Legal representation: what do you need to know about powers of attorney?

Imagine: you're on holiday in another country and you have an important contract to sign in Lithuania. Or your grandmother can't go to the bank or do the paperwork herself because of health problems. A friend asks you to help him sell his flat because he lives abroad. According to lawyers, there is only one solution to these situations - power of attorney. A power of attorney is a written document that gives someone the right to carry out legal acts on behalf of another person. Rokas Puodžiūnas, a lawyer at AVOCAD, points out that although it is a convenient and frequently used tool, it is important to know the basic rules of the power of attorney in order for it to work smoothly and avoid mistakes.

First of all, the will of one person (the principal) is sufficient to constitute a power of attorney. "The consent of the representative is not required for the power of attorney to be issued and take effect. The chosen representative is not obliged to fulfil the obligations entrusted to him or her, and the law gives the representative the right to refuse the power of attorney issued to him or her," the lawyer points out.

The principal who issues the power of attorney is called the attorney-in-fact and the agent who receives the power of attorney is called the agent. The power of attorney specifies the specific acts to be performed by the principal on behalf of the agent with respect to a third party.

The rights conferred on a representative can only be confirmed by a power of attorney issued by the representative, so the representative must produce the power of attorney to third parties when performing any act on behalf of the principal.

The lawyer also points out that powers of attorney must specify the precise rights conferred on the authorised person. "The law does not allow the abstract content of rights to be specified. For example, it is not possible to state that the power of attorney covers all possible legal acts. The power of attorney must contain an exhaustive and detailed list of the rights to be granted," says Puodžiūnas. Similarly, a power of attorney cannot be granted for rights that can only be exercised personally (e.g. marriage, making a will, establishing usufruct over an object).

Powers of attorney vary from one-off to more powerful. For ease of understanding, they are classified according to the extent of the rights they confer:

  • A single (ordinary) mandate is one that is intended for one specific act. For example, if you need to sign a contract for the sale of a car and you can't do it, you issue a power of attorney to someone else to do it for you.
  • General Power of Attorney - when you want someone to help you take care of your property, protect it or manage its day-to-day affairs. This is a slightly broader power of attorney, but still limited.
  • Special mandate - for action in a specific field. For example, if you want someone to represent you in court or handle your affairs at the bank.

Powers of attorney can also be issued to one person or several. If you appoint one specific person, this is called a separate power of attorney. If you authorise several people and they have to act together, this is a general (quantitative) authorisation.

Another important point, according to an AVOCAD lawyer, is the duration of the mandate. It can be either fixed-term (where it clearly states how long it is valid for) or open-ended. "However, if there is no time limit, the law still limits its validity - such a power of attorney is automatically valid only for one year from the date of issue," says R. Puodžiūnas.

To be valid, a power of attorney must be in a separate written document and signed by the attorney-in-fact - the one who authorises another to act on his/her behalf. In some cases, the law also requires notarisation. This is necessary when authorising transactions requiring a notarial form, when acting on behalf of a natural person in dealing with legal persons or when dealing with actions relating to the management, use or disposal of immovable property.

Mandates are not perpetual. They expire in various ways - when they expire, when the attorney-in-fact decides to revoke it, or when the attorney-in-fact refuses to execute it. A power of attorney also ceases to have effect when one of the parties disappears - for example, if a legal person is wound up or is declared bankrupt, or if one of the natural parties dies, or is declared incapacitated in a particular field, or is simply declared missing.

The lawyer reminds you that when the power of attorney ends, both the principal and the attorney-in-fact have their duties. The principal must reimburse the necessary expenses incurred by the agent in the performance of his or her mandate - unless it was agreed in advance that this would be done without remuneration. If both parties are natural persons, the agreement is presumed to be gratuitous unless otherwise stated.

The principal also has a duty to inform of the end of the mandate, in particular if he or she revokes it, or if the mandate ends because of death or a change in legal status. In such a case, the heirs should be notified. In the meantime, the attorney-in-fact must return the original document - if he or she is unable to do so, his or her successors must do so. In addition, the attorney-in-fact must be accountable to the principal: he or she must give full details of how he or she carried out the assignment, the acts he or she performed, the documents he or she signed and the benefits he or she received on behalf of the principal. Anything received during the execution of the assignment must be returned to the principal.

 

Dividends: when are they illegal?  

