When does public performance of music become an offence?

Imagine you're walking down a city street, and a nearby café is playing a jazz tune, while a passer-by is blasting a popular song on his phone. Music is almost everywhere in the city, but have you ever wondered when such public performances cross the boundaries of legality?

When is music a legitimate source of joy, and when can it lead to serious consequences? Where are the limits of copyright protection and how do you avoid being listed as a copyright infringer? Rokas Puodžiūnas, lawyer at AVOCAD, answers these questions.

Musical works are protected by Copyright. Copyright objects are original literary, scientific and artistic works that are the result of creative activity expressed in some objective form.

Thus, there are two requirements for works to be protected by copyright: originality and objective form. The latter means that the work must have been created in a form (which does not necessarily have to be fixed in a tangible medium) that allows it to be perceived by others (e.g. a book that can be read, a painting, etc.). A work cannot be considered to be merely an idea that has not been realised.

The moment of creation of protection in works

Copyright protection of works starts from the moment the work is created, i.e. from the moment the work is expressed in an objective form. Whether or not the person who created the work intended it to be the subject-matter of copyright protection is irrelevant to the triggering of protection. Nor does the law require any formalities that are relevant to the emergence of protection (such as registration, special marking, recognition).

Copyright is divided into two types: personal moral rights and economic rights (also known as economic rights).

The author's moral rights are rights that have no economic content. They are intrinsically linked to the personality of the author. The purpose of these rights is to protect the author's personal interest in the work being known as he created it. Non-proprietary rights cannot be transferred to other persons.

The law establishes 3 personal moral rights:

  • authorship right - the right to claim authorship of a work by having the author's name clearly indicated on all copies of the work published, or by any other practicable means of public performance of the work;
  • the right to the author's name - the right to request that any use of the work include or exclude the author's name or a pseudonym;
  • the right to integrity of the work - the right to object to any distortion or other alteration of the work or its title, as well as to any other interference with the work which may harm the author's honour or reputation.

Copyright is the right to use the author's work. Only the author, another rightholder or his/her representative can authorise or prohibit the public use of the work in any way. Unlike in the case of moral rights, the author is entitled to receive a fair and proportionate royalty for each use of the work in relation to the author's moral rights. Economic rights can also be transferred by contract and inherited. However, economic rights are subject to a term of preservation: authors' economic rights last for the lifetime of the author and for 70 years after the author's death.

The law provides for this non-exhaustive list of property rights:

  • reproduce the work in any form or manner;
  • to publish the work;
  • translate the work;
  • adapt, arrange, stage or otherwise rework a work;
  • distributing the original or copies of the work by sale, including by public offer to buy or by targeted advertising of the original or copies of the work to encourage consumers to buy them, or renting, lending or otherwise transferring the original or copies of the work for ownership or possession, or for importing or exporting;
  • display the original or copies of the work in public;
  • perform the work publicly by any means and by any means;
  • broadcasting, retransmission and other communication of the work to the public, including making it available to the public on computer networks (the internet).

Any use of the original work or copies thereof without the permission of the author, his successor in title or his duly authorised representative is considered unlawful.

How are copyright regulations reflected in the public domain when a piece of music is released?

First of all, it should be noted that publishing music without the author's consent is not always an infringement.

The publication of music in a public space is considered a public performance of the work. A public performance is the playing, singing, playing, reciting, reading, dancing or other means of public performance of a work, either directly (live performance) or by means of any means or equipment, in any public place where an unspecified group of members of the public is present at the same time, or is likely to be present.

It is clear from this definition that a performance of a work is not only when it is performed live, but also when it is made audible to an unspecified group of members of the public by technical means.

An undefined group of members of society is understood as a group of individuals who are not bound by any strong reciprocal relationship (e.g. family; friends; classmates) and therefore cannot be defined. Therefore, playing music loudly at a private party of friends will not constitute copyright infringement.

However, playing music in a public space where any passer-by can hear it (e.g. music played over loudspeakers in a shopping mall, in restaurants; in hotel lobbies), unless the author's consent has been obtained and the author has been compensated fairly, will already be considered an infringement. For such an infringement, the author will be able to claim the cessation of the unlawful acts (if they have continued for a longer period of time) and compensation for the use of the infringing work.

How to avoid a possible infringement?

If the aim is to legally play music in a public setting in order to create a cosy atmosphere, it may seem difficult on the face of it, as you would have to agree with all the songwriters whose work you want to play, and it may be even more difficult if you want to play a foreign work. It can be even more complicated if the author and the performer of the musical work are not the same, as in such a case the copyright belongs to the author of the song, but the performer of the song owns the neighbouring rights to the performance of the song (neighbouring rights are derivative rights to the result obtained by the use of the work, i.e. performance of the work, recording of the work, the first take of a film, etc). This would entail contracts with several entities.

To this end, collecting societies exist to administer and enforce the economic rights of performers by concluding contracts with them. It is therefore more convenient for users to be able to conclude contracts for the lawful exploitation of their works with a single organisation that manages such right holders.

