Partitioning is the best solution for disputing co-owners

In practice, it is often the case that real estate is owned by several owners. Tensions and disputes often arise between the co-owners over how to manage and use the property. According to Eimantas Čepas, Senior Associate at AVOCAD, the usual way to resolve such a situation is for the co-owners to agree on a procedure for the use of the property, but this does not guarantee that disagreements will not arise again.

It is difficult for the conflicting co-owners to determine the above-mentioned arrangements for the use of the property on their own, which often leads to disputes going to court, where the situation is not necessarily resolved. For example, when improvements or transfers of jointly used property are sought, the will of the co-owners is required, i.e. the co-owners remain partly dependent on each other even after the order of use has been established.

"However, there is another legal tool that can often help to eliminate disputes between co-owners in a definitive way, but which is not often used in practice," says Eimantas Čepas. The Civil Code provides that each co-owner has the right to request the division of his/her share of the common property.

Partition means a change in the legal regime of the object and the status of the co-owner.The exercise of ownership rights in this way means that the joint ownership with the other co-owners is terminated in respect of the co-owner who is being partitioned. In simple terms, the purpose of partition is not to attempt to determine the order in which the co-owners are to use the property, but rather to completely separate the property rights of the conflicting parties and to leave the property in the possession of one or more of the co-owners.

According to the Supreme Court of Lithuania, the possibility of partition of the jointly shared property is established in order to facilitate and simplify the exercise of the rights of the owner in the common property and to avoid disputes arising in the future between the co-owners in the exercise of these rights.In resolving these questions of the exercise of the co-owners' property rights, priority must be given to the complete partition of the property as the best way of ensuring the maximum exercise of the co-owners' property rights under the law.

How should the division of the property under joint ownership be carried out in order to protect the legitimate interests of all joint owners?

Eimantas Čeps believes that if there is already a conflict, it will not be possible to reach an agreement on how to divide the property, so the only solution is to go to court.The Civil Code provides that if no agreement is reached on the method of partition, the object shall be partitioned in kind as far as possible without disproportionate damage to its purpose, on the basis of an action brought by any co-owner. In this way, the exercise of the rights of the co-owner as owner of the property terminates the community of property held with the other co-owners, and the partitioned co-owner becomes the subject of a right of private ownership and has the right to possess, use and dispose of the partitioned property as he sees fit. In other cases, one or more of the co-owners to be divided receives compensation in cash.Thus, the court deciding disagreements between the co-owners on the partition from the right of community of property is essentially limited to resolving them in two ways: either by dividing the property in kind or by awarding compensation in cash.

In such disputes, priority is given to the division of property in kind, i.e. each person is allocated a share of the property that belongs to him or her, which he or she can use without restriction. The Court of Cassation has clarified that, in the case of a partition in kind according to a partition option agreed between the parties or approved by the court, the parts of the common property are separated, delimited.The best way to ensure the exercise of the co-owners' property rights is to completely separate the co-owner from the jointly shared property, without leaving the parts of the object which are used in common, and it is therefore such a separation which must be sought. However, separation in kind is not always realistically possible, for example because of the small size of the property or because the jointly owned property as a whole may be put to more beneficial use. In addition, one of the co-owners normally has a greater interest in acquiring the whole of the jointly owned property.

If it is not possible to separate the property in kind, the decision is to divide the property by paying one of the co-owners monetary compensation. The following conditions are necessary for such a partition:

  • first, all possibilities have been exhausted to divide the property in kind according to the shares of the co-owners, but this cannot be done without disproportionate damage to the purpose of the property;
  • Second, the factual circumstances are such that the taking of a part of the property from a co-owner should not be regarded as a substantial interference with the owner's rights (e.g. where the share of the common property is significantly smaller in comparison to the other co-owners, it cannot be realistically divided, and the owner's interest in the use of the common property is not considered to be very important).

In the case of a partition in kind, where one of the co-owners is given possession of the property in its entirety and the other is compensated in cash, the crucial point is precisely which co-owner may receive the property and which is compensated. According to the case-law, compensation may be awarded both to the co-owner seeking partition and to the co-owner being partitioned.The decision as to who is to be awarded compensation is determined by the following considerations:

  • the will of the parties;
  • the need of each of the co-owners to be divided for the object to be divided;
  • the possibility of buying another such item;
  • pay compensation to the co-owners being divided;
  • other relevant circumstances.

Once the issue of partition has gone to court, a particularly important point is the principle of adversarial proceedings in civil litigation, where the final decision of the court depends essentially on what the parties are able to prove.

