Clarification of the Supreme Court of Lithuania on parking in courtyards of apartment buildings: residents can determine the procedure for using a parking lot that does not belong to them 

 

Owners of multi-apartment buildings exercising their right of shared ownership and having a legitimate need to use a parking space in the yard, even if it belongs to another owner, can claim the use of the parking space and the compensation to be paid. This was stated by the Supreme Court of Lithuania in a ruling issued on 6 May 2025.

Often, when developers are developing apartment or townhouse projects on their own land, there are cases where the spaces used to serve the main facilities, such as parking lots or access roads, are not allocated proportionally to the residents when the apartments or houses are sold. According to Eimantas Čepas, an attorney at law at AVOCAD, this decision of the Court of Cassation is an important signal for both residents and property developers. "This case becomes a precedent for a clearer definition of the legitimate grounds for the use of infrastructure belonging to another entity, especially when it comes to long-term use and public interest," the lawyer notes.

Who has the right to use the yard?

The circumstances of the case before the Supreme Court revealed that the parking lot adjacent to the apartment building is owned by a private legal entity, UAB, but has been used for many years by the residents of the apartment building, as the detailed planning documents, in implementing the requirement to provide a certain number of parking spaces, envisaged that it would serve the main building, an apartment building. The UAB claimed that the residents had illegally occupied their territory and demanded that they stop using it.

However, the Supreme Court noted that in such situations it is important to assess the reasons for the residents' use of the parking lot, whether it is necessary for the proper operation of the apartment building, and whether there is a legal basis for declaring the parking lot to be an appurtenance of the apartment building.

Proportionality and fairness are key

The Court clarified that the mere fact that a parking lot is not a common facility does not automatically mean that the residents are not entitled to its use.

"The use by residents of a parking lot belonging to another legal person may be justified on the basis of the principles of justice, reasonableness and fairness, where such use is necessary for the functioning of the apartment building and the owner is compensated for the damage," the ruling states on .

The Court stressed that it is necessary to assess all the circumstances - whether the site is actually needed for the residents' needs, whether the residents were willing to agree on the compensation, and whether the compensation is reasonable.

According to lawyer Eimantas Čeps, in situations where the owner of the land or building agrees to the use and the parties agree on reasonable compensation, the use arrangement is considered legal and reasonable.

In his view, this ruling of the Supreme Court of Lithuania may have significant consequences for the residents of cities throughout Lithuania, especially in densely urbanised areas where infrastructure development, ownership and actual use of land or buildings often intersect. Despite the fact that the land or structures serving the main buildings sometimes remain outside the common ownership of the residents after the real estate projects are realised, the actual use or purpose of such land or structures may provide a legal basis for declaring them to be subordinate and for deciding their legal status and fate accordingly.

"The Supreme Court of Lithuania recognises in this decision the legal significance of such a factual practice if it complies with the principles of reasonableness, fairness and proportionality, and promotes constructive solutions between communities and owners of private land or buildings," says the lawyer.

This decision sends a clear message: urban infrastructure and land use must be addressed through dialogue, consensus and fair compensation. Residents, developers and municipalities alike are encouraged to strike a balance between property rights and the public interest, and the Supreme Court's jurisprudence provides a valuable basis for finding lasting solutions in an urbanised environment.

"The principle of justice should not be limited to cadastral maps, but should also reflect the reality of people's lives," notes AVOCAD's lawyer.

Can you win without playing cards: economic pressure, negotiating inequality and treaty challenge 

The most talked-about event at the moment is the US-Ukraine mineral agreement. The terms of the agreement are being examined in public and even certain episodes of the negotiations are being made public. The situation culminated in a meeting between the Presidents of Ukraine and the US, during which it is possible to see the two parties in different positions, namely the dominant US, which is demanding that Ukraine conclude the treaty, with a real threat of existential and economic consequences for Ukraine if the treaty is not signed. On the other side, we have Ukraine, which is being forced to sign a deal that is clearly to its detriment, and which it would never have considered signing if its existence had not been threatened.