In Lithuania, such organisations are often heard in the public domain, such as LATGA (Lithuanian Association for the Protection of Copyrights) and AGATA (Lithuanian Association of Neighbouring Rights). As the name suggests, LATGA represents copyright holders and ensures that authors are compensated for the use of their works. AGATA ensures the rights of related rights holders by representing the interests of performers, producers of phonograms and audiovisual works.

So, if individuals want to legally use music in their activities, they need to enter into agreements with both LATGA and AGATA. Otherwise, an infringement of the law is being committed, for which appropriate legal consequences may be imposed.

Donate to charities instead of expensive gifts for customers

Luxury Christmas gifts for customers are becoming obsolete. Companies are increasingly choosing to donate to charities and support organisations instead of giving gifts to customers. According to Sandra Masevičienė, Head of Fundraising at the association "Raudonos Nosys Gydytojai klounai", such donations are often transformed into long-term cooperation and team-building activities.

"We try to maintain a warm relationship with partners who believe in the power of good emotions and want to contribute to the emotional change that clowns create. Long-term friendships are not just one-way, it's a two-way street. Companies give financial support, become ambassadors - spreading the good word in the public space, within the company. Meanwhile, Red Noses contributes to the emotional well-being of its partners' employees. We have formats specifically for companies - our speakers conduct clowning workshops, we give presentations on the effects of humour, and we create the opportunity to experience the clown effect by organising clown visits to companies. Over the 14 years of our activity, our circle of supporters has been growing and it is gratifying that more and more people are appreciating the importance of emotional hygiene and, at the same time, the presence of medical clowns in the places where it would seem uncomfortable to laugh," shares S. Masevičienė.

According to Egidijus Langis, Managing Partner of AVOCAD, the budget for client gifts has been allocated to those who need it the most for several years in a row. "This year, we decided to join the mission of medical clowns and give smiles to sick children and the elderly. A smile helps us to overcome difficulties and the ability to laugh at the most difficult situations only shows how strong we are," says the lawyer.

According to Egidijus Langis, giving and supporting not only gives a sense of good work, but also brings the team together, and sometimes it turns into a very fun experience and frees you from the constraints of your professional life. "The legal profession is particularly bound by ethical norms and societal stereotypes. And we ourselves often get so caught up in our daily work, the competitive environment and the routine of applying the law that we forget our true values. Collaborating with the clown doctors reminded us that the beauty of life starts with a smile, which inspires others to be happy, and that all it takes is sincere attention", says Langys, introducing the joint video project.

"According to Red Noses, the amount of corporate donations varies from €50 to €20 000, with the average amount being around €300. All the funds go towards creating emotional change in children's hospitals, homes for the elderly and refugee centres. The red nose is the smallest mask in the world and can absorb sadness, bitterness, anger like a sponge... It's probably why it's so soft. And it can also create the cutest smile or the loudest laugh for everyone in the room to hear. "Red Nose Doctors Clowns has been running for 14 years and has delighted more than 220,000 Lithuanian children and seniors.

AVOCAD and RAUDONOS NOSYS video greeting here

 

The prohibition on the Court of Appeal ruling against a worse decision - what's worth knowing about it?

In the Lithuanian legal system, one of the fundamental values of justice is to ensure a fair and just trial. Of particular importance here is the principle of "non reformatio in peius", which ensures that a person who has appealed against a decision of a court of first instance does not suffer worse consequences simply because he or she has exercised his or her right to appeal. According to Domantas Velykis, a lawyer at AVOCAD, this principle is particularly relevant in criminal proceedings as well as in civil and administrative cases.

For example, in a criminal case, if the court of first instance sentenced a person to 2 years' imprisonment and the person appealed against the decision, the Court of Appeal may refer the case back to the trial court. However, even in that case, the court of first instance may not, on the basis of the above-mentioned principle, impose a sentence more severe than 2 years, unless expressly requested to do so by another party to the proceedings, such as the prosecutor. This principle protects the appellant from the negative consequences that could result from the mere exercise of the right to appeal.

AVOCAD's lawyer says that this regulation guarantees the appellant's right to appeal against a decision of the court of first instance that he considers unjust, without fear that the appellate court will make his position worse than that of the court of first instance.

"In assessing whether there has been a breach of this principle in relation to the appellant, it is necessary to establish whether the decision was worse than the one complained of. A decision which is more restrictive of a person's rights, more burdensome, etc., may be regarded as inferior. Importantly, this prohibition only applies when only one party to the proceedings appeals against the decision of the court of first instance," points out Mr Velykis

According to the lawyer, in civil proceedings, the exceptions to the prohibition of an inferior decision in the court of appeal must be interpreted very narrowly and can only be applied in those cases where a substantial public interest established in the particular case clearly so requires, in particular if the proceedings in the court of appeal are terminated without referring back to the court of first instance for a fresh decision.

The legal framework provides that the limits of an appeal may be exceeded only where the public interest so requires and the rights and legitimate interests of a person, society or the State would be prejudiced if the appeal were not exceeded.

"The position of the court practice is that the mere fact that the court of first instance misapplied legal norms when adopting the procedural decision appealed against cannot, by itself, justify either overstepping the limits of the appeal, or, consequently, worsening the appellant's legal position in the court of appeal," emphasises Domantas Velykis.