Once it has been concluded that it is more appropriate to transfer the jointly owned property to one or more co-owners, it must also be decided what financial compensation is to be paid to the co-owners from whom their share of the property is being divided, i.e., in simple terms, those who are losing their rights over the property. The case-law states that a partition by way of monetary compensation is lawful and does not prejudice the rights of the co-owners only if the compensation corresponds to the real value of the part to be partitioned. As a general rule, compensation is fair if it corresponds to the market value of the share. It is important to note that the determination of the market value of a part of the property is also a matter of evidence, and therefore, in order to achieve such a partition, it is important to gather evidence of the value beforehand and to assess accordingly the amount of compensation that may be payable/received in the event of the claim in question being satisfied.

In conclusion, the lawyer points out that in a situation where the property is held under joint ownership and the co-owners disagree on the circumstances of the management of the property, the determination of the order of use of the property does not normally resolve the conflict situations definitively, which tend to recur. "In contrast, once the property is divided, there is no longer any community of property, each owner acquires ownership of the divided part of the property, and can exert a physical and economic influence on the property and determine its legal fate without having to consult the other parties," says Eimantas Čepas.

The same position is also taken in case-law, i.e. the termination of the legal relationship of shared ownership clearly facilitates and simplifies the exercise of the subjective rights which constitute the content of the property right, since the object of the shared ownership becomes, after the division, the objects of separate ownership and each owner of the property then decides separately on the implementation of his/her right of ownership, which helps to avoid any future disputes between the co-owners.

"An important aspect of the application of such a legal instrument is that the unwillingness of the other co-owner to have the partition carried out does not mean that such a method of exercising the right of ownership is not possible, i.e. the unwillingness of a person to have the property partitioned does not alone mean that the property will not be partitioned," notes the lawyer of AVOCAD.

The priority application of the division of the community property also allows for a more effective implementation of one of the main objectives of civil proceedings, namely to restore legal peace between the parties to the dispute as soon as possible. In practice, when many people are unaware of this possibility, the usual aim is simply to establish the order of use of the property held in common ownership. As already mentioned, the latter method may settle disputes in the short term, but the basis for future conflicts remains, as the co-owners remain dependent on each other for the management of the property. Thus, the legal remedy of partition is relatively rarely used, although it can be one of the most effective ways to finally settle disputes between co-owners.

 

Egidijus Langys: "Our colleagues don't have night shifts and don't work weekends"

Egidijus Langys has become the managing partner of AVOCAD . He replaces the previous incumbent, Laurynas Staniulis, who remains a partner of AVOCAD.

"Change is good and the organisation is no exception. It has come a long way in these twelve years, but now I feel it's time to innovate. Egidijus is an integral part of AVOCAD's history and success. He is a personality who has made a major contribution to strengthening the professional community. His professionalism as a lawyer and his personal qualities make him very suitable for the position of managing partner. I have no doubt that he will not only deliver excellent results for the law firm, but also bring new winds that will help AVOCAD to achieve its goals," said Laurynas Staniulis, who will be taking over the position.

"We are very unique in the Lithuanian legal market in terms of our approach to legal work. Although we constantly strive for the highest professional results and maximum client satisfaction, one of the most important goals of our organisation is to have motivated people, a strong internal culture, mutual support and an inspiring atmosphere," notes E. Langys. According to the newly elected Managing Partner, the work of lawyers is often associated with unbearable workloads, ruthless competition and exploitation of lawyers. "AVOCAD has been consistently breaking these stereotypes for more than a decade and more and more young colleagues are listening to us. Although, admittedly, some of them still find it hard to believe that we don't have a night shift and don't have to work at weekends," says the lawyer.

Egidijus Langys has been working at AVOCAD since 2012. He is an arbitrator and mediator at Vilnius Commercial Arbitration Court. The new Managing Partner specialises in corporate and commercial law, insolvency of legal and natural persons, medical, competition and other areas of law.

Who has to pay for terrace repairs - all owners of an apartment building or just the terrace users? 

A terrace on the roof of an apartment building sounds attractive and luxurious. But it's also a big headache when it comes to repairing it and paying the bill for it.

Who has to pay for the repair of the terrace - all the owners of the apartment building or only the users of the terrace who have bought such a luxury apartment - answers Mantas Baigys, Senior Associate at AVOCAD Law Firm

According to the legal regulation laid down in the Law on Associations of Owners of Multi-Unit Residential Buildings or Other Purpose Buildings, the roof, the load-bearing structures of terraces, and the enclosures are classified as common building structures.

One way of using a flat roof is to build a terrace on top of it. Such a building structure, where a terrace is built on a flat roof, has a dual functional purpose: it serves as a roof, i.e. the main structure of the house, protecting the interior of the building from the effects of the weather, and it can also be used by the owners of the building, or a part of them, as a terrace (open area) for domestic, recreational and other needs.