We can look at the situation from a moral point of view, where the stronger party to the contract cannot take advantage of the weaker party's particularly bad situation, but we can also look at the situation from a legal perspective, a situation that is much closer to our everyday lives.

Imagine you are the owner of a company. The company is facing financial difficulties and the possibility of bankruptcy. You are approached by your business partners who ask you to sign a personal guarantee agreement for the company's liabilities, otherwise they will no longer work with your company, which means bankruptcy for you. As the President of the United States would say, you do not have a card to play, either you guarantee or the company ends. Eventually, the surety is signed, the company goes bankrupt and the creditor is already claiming the debt from you. Is it possible to invalidate such a surety agreement?

Even closer: you lose your job, you have young children, you have no means of livelihood, you are offered to sell your home at a price you consider inadequate, but you have no choice but to sell it quickly, otherwise you will suffer very serious consequences. Can such a contract of sale be challenged?

These agreements are not much different from the US-UKRAINE deal in everyday life, but the world is taking a dim view of the current situation, and no one is coming to the rescue of the country that is pressed against the wall. However, if you were the shareholder of the company I mentioned, or a natural person, you could, even after signing such an agreement, go to court and ask for it to be declared invalid.

The Civil Code gives you the right to rescind a contract if it was concluded under economic pressure or a real threat of such pressure. A contract may also be declared void if it was concluded by a person due to circumstances which made it necessary to conclude it on very unfavourable terms.

The case law consistently holds that in order for a transaction to be recognised as having been concluded as a result of economic pressure or a real threat, the following conditions must be met: (1) the other person demanded that the contract be concluded; (2) the threat was made on economic grounds, the occurrence of which depended on the dishonest actions of the other person; (3) the transaction was concluded on terms manifestly disadvantageous to the person concluding the transaction; and (4) the contract would not have been concluded in the absence of economic pressure.

The application of the hardship ground in business-to-business relationships requires consideration of business risk.A transaction may be declared void on this ground only if the following conditions are met: (1) circumstances beyond the control of the other party to the transaction have arisen which have forced the person to enter into the transaction on terms that are manifestly unfavourable to him; (2) the other party to the transaction has knowledge of those circumstances and has taken advantage of them by imposing his own will on the other party to the transaction.

In such cases, it is particularly important to assess the element of inequality between the parties in the agreement, where one party receives much more than the other. The criterion for identifying inequality is defined as a shocking disproportion between the benefits obtained by the parties from the contract or its terms.It is also important that, in addition to the shocking disproportion in the benefits received by the parties, the circumstances giving rise to unfairness are identified, i.e. that the stronger party has taken unfair advantage of the weaker party because of its economic weakness or disadvantage, its imprudence, inexperience, lack of bargaining experience.

International principles of contract law state that in certain cases only an objective element is sufficient to establish a fundamental inequality, i.e. the nature and purpose of the contract may be such that it is sufficient to establish a shocking disproportion in the benefits obtained by the parties from the contract.Such an interpretation of fundamental inequality is in line with the Civil Code.While it is possible in certain cases to establish a fundamental inequality merely on the basis of a disproportion between the parties' mutual obligations and the benefits they receive, where the difference is particularly shocking, the subjective circumstances which make the stronger party's dishonesty unfair should normally also be assessed.

In one way or another, the law provides that a contract may be declared void if it is the result of difficult circumstances or economic pressure, but in each case the circumstances would be examined and assessed by a court, as contracts can in principle only be declared void if there is a clearly established ground.

 

Lawyer Egidijus Kieras

Preliminary agreement: how to avoid unfair treatment and protect your rights?

Preliminary contracts for the sale and purchase of real estate may seem like a simple first step towards a successful transaction, but even small details can be a source of significant conflict, lawyers say.

What if the seller refuses to conclude the main contract? What to do when the deposit has already been paid and the agreements do not meet the original expectations of the parties? How can I protect my interests? Viktorija Dubovskienė of AVOCAD answers these questions .