However, according to the lawyer, it is important that the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Lithuania has clarified that the appellate court must not be limited by the limits of the appeal in such a way that its decision would be fundamentally unfair and that this would violate constitutional values. The principle of proportionality is therefore also very important here.

It is important to note that the case-law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania did not consider as a violation of the prohibition to adopt a worse judgment a situation where both parties to the proceedings lodged appeals, but one of the parties contested only the allocation of the costs of the proceedings, and the Court of Appeal reversed the decision of the Court of First Instance, even though the party that had contested the allocation of the costs of the proceedings had not raised such a claim, but did not disagree with the conclusions of the Court of First Instance, which led to the relevant decision on the allocation of the costs of proceedings, i.e. it also put forward arguments as to why the judgment of the Court of First Instance is not, in principle, correct.

The prohibition against an appellant being adversely affected is relevant to all parties to the proceedings, both in considering the future strategy of the case and the arguments and claims to be put forward in the preparation of the appeals, and in assessing the judgments of the courts of appeal and the possibility of bringing cassation appeals on the basis of a breach of this principle. "This principle is particularly important in protecting individuals from possible abuse of the judicial system or disproportionate decisions. Knowledge and understanding of this principle is important not only for legal professionals, but also for all members of society, as it helps to ensure confidence in the legal system and encourages active participation in legal processes. Only an informed and aware citizenry can effectively defend its rights and contribute to strengthening the rule of law," he stresses.

 

Termination of the employment contract when the employee's job function becomes redundant for the employer: how can the employer avoid mistakes and the employee protect his rights?

Changes in work organisation are an inevitable reality of modern business. Economic crises, technological advances or changes in the way a company operates can lead to situations where certain job functions performed by employees become redundant for the employer. In such cases, the Labour Code (" LC") gives the employer the right to terminate the employment contract, but this right is limited by strict rules. Commenting on such situations, Laura Jodeliukaitė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, stresses that dismissal of employees in such cases must be carried out with the utmost care and responsibility, as non-compliance with the rules may result in legal disputes and significant financial losses for the employer.

Grounds for and substance of termination of employment

The LC provides that an employer has the right to terminate an employment contract if the employee's job function becomes redundant for the employer due to changes in the organisation of the work or other reasons related to the employer's activities.

Thus, changes in work organisation or other reasons related to the employer's activities may make the work function performed by the employee redundant for the employer, i.e. the employer's need for the employee's work changes and the work function performed by the employee becomes superfluous.

This could be the case when a company introduces a new technology that allows the automation of certain functions. This technological change may reduce the need for certain job functions because these functions are performed faster and more efficiently by the new technology. For example, a company implements an automated customer service platform that is able to answer common questions and solve simple problems. In such cases, the need for customer service agents may be reduced as these tasks are efficiently performed by the system.

A job function performed by an employee may be considered redundant if the employer abandons the job function entirely or decides that the same or similar functions can be performed by fewer employees in order to optimise resources, etc.

The reasons for terminating an employee's contract, which are linked to the employer's activities, can be both internal (reorganisation of the work organisation, optimisation of the resources available, etc.) and external (economic or other external reasons where the employer decides to reduce the cost of the company's activities, etc.).

Conditions for dismissal of redundant staff

Termination of an employment contract when the work function performed by the employee becomes superfluous for the employer will only be lawful if certain conditions are met.

First, the changes in work organisation or other reasons related to the employer's activities are real and make the job function performed by the worker (or group of workers) redundant.

If the employee challenges the lawfulness of his dismissal, the employer will have to prove that:

  • changes in work organisation or other reasons related to the employer's activities are real;
  • these are the reasons why a particular job function performed by a particular worker (or group of workers) is redundant (the reason is directly causally linked to the fact that the job function performed by the worker has become redundant for the employer).

However, termination will be considered unlawful if the employer's structural/organisational changes turn out to be a sham.

A fictitious reason for termination of employment can be, for example, if a new person is hired to replace an employee after the dismissal. A similar situation may arise where an employer abolishes a post but soon creates a new post with identical or very similar functions. This would indicate that the employer's reasons given for the redundancy of the job function were unfounded, as the job function performed by the employee was not in fact redundant, and may have been intended to justify the termination of the contract of employment of a particular employee.

Second, the staff selection criteria are met

Where a redundant job function is performed by a number of employees but the employer plans to make only some of them redundant, it is necessary to establish and apply clear criteria for selecting employees. These criteria must be used to decide which employees will be retained and which will be made redundant.

Criteria for selecting redundant workers must be agreed with the workers' representatives

The employer adopts the criteria for selecting the workers to be made redundant, but these must be agreed with the works council or, in the absence of a works council, with the trade union. The selection for dismissal is carried out by a specially appointed committee of the employer, which also makes proposals for dismissal. If neither a works council nor a trade union is established, the employer shall not set up a panel and shall decide on the selection criteria and carry out the selection of the employees itself.

Staff members with a right of first refusal to remain

The selection criteria for redundancies must ensure the right of preference of certain workers to remain in employment. For example, priority for job retention is given to workers who are less than three years away from retirement pension age, who have three or more children under the age of 14 or who are raising a child under the age of 14 on their own, as well as in other cases provided for in the LC. The right of preference applies only if the worker's qualifications are not inferior to those of other workers of the same specialisation employed by the undertaking (except for the exception provided for in the LC).