According to the lawyer, irrespective of the fact that a terrace is built on the flat roof (or part of it), the roof remains a common structure of the building, i.e. an object that is part of the common property of all the owners of the flats and other premises of a multi-apartment building.

The terrace, as a parking area, can be either a shared space, in which case its ownership will also be shared, or it can be used by the owners of a single apartment.

"However, in any case where the terrace is used by only one owner of an apartment and the Real Estate Register data on the apartment owned by that owner indicates that it is an apartment with a terrace, the roof structure on which the terrace is located and the other external structures of the terrace remain the common property of all the owners of all the apartments or other premises," points out Baigys.

Does this mean that all owners of a block of flats have to contribute to the repair costs?

"Not by itself - it depends on the actual situation in the apartment block. All the owners of the building will have to pay for the repair of the terrace if the flat roof structure of the apartment building and the terrace structures installed on the flat roof, which according to the design of the building are part of the flat roof structure that protects the interior of the building from the effects of the weather, are the common property of all the owners of all the flats or other premises, and in the case where only the owners of some of the flats or other premises are entitled to use the terraces," notes the lawyer.

Only the users of the terrace will have to pay for repairs to the terrace, if the terrace structures installed on the flat roof of the apartment building are not part of the flat roof structures designed by the building to protect the interior of the building from the weather and the terrace is not a common use.

All in all, to find out whether you will have to pay for repairs to your terrace, you need to look at the design documentation of the house - whether the terrace is designed as part of the roof structure.

When building new apartment blocks, developers should also take note of the latest case law on whether the terrace is designed as part of the roof of the block of flats. Otherwise, this may reduce the sale value of the home due to potentially high repair costs that would be borne solely by the user of the terrace.

The lawyer advises that homebuyers should also analyse these circumstances in order to assess who will have to pay for the terrace repairs. Otherwise, unplanned repair costs may be incurred. The safest approach is to consult professionals in the field who can help you assess all potential risks.

Profit sharing: are all shareholders entitled to dividends?

Many companies call an ordinary general meeting before the end of April after the end of the financial year to approve the annual accounts and distribute profits. Shareholders of companies often look forward to this date in the hope of receiving an appropriate share of the profits in the form of dividends. But are they all entitled to receive dividends? Can they be paid every year? Are companies free to decide in what form and how much dividends to pay to their shareholders?

According to Sandra Mickienė, Associate at AVOCAD, the Law on Joint Stock Companies (the "ABI") provides for certain important restrictions that must be taken into account when deciding on the payment of dividends.

Are all shareholders of a company entitled to receive dividends, and what proportion of the net profit is used to pay dividends?

The answer to this question, according to the lawyer, depends on when the individual became a shareholder of the company, whether he or she has paid up his or her shares in full and by the due date, and the way in which the company's articles of association regulate the distribution and payment of dividends (for example, the articles of association may provide that the dividend on paid-up shares is reduced if payment for the shares has been completed in the financial year in respect of which the dividend is paid; they may stipulate the percentage of the company's net profits to be used for the payment of the dividend; and so on.) or in the shareholders' agreement, if any (shareholders' agreements often provide that no dividends will be paid to shareholders for a certain period of time in order to, for example, invest a certain proportion of the profits in the development of the company's business, and usually regulate the percentage of net profit to be allocated to the payment of the dividends, and so on).

 

If the company's articles of association do not deal with this issue or do not provide for any exceptions, if there is no shareholders' agreement, then the following general rules apply:

(1) Dividends shall be payable to those persons who, at the close of business on the day of the general meeting of shareholders declaring the dividend, were shareholders of the company and who have paid up their shares;

2) if the share is not fully paid up and its maturity date has not expired, the shareholder's dividend is reduced in proportion to the unpaid portion of the share price;

3) if the share is not fully paid up and the payment period has expired, no dividend is payable to that shareholder;

4) the decision on the payment of dividends and the specific amount of dividends is taken by the general meeting of shareholders of the companies. The decision shall determine the proportion of profits to be allocated to the payment of dividends and the proportionate dividend per share.

In what form are dividends paid?

In practice, dividends are paid to shareholders in the form of shares or assets, or in some other form. However, the ABL provides that dividends must be paid in cash.

Courts have held that it is contrary to the provisions of the ABI to pay dividends in a form other than cash. For example, in one case, the court ruled on the conclusion of assignment of claims agreements to pay dividends. In this case, the court held that the ABI regulates the payment of dividends only in cash, and that it is therefore contrary to the law to enter into assignment of claims agreements for the payment of dividends.