The end of the financial year is a good time to learn more about dividends. This is an important aspect of a company's financial planning, but according to lawyers, businesses often forget a fundamental rule: dividends should only be paid when the company is stable and the interests of creditors are not affected. If a company has outstanding debts that should have been paid, the payment of dividends may be considered unlawful.

According to Domantas Velykis, Associate at AVOCAD, the Law on Joint Stock Companies provides that dividends are a share of profit allocated to a shareholder in proportion to the value of the shares owned by the shareholder. Simply put, dividends are a share of profit distributed to shareholders according to the number of shares they hold. Normally, companies allocate only a portion of their profits to dividends and invest the rest in business development, innovation or other needs.

The distribution of profits takes place after the end of the financial year, when the company's annual accounts are approved. The General Meeting of Shareholders decides on the payment of dividends and their amount. Although dividends are usually paid once a year, the law allows companies to distribute dividends more frequently - for example, every six months.

Only those persons who are shareholders of the company at the close of business on the day of the General Meeting of Shareholders or who are otherwise legally entitled to dividends are entitled to receive dividends. In the event of a subsequent acquisition of shares, the new shareholder is not entitled to past dividends but may be entitled to future payments.

Dividends must be decided in accordance with the legal framework. "If dividends are distributed in violation of the law, the shareholder may be obliged to repay the amount received to the company," notes Domantas Velykis. The Companies Act provides that if a shareholder knew or should have known that dividends were unlawfully distributed, the company is entitled to recover the amounts paid.

According to AVOCAD's lawyer, there are three cases where a company cannot decide to pay dividends:

  1. If the company has outstanding liabilities that have already fallen due.
  2. If the company's distributable profit is negative, a loss has been incurred.
  3. If the company's equity is too low or would fall to a critical threshold after the payment of dividends.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania has stated that dividends should only be paid when the company is stable and such payments do not harm the interests of creditors. One of the indicators of the stability of an undertaking is its ability to pay its creditors. Therefore, if a company has outstanding debts which should have been paid, the payment of dividends may be considered unlawful.

However, case law recognises that if a company, after having declared a dividend, pays the outstanding debt before actually paying the dividend to the shareholders, the infringement is deemed to be eliminated. In such a case, the dividends paid to the shareholders would not be considered unlawful.

Another relevant situation, according to the lawyer, is if the company agrees with the creditor to postpone the payment of the debt by adopting new payment terms. Case law shows that in such cases the obligation is not considered to be in arrears and therefore the granting of dividends can be considered legitimate if the company complies with the new payment terms. In this way, the company can safeguard the interests of its shareholders without infringing the rights of its creditors.

Thus, the distribution of dividends is a delicate process that requires careful legal assessment. It is important for companies not only to comply with the law, but also to take a responsible view of their financial position and liabilities in order to avoid potential legal consequences.

Ocean rescue operation. How much will it cost?

The rescue of Lithuanian Aurimas Mockus off the coast of Australia, which has attracted public attention, has revealed an important aspect - how such rescues are legally regulated and who has to pay for them.

According to Mantas Baigis, an attorney at AVOCAD, such rescue operations are very clearly regulated by international law. According to the lawyer, rescue at sea is regulated by the International Convention on Maritime Search and Rescue, to which Australia is a party. Under the Convention, States are obliged to provide assistance to anyone in danger at sea, regardless of their nationality or the circumstances of the disaster, i.e. rescue operations at sea do not normally involve the reimbursement of rescue costs.

"However, if it is established that a person intentionally or through extreme negligence (e.g. disregarding warnings) caused a situation that required a rescue operation, proceedings may be initiated to recover the costs of such an operation," notes Baigys.

As regards the salvage operation of Aurimas Mockus' rowing boat and the property it contained, the International Convention on Salvage of Property in Waters applies, which entitles salvage operations to remuneration. The Convention details the conditions for indemnity. In other words, salvors are entitled to remuneration. This remuneration is usually paid out of the pocket of the property owner or insurer.

The lawyer also points out that rescue operations are two different categories. "In any case, whether Aurimas Mockus will be required to pay any costs (if a boat rescue is carried out) will depend on how the situation will be qualified by the Australian organisations responsible for the rescue operations," notes the AVOCAD lawyer.

What are the regulations for rescuing people and property in the Baltic Sea?