In addition, the employment contract cannot be terminated in the case of a pregnant worker, workers with children under the age of three, or in other cases provided for by law.

Thirdly, the dismissed worker must be offered a vacancy

The employer must offer the dismissed worker other vacancies, if any. The first vacancies to be offered shall be those which are appropriate to the employee's occupation, qualifications and, where appropriate, medical condition. If there are no such vacancies, or if the worker refuses to take them, any other job which the worker could perform in accordance with his abilities and state of health may be offered. The employer is not obliged to offer jobs for which the worker is not suitably qualified or does not meet the other requirements for the vacancy.

The employment contract can only be terminated if there are no vacancies in the workplace during the notice period (up to five working days before the end of the notice period), to which the employee can be transferred with his/her consent.

Fourth, the time limits for giving notice of impending dismissal are met

The employer must comply with the statutory notice periods. If the employment relationship lasts for more than one year, the employee must be given one month's notice of dismissal. If the employment relationship lasts less than a year, the notice period is two weeks. It should be noted that longer notice periods apply to vulnerable groups of workers.

The dismissed worker is also entitled to severance pay. If the employment relationship has lasted less than one year, the payment is half of his average salary. If the employment relationship lasted more than one year, the amount of the payment shall be equal to two times his average salary.

Termination of an employment contract, when the employee's job function becomes redundant for the employer, is a complex process that requires special attention and care from the employer. Compliance with all legal requirements and procedures can reduce the risk of legal disputes, protect workers' rights and avoid financial losses due to unfair dismissal.

 

 

 

After the tragic loss of a loved one due to the fault of another, it is essential to deal carefully with compensation issues 

Life is varied, not only in its joys and sorrows, but also in the extremely painful events that have lifelong consequences. Dainius Antanaitis, attorney at AVOCAD, discusses the issues of damages and loss of earnings in very painful cases where a spouse is killed in a traffic accident due to the fault of the other .

According to the lawyer, it is natural that, in the state of mind caused by such an event, the relatives of the deceased, including the spouse, are least concerned about the legal aspects of the consequences caused by the perpetrator. "However, these issues have to be dealt with very carefully. And here I would like to draw attention not to the criminal proceedings against the perpetrator who caused the accident, but to the damage caused by the death of the spouse who was not at fault for the accident," says Dainius Antanaitis.

The death caused by a road accident normally results in both material and non-material damage to the person whose spouse has been killed, which must be covered by the compulsory third-party liability insurance of the perpetrator's motor vehicle. As regards damage to property, it should be noted that it is usually understood as destruction or damage to property, loss, expenses. For example, this could be funeral expenses. However, here the lawyer reminds us of another type of property damage - loss of income.

The case law on the loss of income of a spouse due to the death of the other spouse in a road accident is quite detailed and very broad, says Dainius Antanaitis, but the key points to be aware of are:

  • Civil liability is generally imposed for damage caused, but civil liability can also be imposed for future damage that can be proven;
  • the established case-law and the presumption in law that the deceased spouse has contributed to the maintenance of the family, it can reasonably be assumed that the surviving spouse loses the share of the future income that would have accrued to the surviving spouse had the other spouse not died;
  • the loss of income is calculated as follows: determine how long the deceased spouse would have been expected to live according to the average life expectancy of the person as published by the Department of Statistics and add together the deceased spouse's total average monthly earnings and any monthly pensions he or she would have received until the end of his or her expected life expectancy, and divide the result by half.

"In simple terms, the spouse of the person killed in the accident has the right to claim from the perpetrator's compulsory third-party motor insurance ½ of the income that the deceased spouse would have earned if he or she had not been killed, i.e. up to the end of the average life expectancy," notes the AVOCAD lawyer.

However, Dainius Antanaitis, a lawyer, points out that if a middle-income earner is killed in a road accident 10 years before retirement, for example, adding up all the earnings up to the age of retirement, plus the pensions he would have received up to the end of his life expectancy, and then dividing it by two, would give a quite significant sum. Not only that, but if you add the amount of non-pecuniary damages on top of that, which can also be quite significant, the insurer may have to pay quite a lot of money to the spouse of the victim.

Naturally, insurance companies don't always pay the amount demanded without agreeing to it or part of it. In this case, the injured party should seek justice in court. "Neither the person nor the insurer can be 100% sure which way the scales of justice will tip in any particular case. Therefore, litigation does not sound attractive to either of them. And here the insurer can offer a "compromise". For example, an agreement whereby the insurer agrees to pay a solid amount of non-pecuniary damages, but in this agreement the person already refuses to claim another solid amount from the insurer - the loss of earnings," the lawyer points out an important legal point.

He said that, although case law makes it reasonable to conclude that a person is likely to recover both consequential damages and loss of earnings, a risk-averse person may choose to take the sparrow's hand by signing a contract with the insurer to resolve the issue permanently.

However, it happens that a person may realise that signing the contract was a mistake, which may have been due to a variety of reasons (e.g. emotional experiences due to the death of their spouse, lack of knowledge, etc.) and that the loss of income, which they would probably have been able to claim, is very much needed in the household and in the various life worries that they have been left with alone after the death of their spouse.