 

Restrictions on the payment of dividends

 

The Companies Act provides that the General Meeting of Shareholders may not decide to declare and pay dividends if at least one of the following conditions is met:

(1) the company has outstanding debts which have fallen due before the decision is taken;

2) the amount of distributable profit for the financial year is negative(loss);

3) the company's equity is less than , or would become less if dividends were paid, than the sum of the company's authorised capital, statutory reserve, revaluation reserve and reserve for the acquisition of own shares.

According to AVOCAD, it is important to consider not only what debts the company has to its creditors and what the company's situation is before the dividend is paid. "Make sure and assess where the company will be after the dividend has been paid, i.e. whether the company will be able to pay its creditors after the dividend has been paid, and whether the company's equity will not be less than the sum of the company's share capital, the mandatory reserve, the revaluation reserve and the reserve for the acquisition of treasury shares," Sandra Mickienė advises.

However, in business, there are cases where these imperative limits are not respected. There is still a perception that the distribution of a company's profits is a matter for the company itself and its shareholders. Shareholders pay themselves dividends in spite of the legal restrictions, taking the view that non-compliance with the law is a mere formality and hoping that no one will claim against them, either now (since all shareholders have approved the payment of dividends) or in the future.

But the courts say otherwise - if dividends are paid illegally, in breach of the law, shareholders may have to repay dividends paid to the company even years later.

In 2023, the Supreme Court of Lithuania heard a case in which the insolvency administrator applied to the court for an award of dividends paid by the shareholders of the bankrupt company to the shareholders of the bankrupt company (in excess of EUR 75,000), which essentially constituted damage suffered by the bankrupt company as a result of the unlawful acts of the company shareholders. The administrator took the position that both at the time of the decision to pay the dividend (7 March 2017) and at the time of the payment of the dividend (16 August 2017), the company was in arrears to its creditors, and that therefore the decision to pay the dividend and the payment of the dividend were illegal. The Court of First Instance upheld the action and the Court of Appeal and the Court of Cassation have not substantially modified it.

 

Divorce in business: how to protect yourself from painful consequences? 

Divorce, both in personal life and in business relationships, is a difficult and emotional process. And whether the separation is between famous people, or whether the loss is in the millions or just pennies, the fact of betrayal is equally painful for everyone. Egidijus Langys, partner at AVOCAD, answers whether it can be avoided and what legal safeguards exist.

According to a business law lawyer, the most effective way to prevent tensions with a business partner is to have a shareholders' agreement. This is an agreement between the shareholders of a company that has the force of law for the parties to the contract. It can also be concluded in companies with a large number of shareholders. It should be noted that, in order to avoid a legal impasse, it is acceptable and advisable that the shareholders' agreement be signed by all shareholders of the company. 

"There are no specific restrictions on the content of this agreement, other than the mandatory provisions of the law governing corporate governance, which makes it a highly flexible legal instrument. The shareholders may set out various terms and conditions, both those governing the specifics of the company's management and those regulating the relations between the shareholders, which have the force of law for the parties to the contract," says Langys.

A key advantage of shareholders' agreements is the ability of the parties to create an agreement that reflects the individual wishes, interests and visions of the shareholders. However, it is understood that a shareholders' agreement is subject to the approval of all the parties to it, and therefore the procedure for its conclusion must achieve a proper alignment of interests and consensus between the parties.  

This is a very important safeguard of interests, as the shareholders' interests are materially affected by the agreement. For example, the order in which the company's profits are distributed, with individually negotiated profit distribution terms, for example, if the company's turnover and profits for the financial year are greater than €X, then the shareholders of the company are allocated shares in the profits. Meanwhile, in the absence of a shareholders' agreement, disputes and disagreements between shareholders can often arise and, in the absence of a shareholders' agreement, the ability of shareholders to prove their rights or claims is hampered. 

According to lawyer Egidijus Langis, the shareholders' agreement must address the financing of the company. Shareholders' agreements on the financing of the company are particularly relevant during the periods of the company's incorporation and business development, for example, shareholders may agree on additional cash contributions to be made to finance the company or on loan agreements to be concluded. Shareholders' agreements may also be used to make arrangements for actions relevant to attracting external investment, for example by dividing and allocating the duties to be performed by shareholders in order to attract investment. 

The contract must also contain provisions on corporate governance. For example, extending the rights or powers of the company's board. In order to reduce the scope of the rights of the company's manager and thereby eliminate the possibility of arbitrary decisions that are not in the company's interests, the shareholders' agreement may set out a list of significant decisions of the business or of the company's manager that are subject to the approval of the board. A shareholders' agreement is also an effective means of avoiding a legal impasse where the shareholders of a company have the same decision-making power and pursue different ways of resolving the issue at hand. For example, two shareholders of an LLC each hold 50% of the shares of the LLC, one of the shareholders votes in favour of adopting decision A and the other shareholder votes in favour of adopting decision B. Therefore, the shareholders' agreement may preemptively provide for ways to resolve the legal impasse, for example by agreeing in a compromise way that shareholder X's vote is decisive for the appointment of the company's CEO and shareholder Y's vote is decisive for the appointment of the members of the board. 