You own real estate and have decided to sell it. A potential buyer has come along and you have entered into a preliminary contract for the sale of the property with him. In the contract, you agreed on a date by which the main contract for the sale of the land must be concluded. The purchase price consisted of an advance to be paid immediately after the signing of the preliminary contract, a further advance after a certain period of time, and a third, remaining part after the main contract had been signed, within 6 months from the date of signing the main contract.

Everything went smoothly in your situation - both advances from the buyer were paid. However, when the signing of the main contract is arranged at the notary's office, the seller indicates that he does not want to conclude the main contract and refuses to reimburse the advances to the buyer. The argument put forward by the seller is that the money has to be paid at the time of conclusion of the main contract.

The lawyer points out that it is in such a situation that the legal basis for civil liability is the party's dishonest behaviour. The case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania notes that it is the party's dishonest behaviour that is regarded as unlawful conduct when deciding on pre-contractual civil liability when a party fails to perform a preliminary agreement, i.e. refuses to conclude a main contract.

As mentioned above, the buyer paid most of the advance into the seller's bank account before the main contract was signed. The parties agreed in the Preliminary Agreement that the remaining amount of money, the third payment, would be made after the signature of the Main Contract within 6 months from the signature of the Main Contract. The draft main contract, which included the condition of payment of the balance of the price at the time of conclusion of the main contract, was not in conformity with the essential conditions for the conclusion of the main contract, which had been agreed between the parties in the preliminary contract, concerning the payment procedure for the purchase of the property. For that reason, the buyer's refusal to sign such a draft contract on the ground that the procedure for payment of the price of the property was not in accordance with the intention of the parties under the preliminary agreement cannot be regarded as unreasonable and unfair conduct.

The Civil Code obliges each party to a contract not only to perform its obligations in good faith and properly, but also to carry out its duties as economically as possible and to cooperate with the other party. "Both parties to a contract have a duty to cooperate and to exercise their rights in good faith, and therefore both parties must act actively and perform actions that are consistent with reasonableness, which is a prerequisite for proper cooperation between the parties," attorney-at-law V. Dubovskienė notes in her commentary on the case law.

Since the draft of the main contract in such a situation was prepared by the notary proposed by the seller in accordance with the terms and conditions specified by the seller, the Court of Cassation held that it was the seller's duty to ensure that the proposed draft was in conformity with the provisions of the main contract on the procedure for payment for the purchase of the purchased property as laid down in the preliminary contract. The seller failed to fulfil that obligation by taking the position that the price of the property to be acquired was to be paid on the date of signature of the contract and, if the buyer did not agree to sign the main contract in accordance with the design proposed by the defendants, by informing the buyer that the contract was to be regarded as not having been concluded through the fault of the buyer.

According to the lawyer, this behaviour of both parties can be qualified as a breach of the duty of cooperation between the parties, which led to the failure to conclude the main contract. As a result of the breach of the duty to cooperate by both parties and the failure to conclude the main contract, it was decided to oblige the seller to reimburse the buyer for the advance paid by him, but not to grant the buyer's request for a penalty.

Thus, in such a situation, the most frequent and initial assessment will be the pre-contractual relationship and its evaluation, with a particular focus on the behaviour of the parties. Therefore, according to AVOCAD's lawyer, it is necessary to pay attention to what has been agreed and not to deviate unilaterally from the original agreements.

 

Are you entitled to a credit reduction when you buy a car?  

To buy a car, we often use a variety of financing instruments. Some of the most popular are car rental or leasing contracts. Eimantas Čepas, Senior Associate at AVOCAD, comments on what you need to know about these contracts and what misunderstandings often arise when you want to buy a financed car early in the hope of saving money .

According to the lawyer, when concluding a car rental or leasing contract, the buyer of a car can usually choose between paying only monthly instalments during the contract period and not buying the car at the end of the contract, or paying the residual value of the car and taking personal ownership of the used car.