Therefore, the lawyer says, it is important to think carefully before deciding whether to sign such a compromise agreement with the insurer and to consult a lawyer if you still have doubts.

What can you do to protect yourself from unfair competition? 

Around 14-16 thousand new legal entities are registered in Lithuania every year. For example, in 2023, 15.7 thousand new companies were registered, the highest number in the last 25 years.

Not to mention those who provide a range of services on a self-employed basis. Competition is fierce, professionals have a lot of choice and often migrate between different companies in the same field in search of a change, a higher salary or a friendlier team. In many cases, the newcomer not only has specific knowledge of the competitors' company and its characteristics, but also a close relationship with the clients of the former employer.

They are particularly welcome by competitors, even though they may not realise that they are unfairly competing with their previous employer or giving the new employer the opportunity to do so. Jonas Zaronskis , Partner at AVOCAD, tells us what company information is protected by law and what an employer can do to protect itself against unfair competition .

What company information is protected by law?

In a company, some information is usually protected by law (e.g. trade secrets) and the rest is protected by special agreements and contracts. Trade secrets are confidential data which are specific and highly significant and the use of which could in any way prejudice the rights and legitimate interests of the rightful owner of the information. Even after the termination of the employment relationship, a business secret is protected for a period of time in accordance with the law and may not be used for any purpose. According to case-law, information is considered to be a trade secret if it meets three requirements: secrecy, value (commercial value) and whether reasonable steps have been taken to preserve the information. Thus, company managers should bear in mind that the more valuable the particular information constituting a trade secret is, the more intensive the actions taken by the owner of the information to protect it must be in order for the protection to be considered reasonable.

It is very important to note that, according to case law, a company's customer list is also a trade secret. Customer data is to be protected as a trade secret if it contains information other than the name of the customer that is not available to the public, such as contact persons, decision makers, business practices, technical information to assist in the operation of the business, service and quality requirements, planned projects, solvency etc. Thus, if you leave your job and take your former employer's customers with you, you may face significant legal consequences.

Agreements on confidential information

In some cases, companies choose to include in the employment contract or in a separate agreement certain data and conditions that are treated as confidential information within the company. The agreement on the protection of confidential information must specify the data constituting the confidential information, the duration of the agreement on the protection of confidential information, and the employer's obligations to assist the employee in maintaining the confidentiality of this information. The employer and the employee may agree in the agreement on penalties for non-performance or improper performance of the agreement. The agreement on the protection of confidential information shall be valid for a period of one year after the termination of the employment relationship, unless the parties to the employment contract agree on a longer period.

When signing these types of agreements, company directors should bear in mind that the court assesses not only whether the specific confidentiality agreement has been respected, but also whether the information included in the agreement was sufficiently important and whether sufficient care was taken to preserve that information.

In practice, the terms "business secret" and "confidential information" are often used synonymously, but the relationship between these types of information is relevant for the purposes of deciding on the consequences of the disclosure or use of such information. In essence, a trade secret is a type of confidential information, but confidential information is not necessarily protected as a trade secret. An obligation to protect confidential information normally exists where it is provided for in a contract.

Is it better to patent the information or hide it as a trade secret?

However, there are two ways to protect information - you can hide it (e.g. trade secrets, confidentiality agreements, etc.) or you can make it public (e.g. patents).

As a way of protecting information, a trade secret has a number of significant advantages: the information does not have to be disclosed to anyone (e.g. registered in public registers); it is not subject to strict formal requirements (e.g. novelty, originality); etc. In addition, legal protection of trade secrets is open-ended.

So why patent information that could already be a trade secret? Trade secrets have several drawbacks: there is always the possibility that another entity will discover or create the trade secret information on its own, there is also the possibility that the information will be disclosed to another entity in a legitimate attempt to reproduce it (e.g. by trying to replicate the recipe of a drink), and there is the possibility that the trade secret may be disclosed inadvertently or intentionally.

A patent ensures that only you can make, sell or otherwise use the invention. So only you will make a profit from selling and using it. This protects the money you have invested in the invention, and you can always demand that competitors do not use the invention and pay damages. However, the owner of the invention can only enjoy this exclusive right for 20 years. Since a patent is only valid for 20 years and a trade secret is protected indefinitely, very exclusive products, such as the recipe for a Coca-Cola drink, are protected by trade secrets and not by patents.

So basically, the way you choose to protect information depends on the information itself, its importance and even the nature of your business.

 

 

Car depreciation after an accident - a claim against the insurer that few people know about 

Having your car damaged in a traffic accident is not a pleasant experience. Fortunately, if the damage is limited to property, compulsory motor third party liability insurance usually saves you from financial loss. However, according to lawyers, not everyone is aware that not only the cost of repairing the car, but also the loss of its market value, can be claimed from the insurance company.

According to Eimantas Čepas, an attorney at AVOCAD, the amount of damage to a car in a traffic accident is usually understood as the cost of repairs. "However, when buying or selling a car, a lot of attention is paid to whether or not the car has been involved in an accident in the past and whether or not it has been cleaned up, and if the accident is confirmed, the aim is to negotiate the price of the car," the lawyer points out.