Lithuania is also a signatory to the International Convention on Maritime Search and Rescue and is not required to reimburse a person for the cost of his or her rescue (unless the person is found to have acted with extreme carelessness and intent). In addition, Lithuania has adopted the Law on Safe Navigation, which strictly stipulates that ships in the territorial sea and ports of the Republic of Lithuania are obliged to provide assistance to people in distress at sea using the technical means at their disposal. Our country has also acceded to the International Convention for the Salvage of Property in Waters, the provisions of which are applicable to salvage operations, which are normally the responsibility of the owner of the property or its insurer.

 

Can you win without playing cards: economic pressure, negotiating inequality and treaty challenge 

The most talked-about event at the moment is the US-Ukraine mineral agreement. The terms of the agreement are being examined in public and even certain episodes of the negotiations are being made public. The situation culminated in a meeting between the Presidents of Ukraine and the US, during which it is possible to see the two parties in different positions, namely the dominant US, which is demanding that Ukraine conclude the treaty, with a real threat of existential and economic consequences for Ukraine if the treaty is not signed. On the other side, we have Ukraine, which is being forced to sign a deal that is clearly to its detriment, and which it would never have considered signing if its existence had not been threatened.

We can look at the situation from a moral point of view, where the stronger party to the contract cannot take advantage of the weaker party's particularly bad situation, but we can also look at the situation from a legal perspective, a situation that is much closer to our everyday lives.

Imagine you are the owner of a company. The company is facing financial difficulties and the possibility of bankruptcy. You are approached by your business partners who ask you to sign a personal guarantee agreement for the company's liabilities, otherwise they will no longer work with your company, which means bankruptcy for you. As the President of the United States would say, you do not have a card to play, either you guarantee or the company ends. Eventually, the surety is signed, the company goes bankrupt and the creditor is already claiming the debt from you. Is it possible to invalidate such a surety agreement?

Even closer: you lose your job, you have young children, you have no means of livelihood, you are offered to sell your home at a price you consider inadequate, but you have no choice but to sell it quickly, otherwise you will suffer very serious consequences. Can such a contract of sale be challenged?

These agreements are not much different from the US-UKRAINE deal in everyday life, but the world is taking a dim view of the current situation, and no one is coming to the rescue of the country that is pressed against the wall. However, if you were the shareholder of the company I mentioned, or a natural person, you could, even after signing such an agreement, go to court and ask for it to be declared invalid.

The Civil Code gives you the right to rescind a contract if it was concluded under economic pressure or a real threat of such pressure. A contract may also be declared void if it was concluded by a person due to circumstances which made it necessary to conclude it on very unfavourable terms.

The case law consistently holds that in order for a transaction to be recognised as having been concluded as a result of economic pressure or a real threat, the following conditions must be met: (1) the other person demanded that the contract be concluded; (2) the threat was made on economic grounds, the occurrence of which depended on the dishonest actions of the other person; (3) the transaction was concluded on terms manifestly disadvantageous to the person concluding the transaction; and (4) the contract would not have been concluded in the absence of economic pressure.

The application of the hardship ground in business-to-business relationships requires consideration of business risk.A transaction may be declared void on this ground only if the following conditions are met: (1) circumstances beyond the control of the other party to the transaction have arisen which have forced the person to enter into the transaction on terms that are manifestly unfavourable to him; (2) the other party to the transaction has knowledge of those circumstances and has taken advantage of them by imposing his own will on the other party to the transaction.

In such cases, it is particularly important to assess the element of inequality between the parties in the agreement, where one party receives much more than the other. The criterion for identifying inequality is defined as a shocking disproportion between the benefits obtained by the parties from the contract or its terms.It is also important that, in addition to the shocking disproportion in the benefits received by the parties, the circumstances giving rise to unfairness are identified, i.e. that the stronger party has taken unfair advantage of the weaker party because of its economic weakness or disadvantage, its imprudence, inexperience, lack of bargaining experience.

International principles of contract law state that in certain cases only an objective element is sufficient to establish a fundamental inequality, i.e. the nature and purpose of the contract may be such that it is sufficient to establish a shocking disproportion in the benefits obtained by the parties from the contract.Such an interpretation of fundamental inequality is in line with the Civil Code.While it is possible in certain cases to establish a fundamental inequality merely on the basis of a disproportion between the parties' mutual obligations and the benefits they receive, where the difference is particularly shocking, the subjective circumstances which make the stronger party's dishonesty unfair should normally also be assessed.