It is important to note here that this refers to rental or leasing contracts between a consumer and a trader. In a consumer contract, the trader undertakes to transfer the ownership of the goods or services to the consumer and the consumer undertakes to accept the goods or services and pay the price. A consumer is a natural person who enters into transactions for purposes other than his business, trade, craft or profession. The consumer is considered to be the weaker party to the transaction when concluding a contract with a trader, which is why the law provides for additional safeguards to protect the rights of the consumer.

The Consumer Credit Act is one of the tools designed to protect the interests of consumers who are considering taking on financial obligations. The Consumer Credit Act enshrines the consumer's right to discharge all or part of his obligations under a consumer credit agreement at any time. If he does so, he is entitled to a reduction in the total cost of the consumer credit, consisting of interest and costs for the remaining period of the consumer credit agreement, calculated from the date of repayment of the consumer credit or part thereof.

Thus, if a contract is concluded and the owner decides to take ownership of the financed car before the final contractual maturity date, it is common practice to expect to save on the interest part of the lease or hire purchase agreement. However, there are occasions when, after expressing such a wish, the car financier asks to pay not only the residual value of the car, but also the interest for the entire pre-agreed period of the contract.

"Such situations have been created by the provisions of the Consumer Credit Act, according to which this Act applies to consumer credit agreements, but not to lease or hire-purchase agreements, where these agreements or a separate agreement do not stipulate an obligation to purchase the object of the agreement, in this case a car," says Čepas.

Financing agreements are usually drawn up in advance by the lender. The condition that at the end of the contract it will not be necessary to buy the car for the remaining value and that it will be up to the buyer's wish to do so, may seem attractive to many consumers. However, a financier who takes advantage of this, by formally stipulating in a standard rental or leasing contract that the consumer is not obliged to acquire the car, or only acquires the right to acquire the car by expressing his/her will in a separate notice, may seek to avoid the application of the provisions of the Consumer Credit Act, which enable the consumer to save money by early repayment of the contract, without having to pay a portion of the interest. Such a provision is undoubtedly advantageous for the creditor, as it ensures that the consumer, even if he decides to repay the credit early, will have to pay the full amount of the pre-agreed interest for the entire term of the contract.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania, which has established uniform case law in Lithuania, has pointed out that when assessing whether the financier in such contracts, by not imposing an obligation on the buyer to purchase a car, does not intend to evade the application of the Consumer Credit Law and to make a potentially unjustified profit from the consumer, the purpose for which the buyer enters into the contract should be taken into account. In this case, the consumer's purpose is usually clear, namely to purchase a car by spreading the payments over a period of time.

In the Court's view, where the contract in question does not contain a clause requiring the consumer to acquire ownership of the car and these circumstances have not been individually discussed with the consumer, or where other circumstances suggest that the terms of the lease or hire-purchase agreement were intended to avoid the application of the Consumer Credit Act, the provisions of the Consumer Credit Act must apply to such contracts and the consumer's rights to discharge all or part of his obligations under the consumer credit agreement and to reduce the total cost of the consumer credit at any time must be protected.

Nor should the consumer's right to discharge all or part of his obligations under a consumer credit agreement at any time be confused with a modification of the credit agreement. This means that the consumer may decide on his own to prematurely discharge all his credit obligations, in which case he may not be required to renegotiate the terms of the financing provided.

According to Eimantas Čepas, attorney at law at AVOCAD, notwithstanding the possible unfair behaviour of creditors in not stipulating the obligation to purchase a car in rental or lease agreements, in order to formally avoid the application of the Consumer Credit provisions, a consumer who decides to redeem the car subject to the agreement before the due date is entitled to a reduction of the total price of the consumer credit, i.e. to the conversion of the interest rate at the time of the redemption of the car, thus lowering the overall price of the interest payable.

 

 

Household consumers and small businesses can terminate their energy supply contract without any termination fee

According to recent case law, it is clearly established that household consumers, micro-enterprises and small enterprises have the right to unilaterally terminate their electricity sales contract and switch to an independent supplier free of charge from 15 July 2021, without paying any termination fees.

According to Mantas Baigis, Senior Associate at AVOCAD, the Lithuanian Court of Appeals has recently issued a very important decision rejecting a claim of more than EUR 1 million for the payment of termination fees.

