro and small enterprises) have the right to review their electricity contracts and assess whether there are any objective criteria for choosing another electricity supplier, and not to pay any termination fee. Even if termination fees are fixed in the contract.

"This does not in itself mean that it is possible to initiate the termination of contracts in haste. It is necessary to responsibly assess whether all the necessary conditions for such action exist. It is therefore advisable to seek legal advice," points out the AVOCAD lawyer.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lawyer's tips for e-business: how to sell not only profitably but also legally

Often, businesses only become interested in the legal requirements of their business when they encounter problems, but law is not just about solving disputes, it helps prevent them from happening in the first place. "Those who know this rule are much less likely to face legal challenges, which cost much more to resolve than to prevent," says Egidijus Kieras, an attorney at AVOCAD. He highlighted the most important international legal aspects of e-commerce for the participants of the GlobalShop "Innovation Agency" Academy, which are essential for e-business developers.

According to the lawyer, anyone starting and running an e-business should be aware that non-compliance with the law is punishable by a fine of up to 4% of annual turnover. "If fines don't scare you, be aware that if the infringements are repeated, your e-marketplace could simply be blocked," warns Egidijus Kieras.

What is important for an entrepreneur to do with e-commerce?

According to Kier, almost every action has a legal expression, so the rules of trade are set out in law. Acts come in two flavours: national law and international law.

Each country makes laws that apply only to itself, regulating the activities of individuals, their requirements, etc. For example, there may be differences in terms of return periods, delivery, etc.

The rules and requirements for e-commerce are, in most cases, laid down in directives issued by the EU, but they are not directly applicable in the country and each country has to incorporate the provisions of the directives into its national legislation, i.e. issue laws, e.g.: after the adoption of a directive, the Civil Code or other laws in Lithuania are revised.

"Trade rules need to be harmonised according to the rules of the specific country where the goods are sold to consumers. A website is tailored to the consumers of that particular country if it is available in their language, the presentation of the website is automatically adapted to the consumer's country (with appropriate extensions), and there are other clear indications that the offer of the goods is a targeted act in that particular territory," says the lawyer.

Distance Purchase Agreement - what must be included in it?

The legal relationship between the consumer and the trader is established by the sales contract. What must it contain?

  • Key product features. Although, according to the lawyer, it seems to be very clear to everyone, there are a number of fines for this. Last year, the State Office for Consumer Rights Protection fined €45,624 to a company" that operates an online shop. The Office found that the information published by the portal was incomplete and that the goods presented to consumers differed from their description, for example, they were scratched, there were certain irregularities, etc. Thus, the bottom line is that the description of the product must be specific and not mislead the consumer.
  • Trader's identity: name, address, telephone, email;
  • The total price of the goods or services, including taxes and other costs. If the total cost cannot reasonably be calculated in advance, the method used to calculate the price must be indicated. "The important thing to understand here is that if you don't specify the total price including all taxes, you won't be able to collect them from the buyer later," notes Kieras.
  • If you apply personalisation of the price, this must be stated. The buyer must understand that you have personalised the price he sees according to certain automated criteria. What problem does this rule solve? Businesses can use algorithms based on a consumer's purchase history or the websites they visit to determine whether a consumer is interested in a particular product, and if the answer is yes, they increase the price of the product or service. So, if you have personalised the price, you need to make that clear to the buyer.
  • Payment, delivery, the procedure for performance of the contract and the period by which the trader undertakes to deliver the goods.
  • If a right of withdrawal applies, the conditions, time limit and procedure for exercising this right, as well as a model withdrawal form. If there is no possibility to withdraw, this must also be stated. If applicable, it shall state that the consumer must bear the costs of returning the goods after withdrawal. If you do not specify this beforehand, you will not be able to claim later.
  • A reminder that there is a legal guarantee on the goods (2 years).
  • Commercial warranties (warranties provided by the manufacturer or seller).
  • Illegitimate dispute procedures.

And these are just some of the conditions required for a contract.

What is unfair trading?

Egidijus Kieras also points out which actions are considered unfair in all EU countries and which should be avoided. A commercial practice is unfair if it prevents the consumer from making an informed decision or influences his free economic behaviour:

  1. Illegal indication of the reliability and quality mark.
  2. Fraudulent claiming of a licence (authorisation), or product approval.
  3. You make an offer with a price, but you know that you won't actually sell the goods on those terms.
  4. Misleading claims that the product will only be available for an extremely short period of time.
  5. Specifying the consumer's statutory rights as an exclusive condition of the offer.
  6. Fraudulent closures by announcing sales.
  7. Deceptive claims that the product cures.
  8. Offering to enter a competition or receive a prize, but not giving the prizes or their equivalents specified.
  9. Including an invoice or similar payment document in marketing materials.
  10. Creating a pyramid distribution system.
  11. Inappropriate labelling of advertising.
  12. Rating.

What is important to know about ranking on an e-marketplace?

E-Commerce operators that allow consumers to search for products offered by different sellers must inform consumers of the main criteria that determine the ranking of the products provided to the consumer as a result of his search query. For example, it may indicate that products are ranked on the basis of price, the ratings of the customers who have purchased the product, popularity, or a combination of different criteria. If the ranking of a product in the search results is based on paid advertising or other payments received from the relevant merchants, this information should also be clearly indicated to users.

Genuineness of feedback, who guarantees it?

Where a trader makes product reviews available to the consumer, information on whether and how the trader ensures that the reviews published are from consumers who have actually used or purchased the product shall be considered essential. The aim is to better inform the online shopper so that he is not misled and makes a correct, informed decision.

It is up to the entrepreneur to ensure that the review is genuine. "Usually the authorities ask for clarification and then you have to provide evidence that the reviews are written by your real customers, as well as how the reviews were obtained, whether the users have the possibility to make negative comments as well, and whether they are visible to the public," notes Kieras.

In his view, these questions must be answered, as failure to do so could result in sanctions.

The delivery deadline must be taken seriously

Delivery must be made within 30 days. If the consumer does not receive the goods within this period, he has the right to terminate the distance contract and the seller must immediately refund any money paid by the consumer. "In practice, the deadline depends more on the consumer's wishes. However, this time limit should be taken seriously, as many of the fines imposed are because of this", says Kieras.

The lawyer advises that, in any case, businesses must cooperate with both the consumer and the authorities. "The fines are then much lower, even if infringements are found. Remember that the most common sanctions are those for failure to refund funds on time and failure to respond to consumer complaints on time," notes Egidijus Kieras.