In one way or another, the law provides that a contract may be declared void if it is the result of difficult circumstances or economic pressure, but in each case the circumstances would be examined and assessed by a court, as contracts can in principle only be declared void if there is a clearly established ground.

 

Lawyer Egidijus Kieras

Ruin or building: when is a building considered extinct? 

A farmhouse that has been abandoned for decades: the roof is caved in, the walls are crumbling, but the foundations are still visible. The ruins of a factory in the centre of the town: some of the structures have collapsed, but some of the walls still remain. Do such buildings still exist legally or are they considered extinct? These questions are important not only for the owners, but also for the courts in disputes over property rights. The situation is complicated by the fact that there is no concept of extinction in the law.

According to Eimantas Čepas, attorney at law at AVOCAD, the right to property is one of the fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution. "The inviolability and protection of property means that the owner has the right to perform any act on his property except those prohibited by law, to use his property and to determine its fate in any way that does not infringe the rights and freedoms of others," he reminds the lawyer. As a form of property, it is compulsory to register any building, whether created or existing, in the real estate register. The question is, can a structure disappear?

"According to the provisions of the legislation governing the registration of objects, rights in rem and legal facts, the public register must record, among other things, the fact of the extinction of a former object. Thus, it is obvious that the legal extinction of a building can and must be recorded in the public register," says Čepas. However, according to the lawyer, a strange situation arises, as there is no concept of extinction of an object in the legislation. The Supreme Court of Lithuania has also noted this in its practice.

The concept of extinction of an object is, in principle, only established by the rule of case-law that it is only after the fact of total collapse, destruction or demolition of a structure has been established, i.e., that there are no structures left or that only the load-bearing structures below the surface of the ground (the subterranean structure, i.e. in the case of a structure which is underground, where all or most of its load-bearing structures have disappeared), unless the demolition of the structure or parts thereof is carried out in the course of the reconstruction or overhaul of the structure, it shall be presumed to have disappeared and therefore the structure and the rights in rem in respect of the structure shall be registered.

"Thus, once the total collapse, destruction or demolition of a structure has been established, it is deemed to be extinct and must be registered, and vice versa - if there is no reason to establish the total collapse, destruction or demolition of a structure, there is no reason to deem it to be extinct," the lawyer notes.

This regulation is the subject of disputes in the courts

In practice, this legal framework often leads to disputes as to how many and which of the building's structures must be destroyed, destroyed or missing in order for the building to be considered extinct, and conversely, to prove that the building can still legally exist.

Establishing the existence of a structure can be particularly important for the restoration of old buildings. The case-law also makes it clear that where the owner does not wish to demolish the building, but the building has deteriorated and its load-bearing structures are no longer there, the owner has the right to restore the building in accordance with the procedure laid down by law. The right to restore a building may not be restricted, provided that it is exercised in accordance with the procedure laid down by law, i.e. a person's constitutional right to own and enjoy his or her property must be guaranteed and not restricted.

AVOCAD's lawyer argues that there are cases where the courts have taken the fact that only parts of a building's foundations, and not the entire structure, have survived as evidence that the load-bearing structures have not survived and that the building should be considered to have collapsed completely.The Court stated that, if it is established that none of the load-bearing structures remain and that the remaining parts of the foundation are not capable of fulfilling the purpose of a load-bearing structure, the dwelling does not meet the definition of a structure as set out in the law and should therefore be considered as a remnant of a structure and not as a building.Accordingly, it must be declared extinct.

Thus, according to the lawyer, the condition for the disappearance of the structure in the present case was linked to the question whether the remains of the structure could actually be used for their intended purpose. In the other cases, the condition of extinction has been recognised essentially on the basis of a purely visual and subjective assessment of the situation, i.e. the court has held that the structure is extinct because only its individual fragments and remnants are visible.

However, recent case-law provides a different interpretation of the situation in question: when deciding whether a building has disappeared and whether its structures have survived, it is irrelevant whether the surviving structures comply with the requirements of strength, stability or integrity for the structures of a new building.In simple terms, it has been clarified that, for the purposes of declaring a structure extinct or not, it is not relevant whether the surviving structures of the structure are still capable of being used for their main purpose, but rather the existence of the surviving structures, without assessing whether they comply with the requirements for the structures of a new building, and not the existence of their fragments or remains. Furthermore, the Court explained that the fact that, for example, the foundation of a building is damaged and broken in pieces does not constitute a ground for finding that only fragments or remains of the foundation of the building have survived.