Therefore, according to Eimantas Čeps, it should not be forgotten that there is another form of damage - the loss of the car's market value due to the damage sustained in the accident. "And this is not just the negotiating position of the seller or buyer of the car, but the amount clearly determined in accordance with the criteria laid down by law," the lawyer stresses.

According to the legislation in force in Lithuania, loss in marketable value is defined as the irreversible reduction in the value of a vehicle due to repairs, painting or unrepaired damage (when parts of the vehicle are technologically repaired to restore their functional characteristics, where the technological process of repair may affect the physical, chemical, aesthetic condition or service life of the item), including the change in the vehicle's history as a result of an event, compared to the vehicle's value before the damage.

As with ordinary damages, the loss of resale value must be covered by the perpetrator's liability insurance. "Unfortunately, there is no clear indication in the existing legal framework that the victim of a traffic accident has the right to claim from the insurer also for the loss of market value", notes AVOCAD's lawyer.

He says that, taking advantage of the lack of information, not all insurance companies offer to compensate the victim for the loss of the car's trade value due to the repair work, in addition to the usual compensation. "If they do offer compensation for loss of value, the amount offered is not always calculated objectively. Therefore, even if the insurer's offer is accepted, it would be worthwhile to have an independent appraiser's report, as the amount of compensation for the loss of marketable value can be quite significant and can be calculated in thousands of euros," notes Čepas.

However, according to the lawyer, it should be noted that loss of marketable value is calculated for vehicles up to 5 years after the first registration. "As this compensation is calculated for relatively new cars, which means that the value of the cars is correspondingly higher, the amount of compensation can often be quite significant", the lawyer notes.

According to the current legal framework, the amount of damage caused to property in a traffic accident is determined by the responsible insurer on the basis of reports by authorised persons and property valuation reports, documents proving the circumstances, the fact and the amount of the damage, photographs and video recordings.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania emphasises the insurer's duty to assess all documents submitted to it and to evaluate all circumstances, including the documents submitted by the injured third party to prove the amount of the damage, in order to determine the amount of the damage in such a way that the injured party is fully compensated for the damage, to the extent permitted by the rules governing compulsory civil liability insurance.

The principle of full compensation requires that, as far as is objectively possible, the damage caused to a person should be determined on an individual rather than standardised basis.In the event of a dispute as to the amount of the insurance benefit between the person claiming the insurance benefit and the insurer who has insured the civil liability of the driver of the vehicle by compulsory insurance, the amount of the insurance benefit must be proved in each individual case.

To sum up, in order to ensure fair compensation after an accident, it is important not only to rely on the insurance company's offer, but also to be vigilant and proactive in defending your rights - not forgetting the possibility of claiming compensation for the loss of the car's marketable value, and, if necessary, to seek the advice of independent experts who can help you to assess the damage in an objective way and make sure that you receive the full amount of compensation you are entitled to.

Important reminder from the Supreme Court of Lithuania to natural persons in bankruptcy

Bankruptcy of natural persons has existed in Lithuania for more than a decade. It gives people in financial difficulties the chance to start their lives afresh. A lot of practice has been accumulated over this time, but according to lawyers, bankrupts often forget the basics, with very painful consequences.

Commenting on the recent case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania, Egidijaus Langys, Managing Partner of AVOCAD, reminds that one of the essential duties of a natural person who intends to initiate bankruptcy proceedings is to inform creditors about the intention to initiate a bankruptcy proceeding of a natural person.

According to the lawyer, the fulfilment of this obligation is important in several respects:

Firstly, it should be in the natural person's own interest to inform creditors about his/her bankruptcy proceedings, as only the outstanding claims of creditors as set out in the natural person's solvency plan will be written off when the natural person's bankruptcy proceedings are closed.

Second, creditors have the right to submit to the insolvency administrator, within the time limit set by the court, their claims arising before the date of the opening of the natural person's insolvency proceedings. Creditors may exercise this right only if they have been informed of the natural person's bankruptcy proceedings.

"Therefore, a person seeking to restore his or her solvency has a duty to be proactive and to keep all creditors properly informed and to indicate the pending proceedings in respect of the claims brought by creditors," points out Egidijus Langys.

According to the lawyer, the write-off of creditors' claims upon the termination of the insolvency proceedings of a natural person is a specific statutory ground for the termination of an obligation. The obligation is extinguished when the insolvency proceedings of the natural person are closed.

"It is very important to understand that when a natural person's insolvency proceedings are closed, only the outstanding claims of creditors listed in the natural person's solvency plan are written off. In other words, only the claims of those creditors who have been informed of the bankruptcy proceedings are written off," notes Langys.

Consequently, other creditors' claims which arose before the opening of the insolvency proceedings against the natural person but were not included in the insolvency plan, or which arose after the opening of the insolvency proceedings against the natural person, do not automatically expire. It is therefore in the debtor's own interest to name all potential creditors. This is because, at a later stage, after the natural person's insolvency proceedings have been closed, creditors will be able to make claims in accordance with the law and can be enforced against the natural person after the natural person's insolvency has been closed.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania has clearly and unequivocally absolutized the debtor's duty in the context of the protection of the creditors' interests and has stated that the relevant circumstance is not whether the creditor knew or should have known of the debtor's bankruptcy proceedings, but whether the natural person seeking bankruptcy was active in such proceedings and duly fulfilled the statutory obligation of the bankruptcy court to inform the debtor of his/her property claims brought in other proceedings.