"Until now, both household consumers and small businesses have been afraid to initiate the termination of uneconomic electricity contracts and change electricity supplier, because electricity suppliers demand huge termination fees for terminating contracts," Mantas Baigys notes.

Directive (EU) 2019/944 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 5 June 2019 concerning common rules for the internal market in electricity and amending Directive 2012/27/EU (Directive 2019/944) provided for an obligation for Member States to ensure that unreasonable switching charges are not levied, and for the Member States to ensure, by their proactive action, that relevant unreasonable charges (i.e., switching-only charges that are unrelated to a specific loss of the supplier) are not levied against household consumers and small businesses.

Legislator 01 June 2023 The Energy Law of the Republic of Lithuania established that household consumers, micro-enterprises and small enterprises as defined in the Law on Small and Medium Business Development of the Republic of Lithuania shall have the right to unilaterally terminate the contract for the sale and purchase of electricity or the contract for the sale and purchase of electricity and provision of the transmission service to an independent supplier, and shall have the right to change the independent supplier.

According to the legislator, it is prohibited to provide for termination fees, switching fees and penalties to be charged to the consumers referred to in this paragraph for the unilateral termination of a contract for the sale and purchase of electricity or a contract for the sale and purchase of electricity and the provision of a transmission service.

Recent case law has clarified that the provisions of Directive (EU) 2019/944 have been properly transposed into the Lithuanian legal system since the adoption of Law No XIV-483 of 30 June 2021, which meant that as of 15 July 2021, it was ensured that household consumers and small businesses would not pay any switching fees when unilaterally terminating their contracts.

In other words, even if the termination fee was provided for in the contract between the parties in the electricity sales contracts concluded after 15 July 2021, it cannot be applied to the termination of the contract in accordance with the legal framework. Even if a termination fee has been paid (on or after 15 July 2021), you have the right to claim its reimbursement.

According to the lawyer, both ordinary consumers and businesses (micro and small enterprises) have the right to review their electricity contracts and assess whether there are any objective criteria for choosing another electricity supplier, and not to pay any termination fee. Even if termination fees are fixed in the contract.

"This does not in itself mean that it is possible to initiate the termination of contracts in haste. It is necessary to responsibly assess whether all the necessary conditions for such action exist. It is therefore advisable to seek legal advice," points out the AVOCAD lawyer.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Profit sharing: are all shareholders entitled to dividends?

Many companies call an ordinary general meeting before the end of April after the end of the financial year to approve the annual accounts and distribute profits. Shareholders of companies often look forward to this date in the hope of receiving an appropriate share of the profits in the form of dividends. But are they all entitled to receive dividends? Can they be paid every year? Are companies free to decide in what form and how much dividends to pay to their shareholders?

According to Sandra Mickienė, Associate at AVOCAD, the Law on Joint Stock Companies (the "ABI") provides for certain important restrictions that must be taken into account when deciding on the payment of dividends.

Are all shareholders of a company entitled to receive dividends, and what proportion of the net profit is used to pay dividends?

The answer to this question, according to the lawyer, depends on when the individual became a shareholder of the company, whether he or she has paid up his or her shares in full and by the due date, and the way in which the company's articles of association regulate the distribution and payment of dividends (for example, the articles of association may provide that the dividend on paid-up shares is reduced if payment for the shares has been completed in the financial year in respect of which the dividend is paid; they may stipulate the percentage of the company's net profits to be used for the payment of the dividend; and so on.) or in the shareholders' agreement, if any (shareholders' agreements often provide that no dividends will be paid to shareholders for a certain period of time in order to, for example, invest a certain proportion of the profits in the development of the company's business, and usually regulate the percentage of net profit to be allocated to the payment of the dividends, and so on).