According to lawyer Eimantas Čeps, since the legislation does not contain clear and specific definitions of what can be considered as an extinct structure, once the dispute has moved to the courts, how much and what kind of remnants of a structure can be sufficient to declare that there are no grounds for establishing that the structure has been completely collapsed, destroyed, or demolished, and thus should not be considered extinct, or, on the contrary, to declare the structure to have disappeared, is a matter that remains subject to evidence in the case, and the final assessment may vary from case to case.

 

Compulsory military service: what do I need to know?

The list of conscripts for 2025 has already been published, with a target of around 3 800 conscripts to be called up for compulsory initial military service. While there is no shortage of information about conscription in the public domain, many people are still confused about the legal process of conscription and the rights and obligations involved. According to Sandra Mickienė, Senior Associate at AVOCAD, there are many myths circulating in the public domain which can lead to wrong decisions, unfounded fears and misjudgements. It is therefore important to know the basic facts about compulsory military service.

Military obligation: duty and responsibility

One of the most important duties is the constitutional obligation to defend the Lithuanian state against foreign armed attack. In order to ensure that citizens are able to fulfil this duty properly, it is necessary to prepare them physically and psychologically, and this preparation is ensured by compulsory military service. Thus, military duty is not only a personal responsibility, but also an important guarantee of state security, ensuring the ability of citizens to defend their country.

Myths and reality

One of the most common misconceptions is that all conscripts will have to serve in the army. However, according to the legislation in force, the conscription procedure covers not only the selection and appointment of conscripts for compulsory military service, but also the deferment and exemption from service.

"This means that whether a person will actually be obliged to perform compulsory initial military service will depend on whether a statutory health check determines that he or she is fit to perform permanent compulsory initial military service; and whether there are no objective circumstances that justify his or her exemption from service or deferment of service. Only if these conditions are met will a person be obliged to perform compulsory initial military service," said Ms Mickienė.

Another common myth is the issue of conscripts' health. The public perception is that in order to avoid compulsory initial military service, it is sufficient to go to a doctor, to collect a medical history documenting the various health problems and illnesses that one has had, and in some cases it is even suggested to falsify the data by referring to non-existent conditions or illnesses. It is noted that conscripts often turn to psychologists or psychiatrists in order to obtain diagnoses that could be used as grounds for declaring them unfit for compulsory military service. There are a number of important points to note here:

  • Simulating or falsifying documents is a criminal offence punishable by criminal penalties (arrest or imprisonment for up to three years).
  • Psychological or psychiatric diagnoses can make it difficult to pursue a future career in fields that require perfect health (e.g. law enforcement, aviation).
  • The legislation governing military conscription provides for a separate medical examination procedure, and therefore the medical certificates collected in advance may have no legal value.

A third aspect that is often confused is the age limits for compulsory initial military service. Under current legislation, the age limit for conscripts is 18-23 years. However, persons who wish to serve voluntarily may do so until the age of 38. In exceptional cases, if military service has been postponed due to studies, the age of conscription may be extended to 26.

Compulsory initial military service is not a punishment but an opportunity

Young people who have not yet established a professional career and do not have financial commitments often avoid the service because of negative perceptions of it. However, compulsory service is not a punishment, but an opportunity to acquire valuable skills, to strengthen physical and psychological endurance and to contribute actively to national defence.

The lawyer says that the legislation provides for social guarantees for conscripts, such as clothing, food, official accommodation and allowances for living expenses. During their service, they receive cash incentives based on their performance. If their service is satisfactory (very good, good or satisfactory), they are paid monthly allowances, which are payable at the end of a full period of service of 9 months. In addition, for those who voluntarily serve and express their wish before the publication of the list of conscripts for the calendar year, the allowances are increased by 30 %. For those who express their wish after the publication of the list but before the signing of the order of assignment to a military unit, the increase shall be 15 %. "Employers who have recruited conscripts who have completed their initial compulsory military service receive a wage subsidy for up to 6 months. This subsidy applies if the conscript was recruited within 3 months from the date of his/her permanent compulsory initial military service," notes Sandra Mickienė.