It is also worth including in the shareholders' agreement a regulation on the sale of shares in the company. It can be agreed whether, if one of the shareholders decides to sell his shares in the company, the other shareholder has the right of first refusal to acquire the shares to be sold, and the method of calculating the price of the shares to be sold can also be agreed. It should be noted that the waiver of the shareholders' pre-emptive rights may also be provided for by the shareholders of the company in the company's articles of association.

The contractual liability of the shareholders is also very important. The shareholders may agree on the application of contractual liability of the shareholders for certain defaults, but it is important that the form and amount of such liability must not be in breach of mandatory provisions of law, public policy or good morals. Moreover, it should be noted that, according to the recent case law of the Court of Appeal of Lithuania, it is the penalties provided for in the shareholders' agreement that are the essential and most effective means of ensuring compliance with the shareholders' agreement. However, a shareholder who discovers that another shareholder has breached the shareholders' agreement must act swiftly, as such fines are subject to a six-month shortened limitation period.

The agreement should also include a clause on dispute resolution procedures. A shareholders' agreement is not only relevant for the preventive nature of avoiding shareholder disputes, but it can also provide for effective dispute resolution procedures between the parties. For example, in the case of a particularly damaged relationship between shareholders, where there is no possibility of cooperation between the parties and the likelihood of a peaceful resolution of the dispute disappears, but where the actions and conduct of the shareholders do not constitute a legitimate basis for the application of the compulsory sale of shares provided for in the Civil Code, the procedures and conditions for the compulsory redemption or sale of the shares, as negotiated in the shareholders' agreement, can provide the circumstances for a proper and effective resolution of the shareholders' dispute. The shareholders' agreement may also agree on the jurisdiction to be established for shareholders' disputes. 

A shareholders' agreement is drafted to regulate both the company's corporate governance and the relationship between shareholders, and a timely shareholders' agreement is a great preventive way to avoid legal disputes and painful divorces.

Is there a public land rent charge for a shelter under public land?

You own real estate - a warehouse, a shelter or a garden shed. However, the property is on or under public land. You have not entered into any agreement to lease the state land, but one day you receive a notice that you have not complied with your obligation to pay the rent, even though you are not the lessee of the state land. Viktorija Dubovskienė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, explains what your obligations are and what the legal framework is.

The Law on Land Reform of the Republic of Lithuania stipulates that the users of state land plots, who have been granted land plots in accordance with the procedure established by legal acts or who have been allowed to use the land by decisions of the land administering authorities during the period of the land reform, shall pay the land rental fee for the use of the land in accordance with the procedure established by the Government, before the lease or sale-purchase contracts are concluded, except for the land transferred for use. 

According to the Land Law, a land user is the owner of the land or another natural or legal person, foreign organisation, branch of a legal person or foreign organisation, who uses the land on the basis of laws, administrative acts, court decisions, transactions or other legal basis.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania, interpreting the application of the Land Reform Law, points out that the obligation to pay land rent for the use of state land arises not only from the state land lease agreement, but also from law. The Court of Cassation has noted that the actual user of the land may not obtain more privileges than the person with whom the land lease agreement is concluded.

It is therefore clear that immovable property located on State land for which no lease agreement has been concluded does not exempt the owner of the immovable property from the payment of State land rent, nor does it constitute any exception to the non-payment of the abovementioned State land rent.

The Land Reform Law establishes the obligation to pay the state land rent tax not only to those users of state land who use only the state land plot formed in accordance with the procedure established by the legislation and registered in the Real Estate Register, but also to other users of state land who use state land on a legal basis for the actual use of the state land, except for the gratuitous grant of the use - the use.

Is there a public land rent for an underground shelter?

And how would the situation be assessed if the property in question was real estate - a shelter not on public land but under it? According to the Building Act, a building is an immovable object with load-bearing structures, all of which are erected on the site of the building during construction work. According to the same law, a building is a roofed structure, the main part of which consists of premises. 

A shelter is an independent object of legal relations and is included in the concept of basic objects within the meaning of the Civil Code. Therefore, it is the shelter that does not fall within the exceptions set out in the Land Law, which prevent the lease of public land without auction.

It should also be noted that neither the above-mentioned norm of the Land Law, nor any other provisions of laws or other legal acts link the possibility of renting state land, as well as the obligation to pay the state land rent fee, with the fact whether the building is above or below ground. An underground building, like an aboveground building, requires a land plot of an appropriate size for its construction and operation. The term 'built-up' as used in the Civil Code and in the Land Law is to be interpreted as covering the use of public land when both above-ground and underground structures (buildings or installations) are built on it.