 

If the company's articles of association do not deal with this issue or do not provide for any exceptions, if there is no shareholders' agreement, then the following general rules apply:

(1) Dividends shall be payable to those persons who, at the close of business on the day of the general meeting of shareholders declaring the dividend, were shareholders of the company and who have paid up their shares;

2) if the share is not fully paid up and its maturity date has not expired, the shareholder's dividend is reduced in proportion to the unpaid portion of the share price;

3) if the share is not fully paid up and the payment period has expired, no dividend is payable to that shareholder;

4) the decision on the payment of dividends and the specific amount of dividends is taken by the general meeting of shareholders of the companies. The decision shall determine the proportion of profits to be allocated to the payment of dividends and the proportionate dividend per share.

In what form are dividends paid?

In practice, dividends are paid to shareholders in the form of shares or assets, or in some other form. However, the ABL provides that dividends must be paid in cash.

Courts have held that it is contrary to the provisions of the ABI to pay dividends in a form other than cash. For example, in one case, the court ruled on the conclusion of assignment of claims agreements to pay dividends. In this case, the court held that the ABI regulates the payment of dividends only in cash, and that it is therefore contrary to the law to enter into assignment of claims agreements for the payment of dividends.

 

Restrictions on the payment of dividends

 

The Companies Act provides that the General Meeting of Shareholders may not decide to declare and pay dividends if at least one of the following conditions is met:

(1) the company has outstanding debts which have fallen due before the decision is taken;

2) the amount of distributable profit for the financial year is negative(loss);

3) the company's equity is less than , or would become less if dividends were paid, than the sum of the company's authorised capital, statutory reserve, revaluation reserve and reserve for the acquisition of own shares.

According to AVOCAD, it is important to consider not only what debts the company has to its creditors and what the company's situation is before the dividend is paid. "Make sure and assess where the company will be after the dividend has been paid, i.e. whether the company will be able to pay its creditors after the dividend has been paid, and whether the company's equity will not be less than the sum of the company's share capital, the mandatory reserve, the revaluation reserve and the reserve for the acquisition of treasury shares," Sandra Mickienė advises.

However, in business, there are cases where these imperative limits are not respected. There is still a perception that the distribution of a company's profits is a matter for the company itself and its shareholders. Shareholders pay themselves dividends in spite of the legal restrictions, taking the view that non-compliance with the law is a mere formality and hoping that no one will claim against them, either now (since all shareholders have approved the payment of dividends) or in the future.

But the courts say otherwise - if dividends are paid illegally, in breach of the law, shareholders may have to repay dividends paid to the company even years later.

In 2023, the Supreme Court of Lithuania heard a case in which the insolvency administrator applied to the court for an award of dividends paid by the shareholders of the bankrupt company to the shareholders of the bankrupt company (in excess of EUR 75,000), which essentially constituted damage suffered by the bankrupt company as a result of the unlawful acts of the company shareholders. The administrator took the position that both at the time of the decision to pay the dividend (7 March 2017) and at the time of the payment of the dividend (16 August 2017), the company was in arrears to its creditors, and that therefore the decision to pay the dividend and the payment of the dividend were illegal. The Court of First Instance upheld the action and the Court of Appeal and the Court of Cassation have not substantially modified it.

 

Divorce in business: how to protect yourself from painful consequences? 

Divorce, both in personal life and in business relationships, is a difficult and emotional process. And whether the separation is between famous people, or whether the loss is in the millions or just pennies, the fact of betrayal is equally painful for everyone. Egidijus Langys, partner at AVOCAD, answers whether it can be avoided and what legal safeguards exist.

According to a business law lawyer, the most effective way to prevent tensions with a business partner is to have a shareholders' agreement. This is an agreement between the shareholders of a company that has the force of law for the parties to the contract. It can also be concluded in companies with a large number of shareholders. It should be noted that, in order to avoid a legal impasse, it is acceptable and advisable that the shareholders' agreement be signed by all shareholders of the company. 

"There are no specific restrictions on the content of this agreement, other than the mandatory provisions of the law governing corporate governance, which makes it a highly flexible legal instrument. The shareholders may set out various terms and conditions, both those governing the specifics of the company's management and those regulating the relations between the shareholders, which have the force of law for the parties to the contract," says Langys.