Exemption from military service and deferment of military service

S. Mickienė, a lawyer at AVOCAD, points out that a distinction must be made between exemption from military service and deferment of service. Exemption is definitive and applies only in the case of objective circumstances such as disability or incapacity. Deferment is a temporary solution. It may be granted to persons studying, to persons with children under 3 years of age, or for other important reasons.

Each case is assessed individually. Deferment of service due to work or financial obligations is generally not recognised as a sufficient ground, as the law provides for job security for conscripts and the possibility of deferring housing loan payments.

There is more flexibility for conscripts living and working abroad, as they do not enjoy the same social guarantees as in Lithuania. According to the lawyer, both the Conscription and Manning Service and the courts are strict in their assessment of such applications, which must be objectively justified and highly relevant. The nature of the harm must be such as to outweigh the constitutional obligation to perform military service.

"In summary, the circumstances of each case are assessed on a case-by-case basis, taking into account objective evidence and the significance of the damage. It is advisable to take a very responsible approach to one's duties and, if you have any questions, to contact the relevant authorities for accurate and clear information and, if necessary, to consult a lawyer," advises S.Mickienė.

 

 

Recruiting a manager: what are the biggest mistakes and what has changed since the New Year?

The recruitment of a CEO is a key element of an organisation's activities, requiring not only legal clarity but also a clear division of responsibilities. The manager of a legal entity is responsible for the day-to-day running of the company and his/her decisions have a direct impact on the success and reputation of the organisation. However, in practice, according to lawyers, there are often situations where the employment of a manager teeters on the brink of illegal employment.

Why this happens, what mistakes are made and how to avoid legal violations in this situation and how to properly organise the recruitment of a manager - answers AVOCAD Managing Partner, attorney-at-law Egidijus Langys.

The CEO is appointed by the company's board of directors or, if there is no board of directors, by the general meeting of shareholders. This body also approves the manager's remuneration, the job description and decides on bonuses or disciplinary action.

The Labour Code stipulates that a manager must have an employment contract, except for exceptions provided for by law. "This means that a manager's activity in a company without a properly concluded employment contract may be considered illegal employment," points out Langys.

While these requirements are clear, in practice companies often face situations where non-compliance leads to legal and financial consequences.

According to the lawyer, it is not uncommon for company managers not to be given employment contracts on the grounds that they are appointed by the shareholders, or not to be informed of their employment. This omission also leads to illegal employment, which has a number of negative consequences for companies.

The lawyer notes that a common mistake is the incorrect submission of information to Sodra. Failure to notify the manager's employment or late notification can not only lead to fines, but also hinder the provision of social security benefits to the manager. If the company's HR department fails to notice that the manager's employment contract must be registered in the Sodra system before the start of his/her employment. This exposes the company to administrative fines and the manager to temporary loss of insurance cover.

As of 1 January 2025, the Labour Code changes to provide that the conclusion of an employment contract and the recruitment of the head of a legal person must be notified to the territorial division of the State Social Insurance Fund Board at least one hour before the scheduled start of work.

"It is likely that this provision will not raise any questions about the proper recruitment of a manager, and that the amendment will be a help and a reminder to the company's accountants or HR representatives who perform the company's recruitment functions," notes AVOCAD's lawyer.

 

Preliminary agreement: how to avoid unfair treatment and protect your rights?

Preliminary contracts for the sale and purchase of real estate may seem like a simple first step towards a successful transaction, but even small details can be a source of significant conflict, lawyers say.

What if the seller refuses to conclude the main contract? What to do when the deposit has already been paid and the agreements do not meet the original expectations of the parties? How can I protect my interests? Viktorija Dubovskienė of AVOCAD answers these questions .

You own real estate and have decided to sell it. A potential buyer has come along and you have entered into a preliminary contract for the sale of the property with him. In the contract, you agreed on a date by which the main contract for the sale of the land must be concluded. The purchase price consisted of an advance to be paid immediately after the signing of the preliminary contract, a further advance after a certain period of time, and a third, remaining part after the main contract had been signed, within 6 months from the date of signing the main contract.

Everything went smoothly in your situation - both advances from the buyer were paid. However, when the signing of the main contract is arranged at the notary's office, the seller indicates that he does not want to conclude the main contract and refuses to reimburse the advances to the buyer. The argument put forward by the seller is that the money has to be paid at the time of conclusion of the main contract.