It is therefore very important to remind both natural persons themselves and their advisors that all possible creditors must be informed of the intention to initiate insolvency proceedings. If bankruptcy proceedings have already been opened, to the court, and to the court of the proceedings in other cases.

"Otherwise, the only person left to blame is himself, because not all debts that could have been written off were written off at the end of the insolvency process," stresses Egidijus Langys.

(Civil case No 3K-3-191-381/2024 of 24 October 2024)

 

Is it possible to choose Lithuanian law for an employment contract with a foreign company?

 

Thanks to the Covid-19 pandemic, society has discovered the benefits of teleworking. Many employers and employees still choose teleworking, or at least a hybrid model, today. Many people living in Lithuania, taking advantage of teleworking opportunities, also conclude employment contracts with employers based and operating in foreign countries, but actually working remotely from Lithuania.

It is usual for an employer to draw up an employment contract in accordance with its national law. Usually, the employment contract is drafted in the national language of the employer, the employment contract refers to the labour law rules of the employer's country, and the working time, wages, holidays, termination and other conditions of employment are also set out in the contract in accordance with the national law of the country of the employer. However, since such employment contracts go beyond the borders of a single State, the question naturally arises: should the employment relationship arising from such contracts nevertheless be governed by the labour law of the Republic of Lithuania, from which the employee actually performs his/her work functions, since that is where the employee works and lives?

Sandra Mickienė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, comments on the cases in which the law of the Republic of Lithuania may apply and what it depends on.

To discuss the situation, let's take the United Kingdom as an example, i.e. let's imagine that an employment contract is concluded between an employee (a permanent resident of the Republic of Lithuania) who performs his/her work functions remotely from Lithuania and a company established in the United Kingdom and operating in the United Kingdom, which does not have a branch or any other structural unit in Lithuania, and which carries out its activities in the country of its own (the United Kingdom). This could be administrative work, which employees can do by accessing the employer's internal systems and communicating with management and employees by electronic means.

According to the lawyer, when concluding an employment contract, the parties have the option of specifying in the contract which country's law will apply to the employment relationship between them. However, in many cases the employment contract does not specify the applicable law (even the model form of employment contract approved by the Minister of Social Security and Labour does not contain such a provision). Although a contract with an employer established and operating in the United Kingdom is likely to be drafted in English and to refer to the national law of the United Kingdom, this does not mean that any employment relationship between the employee and the employer would automatically be governed by the law of the United Kingdom, as the employment relationship is a bi-national one.

The Labour Code provides that if the parties to an employment contract have not chosen the law applicable to the employment relationship, it is governed by the law of the country in which the employment contract is regularly performed. According to the commentary to the Labour Code, the key criterion here is the permanent place of work, which means the place where (from which) the employee actually performs his/her duties.

AVOCAD's lawyer points out that despite the fact that the employer is established and operates in the United Kingdom, Lithuanian law should apply to the relations between the parties in accordance with this provision of the Labour Code. However, the Labour Code also provides for exceptions to this rule: if the employee is not permanently employed in one State, the law of the State in which the employer or the employer's place of work is situated applies. Both the first and the second rules also do not apply if, by reason of the substance of the contract of employment and the circumstances in which it was concluded and performed, the employment relationship is more closely connected with another State.

The Labour Code does not clarify when an employment relationship is deemed to be more closely connected to one or another country, but, in the light of case law, the following may be considered as circumstances that may indicate a connection to one particular jurisdiction: nationality of the parties to the contract or their belonging to a particular jurisdiction, the language of the contract, the place of conclusion and performance of the contract, the currency of the contract, the place of settlement of the disputes, the terminology used, the reference to the applicable collective agreements, etc. In addition, the country in which the worker is taxed on his income, where he is covered by social security and the relevant pension, sickness and disability insurance schemes are also relevant considerations.

"Thus, if the parties have not defined the applicable law in the employment contract, the totality of the circumstances would lead to a decision as to which country the employment relationship is more closely connected with and the national law of that country should prevail," says S. Mickienė.

If the parties choose the law applicable to the employment relationship, the law chosen would prevail. However, even if the choice of applicable law is made (if the employer is based in the UK, UK law would most likely be chosen), such an employment contract could still be subject to the mandatory provisions of the LR's employment law.

According to Ms Mickienė, the Labour Code itself does not specify which mandatory provisions should be applied when the choice of applicable law is made in a contract. However, according to the general provisions of the Labour Code, mandatory provisions are considered to be laws, regulations or collective agreements and arbitration awards which have been declared generally applicable and which cannot be derogated from by agreement of the parties under the law of the applicable State.

"Such provisions would cover all the provisions of the legislation governing employment relations that govern the conclusion, performance and termination of the employment contract and cannot be derogated from by agreement between the parties, i.e. the legislation does not provide for the possibility of an agreement to the contrary," she says.