Therefore, the Court of Cassation in its practice has stated that the fact that the structures (buildings) located on state land are underground does not negate the use of state land necessary for the operation of such structures in accordance with their intended purpose and this circumstance does not constitute a reason to exempt the owner of such structures from the obligation to pay the rent of the state land.

So, whether your property is on or under state land, and whether or not you have a state land lease, the legal obligation to pay state land rent is not eliminated, and you must always comply with this legal obligation.

Transactions that don't benefit the company - when is the CEO liable?

Žygimantas Klizas, Senior Associate at AVOCAD

As one of the main bases for the creation of obligations, the conclusion of transactions is a normal part of a company's day-to-day business operations.

By entering into transactions, companies achieve their business objectives. In particular, business practice often leads to situations where, in order to develop their business, the management bodies of companies have to take risky decisions or enter into transactions that often do not work as well as planned and, consequently, cause material damage to the company or even lead to insolvency situations. Moreover, even in the face of business cycles, economic fluctuations and other factors beyond the company's direct control, a company cannot guarantee that every transaction it enters into will be economically advantageous.

In many cases, when negative consequences arise from the activities of a legal entity, the search for the guilty is often directed towards the decisions taken by the head of the company's management bodies or the members of the board of directors of the collegial management body, as well as the other actions taken by these individuals. In more than one case, this becomes part of the plan and a way to get the person in charge out from under the helm of the company.

The Civil Code of the Republic of Lithuania establishes the general duties of members of the management bodies of a legal person, otherwise known as fiduciary duties - to act honestly, reasonably, to be loyal, to observe confidentiality and to avoid conflicts of interest. It also stipulates that a member of the management body of a legal person who fails to perform or improperly performs the duties referred to in this Article or in the instruments of incorporation shall be liable to compensate the legal person in full for the damage caused, unless otherwise provided by law, the instruments of incorporation or the contract.

Civil liability requires a set of conditions set out in the law: unlawful acts of the manager (except for exceptions set out in the law), a causal link between the unlawful acts and the loss, fault on the part of the manager (except for the exceptions set out in the law or the contract), and damages. The burden of proving the totality of these conditions rests on the company or the shareholder of the company seeking civil liability, which is the shareholder's non-pecuniary right under the Law on Companies.

In disputes concerning the liability of members of the management bodies of public limited liability companies, it is recognised in case law that even if a particular business decision could lead to a loss, this does not mean that the decision was unlawful. As the Supreme Court of Lithuania has clarified in its case law, the mere fact that a transaction entered into by the company's manager turned out to be unprofitable and caused damage to the company or its creditors does not in itself provide grounds to consider the actions of the company's manager as unlawful, provided that the manager of the company has acted in good faith and with due care, has not breached any duties imposed on him by the law or the company's operating documents, and has not clearly exceeded the normal economic and commercial risk in the company's business.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania, in developing the practice of application of the liability of members of the management body of a legal person, also states that participation in business involves a risk that the decisions taken may be not only beneficial but also detrimental. If the members of the management bodies of a company were to be held personally liable for every decision that caused a loss, it would hamper their initiative and entrepreneurial spirit, limit their freedom of action in situations requiring quick and decisive decisions, and encourage shadow management of the companies. In order to protect members of a company's management bodies from damages claims, the business judgment rule applies, which presumes that they are acting in the bona fide best interests of the company they lead. This presumption is intended to protect the directors of a company from personal liability for business decisions made in good faith and in accordance with the standards of the duty of care. Therefore, it is not sufficient for the person seeking damages to prove the fact of the damage caused, but it is also necessary to prove a breach of the fiduciary duties of the members of the company's management bodies (loyalty, honesty, reasonableness, etc.), a manifest disregard of a reasonable commercial risk, a manifest negligence or an excess of powers.

It should be noted that it is the business judgment rule that ensures that the governing bodies of a legal person can take risky decisions that may lead to business development, bring about highly successful results of economic and commercial activities, and thus ensure the interests not only of the legal person but also of its shareholders. Moreover, this rule also protects the members of the management bodies of the legal person from strategic lawsuits, which are very often used in shareholder disputes as a means of exerting pressure on a shareholder who is also a member of the body of the legal person.

Thus, the question of compensation for damages is decided on a case-by-case basis, after assessing the totality of the circumstances, the reasons and motives for the respective decisions of the manager or the collegial management body, and other relevant circumstances which reveal whether the management body of the legal person has fulfilled or breached its fiduciary duties. It is precisely if it is established that a member of the management body of a legal person has breached his or her fiduciary duties by concluding a transaction that is manifestly unfavourable to the legal person and that has led to the occurrence of the damage that the manager of the legal person should be obliged to compensate for the damage caused by his or her actions.