The lawyer points out that it is in such a situation that the legal basis for civil liability is the party's dishonest behaviour. The case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania notes that it is the party's dishonest behaviour that is regarded as unlawful conduct when deciding on pre-contractual civil liability when a party fails to perform a preliminary agreement, i.e. refuses to conclude a main contract.

As mentioned above, the buyer paid most of the advance into the seller's bank account before the main contract was signed. The parties agreed in the Preliminary Agreement that the remaining amount of money, the third payment, would be made after the signature of the Main Contract within 6 months from the signature of the Main Contract. The draft main contract, which included the condition of payment of the balance of the price at the time of conclusion of the main contract, was not in conformity with the essential conditions for the conclusion of the main contract, which had been agreed between the parties in the preliminary contract, concerning the payment procedure for the purchase of the property. For that reason, the buyer's refusal to sign such a draft contract on the ground that the procedure for payment of the price of the property was not in accordance with the intention of the parties under the preliminary agreement cannot be regarded as unreasonable and unfair conduct.

The Civil Code obliges each party to a contract not only to perform its obligations in good faith and properly, but also to carry out its duties as economically as possible and to cooperate with the other party. "Both parties to a contract have a duty to cooperate and to exercise their rights in good faith, and therefore both parties must act actively and perform actions that are consistent with reasonableness, which is a prerequisite for proper cooperation between the parties," attorney-at-law V. Dubovskienė notes in her commentary on the case law.

Since the draft of the main contract in such a situation was prepared by the notary proposed by the seller in accordance with the terms and conditions specified by the seller, the Court of Cassation held that it was the seller's duty to ensure that the proposed draft was in conformity with the provisions of the main contract on the procedure for payment for the purchase of the purchased property as laid down in the preliminary contract. The seller failed to fulfil that obligation by taking the position that the price of the property to be acquired was to be paid on the date of signature of the contract and, if the buyer did not agree to sign the main contract in accordance with the design proposed by the defendants, by informing the buyer that the contract was to be regarded as not having been concluded through the fault of the buyer.

According to the lawyer, this behaviour of both parties can be qualified as a breach of the duty of cooperation between the parties, which led to the failure to conclude the main contract. As a result of the breach of the duty to cooperate by both parties and the failure to conclude the main contract, it was decided to oblige the seller to reimburse the buyer for the advance paid by him, but not to grant the buyer's request for a penalty.

Thus, in such a situation, the most frequent and initial assessment will be the pre-contractual relationship and its evaluation, with a particular focus on the behaviour of the parties. Therefore, according to AVOCAD's lawyer, it is necessary to pay attention to what has been agreed and not to deviate unilaterally from the original agreements.

 

Working while ill: legal challenges, employer and employee responsibilities

 

In Lithuania, workers have the right to paid sick leave, which is provided for and regulated in detail by law. Nevertheless, some workers choose to go to work even when they are ill.

"Such behaviour, not only in the context of the pandemic experienced and survived, but also during the annual infectious disease season, raises significant legal, health and occupational safety issues," says Karolina Briliūtė, a lawyer at the law firm AVOCAD.

She said that Lithuanian labour law provides for measures to ensure workers' health and regulate employers' obligations, but there are no explicit prohibitions on working when ill. This highlights the need for stricter or more creative application of existing laws and regulations, or for regulating such situations through internal workplace regulations to address what is known as "presenteeism". This is a situation where an employee loses productivity in the performance of his/her job functions at his/her workplace due to illness, injury or other objective circumstances. Nevertheless, even when ill, individuals often feel the need and desire to physically go to work.

Under Lithuanian labour law, employers are obliged to ensure the health and safety of their employees, as set out in the Occupational Safety and Health Act. This law obliges employers to implement measures to prevent risks in the workplace, including the spread of communicable diseases. By encouraging or allowing (or failing to prevent) sick workers to work, employers not only violate their obligations to ensure a safe working environment, but may also be in breach of the Labour Code of the Republic of Lithuania, which stipulates that employers have a duty to provide suitable working conditions and to ensure the well-being of employees.

Karolina Briliūtė notes that the legislation does not explicitly prohibit working when ill, which may place too much responsibility on employees and employers by regulating such situations in internal workplace regulations. "For example, the Occupational Safety and Health Act imposes an obligation on the employer to take measures to ensure that the working environment complies with the requirements of the occupational safety and health legislation, which may also include the obligation to regulate situations where employees go to the workplace when they are ill, thus endangering the health and safety of other employees," notes AVOCAD's lawyer.