A key advantage of shareholders' agreements is the ability of the parties to create an agreement that reflects the individual wishes, interests and visions of the shareholders. However, it is understood that a shareholders' agreement is subject to the approval of all the parties to it, and therefore the procedure for its conclusion must achieve a proper alignment of interests and consensus between the parties.  

This is a very important safeguard of interests, as the shareholders' interests are materially affected by the agreement. For example, the order in which the company's profits are distributed, with individually negotiated profit distribution terms, for example, if the company's turnover and profits for the financial year are greater than €X, then the shareholders of the company are allocated shares in the profits. Meanwhile, in the absence of a shareholders' agreement, disputes and disagreements between shareholders can often arise and, in the absence of a shareholders' agreement, the ability of shareholders to prove their rights or claims is hampered. 

According to lawyer Egidijus Langis, the shareholders' agreement must address the financing of the company. Shareholders' agreements on the financing of the company are particularly relevant during the periods of the company's incorporation and business development, for example, shareholders may agree on additional cash contributions to be made to finance the company or on loan agreements to be concluded. Shareholders' agreements may also be used to make arrangements for actions relevant to attracting external investment, for example by dividing and allocating the duties to be performed by shareholders in order to attract investment. 

The contract must also contain provisions on corporate governance. For example, extending the rights or powers of the company's board. In order to reduce the scope of the rights of the company's manager and thereby eliminate the possibility of arbitrary decisions that are not in the company's interests, the shareholders' agreement may set out a list of significant decisions of the business or of the company's manager that are subject to the approval of the board. A shareholders' agreement is also an effective means of avoiding a legal impasse where the shareholders of a company have the same decision-making power and pursue different ways of resolving the issue at hand. For example, two shareholders of an LLC each hold 50% of the shares of the LLC, one of the shareholders votes in favour of adopting decision A and the other shareholder votes in favour of adopting decision B. Therefore, the shareholders' agreement may preemptively provide for ways to resolve the legal impasse, for example by agreeing in a compromise way that shareholder X's vote is decisive for the appointment of the company's CEO and shareholder Y's vote is decisive for the appointment of the members of the board. 

It is also worth including in the shareholders' agreement a regulation on the sale of shares in the company. It can be agreed whether, if one of the shareholders decides to sell his shares in the company, the other shareholder has the right of first refusal to acquire the shares to be sold, and the method of calculating the price of the shares to be sold can also be agreed. It should be noted that the waiver of the shareholders' pre-emptive rights may also be provided for by the shareholders of the company in the company's articles of association.

The contractual liability of the shareholders is also very important. The shareholders may agree on the application of contractual liability of the shareholders for certain defaults, but it is important that the form and amount of such liability must not be in breach of mandatory provisions of law, public policy or good morals. Moreover, it should be noted that, according to the recent case law of the Court of Appeal of Lithuania, it is the penalties provided for in the shareholders' agreement that are the essential and most effective means of ensuring compliance with the shareholders' agreement. However, a shareholder who discovers that another shareholder has breached the shareholders' agreement must act swiftly, as such fines are subject to a six-month shortened limitation period.

The agreement should also include a clause on dispute resolution procedures. A shareholders' agreement is not only relevant for the preventive nature of avoiding shareholder disputes, but it can also provide for effective dispute resolution procedures between the parties. For example, in the case of a particularly damaged relationship between shareholders, where there is no possibility of cooperation between the parties and the likelihood of a peaceful resolution of the dispute disappears, but where the actions and conduct of the shareholders do not constitute a legitimate basis for the application of the compulsory sale of shares provided for in the Civil Code, the procedures and conditions for the compulsory redemption or sale of the shares, as negotiated in the shareholders' agreement, can provide the circumstances for a proper and effective resolution of the shareholders' dispute. The shareholders' agreement may also agree on the jurisdiction to be established for shareholders' disputes. 

A shareholders' agreement is drafted to regulate both the company's corporate governance and the relationship between shareholders, and a timely shareholders' agreement is a great preventive way to avoid legal disputes and painful divorces.