These include: maximum working hours and minimum rest periods; the duration of minimum paid annual leave; pay, including increased pay for overtime, night work, rest and public holidays; working conditions for temporary workers; occupational safety and health; safety at work for persons under 18, pregnant workers, workers who have recently given birth or are breastfeeding; prohibition of discrimination at work; conclusion and termination of employment contracts, etc.

It should be noted that the mandatory provisions of Lithuanian labour law would only apply if the provisions of the United Kingdom's labour law in the same areas (e.g. termination of employment rules, etc.) would give the employee less protection than the provisions of Lithuanian labour law.

Advice for employees and employers

"When concluding employment contracts that cross national borders, we would recommend making sure they specify which country's law will apply to the employment relationship between the parties. This reduces the likelihood of potential disputes and also provides a clear agreement that the law chosen by the parties will apply to at least the majority of situations," emphasises an AVOCAD lawyer.

If, at the time of conclusion of the employment contract, the totality of the circumstances and facts shows that the employment contract is more likely to be related to Lithuania, i.e. to the country from which the employee will actually perform his/her work functions (e.g., taxes on the employee's salary will be paid in Lithuania, the employee will be covered by a social security scheme in Lithuania, the employee's work functions will be related to Lithuania, etc. If the employee's functions are related to Lithuania, i.e. the employee will provide services to Lithuanian residents, or the employee will perform physical work in Lithuania and not just connect to the employer's internal systems, etc.), it is advisable to conduct an analysis of the mandatory provisions of the labour law of both countries and to ensure that the employee is subject to the mandatory provisions of the labour law of the country that provides for a greater protection of the employee's rights and interests.

"Although we have discussed the case of an employment contract with an employer in a non-EU country, very similar rules would apply in the case of an employment contract with an employer established and operating in an EU country," she points out.

How do I move a road easement on your land?

A road easement has been established on your land to give your neighbour, who lives on the adjacent land, access to his land. What if you think that you would like to build a pantry, for example, on the site where the road easement is located, and you want to relocate the road easement, but your neighbour has already made improvements and invested a considerable amount of money to create them.

Viktorija Dubovskienė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, explains what your obligations are and what legal regulations apply to such a situation.

First of all, she said, it is important to know that the Constitution enshrines an important principle of the inviolability of property. "In interpreting this principle, the Constitutional Court has stated that the inviolability and protection of property means that the owner has the right to own, use and dispose of property belonging to him or her, as well as the right to demand that other persons do not violate these rights, and the state has the duty to defend and protect property against unlawful encroachment," Dubovsienė points out.

To address the situation described above, the remedies for the owner of the land on whose land the road easement is established are set out in the Civil Code. According to the legal framework laid down therein, the method to be applied in order to protect the rights of the owner depends on how the infringement of the rights of the owner of the object is manifested. "If the violation of the owner's rights does not involve loss of possession, which is what we have in the situation described here, and if it is not possible to reach an agreement with the neighbour, an action for the elimination of the violation of the right of ownership that does not involve loss of possession - a non-generative action - should be brought," she stresses.

The owner's right to bring a non-statutory action is also enshrined in the Civil Code. Under it, the owner can demand the removal of any violation of his or her right, even if it does not entail loss of possession.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania has stated that when bringing a non-statutory action, the claimant must prove two things:

  • that he is the owner of the property;
  • that his rights have been violated.

According to AVOCAD's lawyer, it will not be difficult to prove that the plaintiff is the owner of the property in the above situation. However, the burden of proof will shift to the second point - that the rights of the owner are violated by the established road easement. Let us assume that, in these factual circumstances, the landowner considers that the neighbour's landscaping, including but not limited to the neighbour's gates, fence, trees, tuyas, etc., are a nuisance and that the owner is prevented from using the part of the land occupied by these objects in the part of the road easement.

In such a case, the non-statutory action is brought to protect a subjective property right of a specific person. In the case of a non-statutory action, the subject-matter of the action (the claims asserted) may be:

  • put an end to the infringement of the applicant's subjective property rights;
  • to restore the situation prior to the infringement of the applicant's subjective property right;
  • prohibit any future infringement of the applicant's subjective property rights.

However, in this situation, the Supreme Court of Lithuania pointed out and clarified that the legislator does not directly link the violation of the rights of the owner of the land plot related to the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot related to the infringement of the requirements of the legislation by the violation of the rights of the owner of the land plot in relation to the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the rights of the owner of the land plot by the infringement of the requirements of the legislation. Therefore, in order to be able to succeed in a non-compulsory action for the protection of a subjective property right, the infringement of which is attributable to trees, shrubs or other plants growing on the adjacent land close to the boundary of the parcel or on the boundary of the parcels of land, the claimant must, inter alia, prove that his subjective property right has been violated. The fact that it is established in a case that trees, shrubs or other plants are growing on the boundary of the parcels or on adjacent land at distances from the boundary of the parcel which do not comply with the legal provisions does not constitute a ground for declaring that the applicant's subjective right of ownership has been infringed.

Thus, according to the lawyer, it is not enough, when bringing a claim in a non-statutory action, to specify only the objects which, according to the claimant, prevent him from using the object for its intended purpose. It is then necessary to show how those objects infringe his rights.