Bonds - new market challenges and investor protection

Recently, there has been a trend towards using bonds as a new tool to raise finance. However, in many cases, investors, perhaps due to lack of experience or a reluctance to understand the situation, do not appreciate the true risks of investing in the bonds being offered. Laurynas Staniulis, Managing Partner of AVOCAD, talks more about this.

First of all, it should be understood that a bond is simply a debt security issued by a company or government. It is a document that gives the bondholder the right to call on the entity that issued the bond at the end of the bond period. The entity that issued the bond is obliged to repay the money invested. In other words, the bondholder and the issuing entity have an elementary loan relationship.

Today, we see a trend towards bonds with very high yields and relatively short duration. In fact, borrowing at such a price means that, for one reason or another, traditional means of financing, such as loans from financial institutions or investment funds, are not available. The reasons for this may be varied, but the fact remains that probably no entity will borrow at 15% when banks are lending at an average interest rate of 8-10%.

Also, looking at the current trend in bonds, we see that the bonds that are being distributed are generally not secured by collateralised real estate, but rather by a pledge of the shares of the company that issued the bond as collateral. In terms of whether such collateral provides real protection, one would have to say probably not. Since, if shares are pledged, it is likely that the issuer does not have any assets pledged or that those assets are already pledged. This means that if the worst case scenario does occur and the entity is unable to redeem the bonds, the claims of the bondholders would only be met after the claims of the mortgage lender have been met, and only then, if there is anything left over, would it be the bondholders. I would therefore probably not be very far wrong in saying that such bonds are, in essence, simply a loan without any additional security for the bondholder.

Another point to note is that bonds are often placed to refinance an existing bond issue, while the source of redemption of the new bond is a future planned bond issue. This pattern of short-term high-yield bonds implies that the bonds are not issued to finance a new activity that would directly result in a redemption source, but rather to temporarily balance cash flows, to build equity or the like.  

However, from today's perspective, can we say that when the bonds mature, the issuer will have the ability to refinance them and, if necessary, service even more expensive bonds? Probably not, which leads to the view that the bonds issued simply reflect the issuers' belief in a positive market development. But the "what if" question remains unanswered.

Sometimes the answer to this question can be deduced, albeit indirectly, from the assessment of the issuer. If the issuer is a project company that is part of a large group of companies, and the bonds are not redeemed by the "parent" company, we may consider that the "parent" company is aware of the risks of the project and is not prepared to fulfil its obligations to the bondholders at any cost. Obviously, this is only an assumption and one would like to believe that if the issuer is unable to meet its obligations, there would be a consolidation of the Group's forces to redeem the bonds. However, the reluctance to formally commit leaves the question open.

In summary, bonds are not a new way of raising funds and are certainly not a threat in themselves. Bonds, like any other investment, involve risks that each investor has to assess individually according to his or her risk appetite. However, in any case, investing in bonds should not only be based on a careful assessment of the issuer or the collateral, but also on an understanding of the objectives of the bond.

Are you in litigation with a public authority? You may still have to pay the state's lawyer's fees

Today, "I'll sue" can often seem like a good way of clarifying a relationship and, at the same time, solving a problem. Although most people are already aware of this, it is sometimes not fully appreciated that, invariably, at the end of the litigation, the losing party not only does not recover the costs of the litigation, but also has to pay for the legal costs of the lawyer of his opponent. Thus, it can often be really expensive to deal with the relationship in this way. This is the classic situation of the end of a legal dispute between two private parties, which is determined by the loser pays principle, often referred to in case law.

However, the court is always dealing with the question of the reasonableness of such costs: when a litigant claims tens of thousands of euros in legal costs, the court does not always agree - it is a very case-by-case decision. What about cases involving a public authority that uses its own lawyers? Are costs not always payable if you lose? Dainius Antanaitis, attorney at law at AVOCAD, explains more about this.

It should be understood that when a court finds that costs are unjustified, the unsuccessful party is not obliged to pay them. However, the law does not provide for a list of cases in which costs may be declared unreasonable. The unreasonableness of costs shall be determined on a case-by-case basis. For example, in a case concerning the division of property (which can be practically any other type of case, including business disputes), the costs will usually be calculated in proportion to the amount of the successful claims. I.e. if you are claiming €100,000 from your spouse and the court awards you €70,000, the costs here would be shared in a similar proportion. Here, 70% of the costs would be paid to the court. Your lawyer's costs should be reimbursed by the other party. Of course, this is a very crude example and the situations in practice are usually much more complex, but the basic calculation would be something like this.