She also notes that staff who work while ill, especially in cases of communicable diseases, not only endanger the health of colleagues but also violate the principles set out in the Public Health Act. "This law obliges employers and employees to contribute to public health, and working when sick hinders this. "The instruments in the existing legislation are sufficient for creative interpretation, allowing employers to set stricter, clearer instructions in their internal regulations," the lawyer notes.

Employers have a wide range of responsibilities to reduce the risks associated with sick workers in the workplace. They must ensure a clear sick leave policy, encourage employees to prioritise their health, and inform them of their rights and responsibilities, ensuring that employees are aware not only of their own health but also that of their colleagues. Employers should take proactive measures, such as health checks or favourable teleworking policies, especially in areas wherepresenteeismcan have serious consequences, such as the healthcare or food service sectors and areas where there is constant contact with individuals. Such provisions could be added to the Occupational Safety and Health Act or, through creative application of existing statutory provisions, elaborated in sub-statutory or internal legislation.

According to Briliūtė, in order to fully address the challenges posed bypresenteeism, Lithuania could consider amendments to legislation that would provide legal consequences for non-compliance with such obligations and mechanisms for anonymous reporting of breaches by employees. "These provisions could be included in the Labour Code or the Law on Public Health Care, thus creating a coherent legal framework to ensure workers' health and public safety. Strengthening this legislation would promote a healthy working culture, reduce risks in the workplace and ensure the well-being of workers and society," she stresses.

Actual and formal head of the company - who is liable for damages?

"I'm just a placeholder...", "I was only formally appointed here, the real manager was someone else...", "my friends asked me to be formally present...", "I didn't handle the money, another manager did". These and similar excuses often baffle lawyers when dealing with managerial responsibility.

"It may be the result of innocent naivety or blind trust, or perhaps a lack of basic understanding and knowledge, but sometimes these cases can also be the result of deliberate action," says Egidijus Langys, Managing Partner at AVOCAD. He says that the most important thing is not to blame, but to help managers avoid such situations or to get out of them as soon as possible. So, how can we protect ourselves from the potential risks that can arise from the formal performance of managerial duties?

Limits to the responsibilities of the actual and formal manager

Before the holidays, the Supreme Court of Lithuania (SCL) issued an important clarification that distinguishes between the formal, or in other words legal, and de facto liability of a company's manager. This clarification is of particular relevance for those who find themselves caught between formal duties and real managerial control.

"Today's leader, in my opinion, is either a hero or a madman," Langys wryly remarks. According to the lawyer, managers must work with the utmost care, competence and compliance with the law, because the limits of liability can be wide and sometimes very unexpected.

The mere existence of a de facto manager does not exclude the liability of a formal manager. If both managers committed illegal acts, the question is whether they acted as accomplices. "It must be assessed whether the managers acted jointly with the intention to cause damage (subjective complicity) or whether the interaction of several actions simply led to the consequences (objective complicity)," explains Egidijus Langys.

Liability for aiding and abetting in court

One of the most common cases is when a person agrees to become a formal manager out of friendship or a simple request. Such a manager may believe that nothing serious will happen: after all, he or she has done nothing but sign a few documents. "But even in this case, the liability remains because the activity was carried out in his name. The formally appointed manager who signs the documents often does not look into the details and relies on the actual manager, but in court all this proves subjective complicity," warns Langys.

It is therefore necessary to assess the risks if you are asked to become a formal manager, whatever the purpose. "If you are already a formal manager and blindly follow the instructions of others, you should step down as soon as possible. It is important to remember that leadership is not only a responsibility, but also a huge risk, so a responsible approach to this role is vital.

What liability can a manager face?

According to AVOCAD's Managing Partner, the manager may be subject to civil, administrative or even criminal liability depending on the nature and extent of the damage caused. "For example, if a manager signed documents without looking at the information contained in them and this caused financial damage, he or she may be liable for damages," explains Mr Langys. In cases of criminal liability, the manager can face fines, imprisonment or even imprisonment.

"That's why it's important not only to understand the limits of your responsibilities, but also to ensure that all actions are legal and justified. Leadership is not only an opportunity to develop your career, but also a responsibility for all the consequences that may arise from poor decisions," emphasises Langys.

Current ruling: order of the Supreme Court of Lithuania in civil case No e3K-3-243-403/2024 of 16 December 2024.