The situation is slightly different when a private dispute involves public authorities, which have a relatively large pool of lawyers. If the public authority uses its own lawyers, the losing party does not have to pay for such legal costs. However, each institution has quite clear specificities and, for example, the lawyers of the State Planning and Building Inspectorate will not necessarily be well versed in the specifics of, say, non-pecuniary damage. Thus, in such cases, the institution may decide to hire a lawyer. Of course, this is done at the expense of the institution or, in other words, at the expense of taxpayers.

At the end of September, the Supreme Court of Lithuania issued a ruling which, among other issues, addressed the request of a public authority to pay the costs of the law firm it hired. Here, the Court noted that when deciding on the question of the award of representation costs in favour of an institution, the court must make a comprehensive assessment of whether the use of a lawyer was necessary in the light of the institution's internal administrative capacity and the nature of the case. In determining the nature of the case, account must be taken of the novelty of the legal issue raised in the case, the volume and complexity of the case. The totality of all three criteria is necessarily taken into account. It must be acknowledged that judges may see the same situation quite differently and, therefore, being principled and fair in their perception of justice, they decide on costs on the basis of their own internal conviction, which does not always coincide with that of different judges.

In the opinion of the Supreme Court of Lithuania, it is necessary to assess whether the lawyers of the institution involved in the case do not have sufficient capacity and competence to properly represent the institution in court due to the specificity, complexity or scope of the case. If, in the court's assessment, such capacity is lacking, the services and costs of the lawyer are considered reasonable and, if the institution successfully defends itself in court, the unsuccessful party must pay those costs. However, if the court were to find that the institution was able to pursue the case with the resources at its disposal and that the hiring of a lawyer was an excessive expense, even if the institution were to win the case, the costs would not be reimbursed to the State budget, as the losing party would not have to pay them.   

Mountains of unfulfilled obligations, unpaid salaries: is it time to declare bankruptcy?

This is the third time the suppliers have called - their invoice has been sitting unpaid for two months. And there is more than one such invoice. And where are the salary payments? You decide not to pick up the phone. Will that solve the problem? Hardly. But the money is gone and you don't know where to get it from, and the pile of unpaid bills on your desk keeps growing. You contact your lawyers, they assess the situation and then smile uncomfortably and say: "It's a very bad situation, you've waited too long. It looks like you will have to declare bankruptcy."

So when is it time to declare bankruptcy? Is it too early? What are the main criteria? Egidijus Langys, partner at AVOCAD, talks more about this.


What is assessed when deciding whether to declare bankruptcy?

It should be understood that a company with €100 in outstanding liabilities will certainly not be declared insolvent, even though today's legal framework would formally allow it. Thus, the criteria for assessing a company's insolvency are still relevant in court.

Assessing a company's insolvency looks at its balance sheet and liquidity ratios (balance sheet and liquidity tests), as well as its viability - in simple terms, what the company's future prospects are for meeting its obligations.

Insolvency is most often equated with a lack of working capital - delays in financing day-to-day operations, meeting creditors, paying wages, etc. It is a test of liquidity - the extent to which a company is able to operate and meet its obligations. 

The balance sheet test reveals the ratio of a company's liabilities to its assets and, importantly, the extent to which liabilities exceed assets.

The last criterion is the viability of the company, which shows how well the company is able to operate and generate profits. Case law elaborates on this criterion:

  • the causes of the company's insolvency problems;
  • the economic and commercial activities carried out by the legal person;
  • the prospects of the business, the expected income (profit) and whether it will enable the company to meet its future debts to creditors;
  • how many employees are working in the company (headcount turnover), etc.

The absence of commercial activities or the fact that the commercial activities envisaged will clearly prevent the legal persons from meeting their debts in the future raises doubts as to the viability of the company.


When is it time to declare bankruptcy?

There is always the risk that a manager will initiate insolvency proceedings prematurely. This can happen if only formal assessment criteria are assessed, if there is no experience or practice, if bad practice or examples are followed, if immediate reliance is placed on advice from oneself or from colleagues who have supposedly "been there".

Without legal advice, this situation will involve the company in legal proceedings. Filing for bankruptcy prematurely and not being declared bankrupt by the court could damage the company's business reputation, damage the company's image with its business partners, and put the company on the list of unreliable companies, even though the company is solvent and the manager has made a mistake about the company's insolvency.

Of course, it can happen that a company's insolvency process can be initiated too late. Managers often overestimate their capabilities and believe that certain circumstances will not affect the viability of the company, think that they have made a lot of effort, that the company is struggling but is still in business, and are late in applying to the court for insolvency proceedings, or do not apply at all. However, if the manager's efforts have been insignificant and the company is unable to continue to operate, the manager will face serious consequences for failing to comply with the obligation to initiate insolvency proceedings.