Can a shareholder be convicted of credit fraud?

With the information in the public domain that law enforcement authorities have opened a pre-trial investigation into suspected credit fraud in a company owned by the Prime Minister, questions arise as to what the allegations mean, who can be prosecuted, and whether only the head of the company is liable, or whether the shareholder is also liable.

There are a number of cases of farmers and entrepreneurs who have been tried for fraudulently obtaining loans or aid, so this case is neither new nor exceptional.

What constitutes credit fraud?

According to the Criminal Code of the Republic of Lithuania, credit fraud is a situation where a loan, aid, subsidy or grant is obtained by fraud. Such acts are qualified as a criminal offence under Article 207 of the CC.

Fraud usually involves misrepresentation, including information about the borrower's financial situation. However, such information is only considered fraudulent if it was decisive for the creditor's decision to grant financing.

The objective part of Article 207 of the Criminal Code is that the perpetrator obtains a loan or credit by deceiving the victim. The person must be aware that he or she is acting fraudulently and is seeking a pecuniary advantage or knowingly allowing damage to occur. It should be noted that the fact that a loan has been illegally obtained, irrespective of how it has been used, is sufficient for criminal liability.

For example, if a person knows that his or her existing company does not qualify for soft loans, but sets up a new company, obtains a loan and uses the funds to operate the old company, this could amount to credit fraud.

Setting up companies or selling assets is not prohibited. However, if such transactions are carried out with the criminal intent of obtaining financing by deception, they may be considered a crime.

Who can be prosecuted?

As a rule, specific natural persons acting on behalf of a legal person are prosecuted. This can include:

CEO - if he or she decided to apply for a loan and then used the funds for the benefit of another company;

  • Company staff responsible for drafting or signing documents;
  • Shareholders - if they gave instructions to carry out unlawful acts or took other decisions related to the offence.

Can a shareholder be convicted?

Being a shareholder in a company that has received credit does not automatically mean that you will be prosecuted. However, if it is established that the shareholder not only invested, but also effectively controlled the company, exercised shareholder rights, gave instructions or encouraged fraudulent conduct, he or she may be liable.

Evidence of shareholder-manager communication, shareholder decisions and shareholder knowledge of activities is crucial in such investigations. It also assesses whether the manager was not merely a formal figure (a figurehead).

A shareholder can only be prosecuted if his role goes beyond that of a passive shareholder to active participation in the illegal activity - especially if he acts as a de facto manager.

What are the possible consequences?

In addition to personal criminal liability (fines, imprisonment or restriction of liberty), the company itself can also be sentenced. It can be fined, restricted or even wound up. It may also be liable to claim damages.

Egidijus Kieras, Attorney at Law, AVOCAD

Inaccurate shareholder data - a fine or even criminal liability?

While it may seem that formal registers are just "paperwork", it is worth remembering that mistakes or delays in submitting shareholder data to JADIS (the Information System of Legal Entities Participants) can cost money and have far more serious legal consequences.

According to the Companies Act, as soon as a private limited liability company is established or its shareholders change, all relevant information on the shareholders must be submitted to JADIS within 5 working days: their details, the number of shares, the date of acquisition etc.

Although the manager may delegate this responsibility to another person, the responsibility remains with the manager. This means that if data is not provided, is provided late or is incorrect, it is the manager who is responsible.

Domantas Velykis, a lawyer at AVOCAD, explains what legal liability may be imposed on the head of a company for failure to provide shareholder data of a private limited liability company, late provision of data, or provision of incorrect data .

According to the lawyer, in a standard case, a company manager who violates the obligation or procedure for submitting shareholder data to the JADIS is subject to an administrative penalty of between six hundred and one thousand four hundred and fifty euros, i.e. administrative liability.

The legal basis for this penalty is established in the Code of Administrative Offences, which stipulates that, firstly, the submission of incorrect data of a legal entity and other information to be provided to the data manager of the Register of Legal Entities, the information system manager of participants of legal entities, and secondly, the failure to provide data of a legal entity and other information to be provided to the data manager of the Register of Legal Entities, the information system manager of participants of legal entities in due time according to the procedure provided for by the legal acts, shall entail the aforementioned administrative liability for the head of the legal entity.

Given the similarities between administrative liability and criminal liability, a reasonable question arises - can the head of a company be held criminally liable for failure to provide shareholder data, late provision of data, or provision of incorrect data?

Domantas Velykis reminds that the Supreme Court of Lithuania has heard a case in which a question was raised about the possibility of applying two criminal offences for false information of shareholders in the public register, when the head of the company, being the sole shareholder and head of the company, sold 50 shares of the company to another person by a share sale and purchase agreement in 2014, but in 2017 the head of the company submitted an application to the Centre for Registers to register himself as the sole shareholder of the company, falsely stating that he had acquired the entire number of shares in 2016, when in fact he had not recovered the shares from another person.

First of all, the Supreme Court of Lithuania found that the Share Purchase and Sale Agreement concluded in 2014 was valid - it was neither annulled nor declared invalid. Therefore, the Court assessed whether the company's CEO could have committed a crime by submitting an application to the Centre of Registers to register himself as the sole shareholder, i.e. whether he had illegally acquired someone else's property, in this case, 50 shares which were already owned by another person.

In this situation, the lawyer said, it is important to know that company shares can only be transferred after a certain transaction (for example, a sale or a gift) has been concluded and an entry has been made in the securities accounts. In contrast, the JADIS is only an information system that registers changes in shareholders that have already taken place, but the entry in it does not in itself create ownership rights.

"Therefore, a manager's mere request to register himself as the sole shareholder does not guarantee that he has legally acquired those shares. As such entries do not reflect a real transaction, the court concluded that this action cannot be considered fraud - the manager did not actually acquire shares or rights related to them that do not belong to him," says Domantas Velykis, lawyer at AVOCAD.

Secondly, the issue was whether the company's director, by submitting an application to the Centre of Registers to register himself as the sole shareholder and by providing false information, could be considered as the creator or user of a forged document - in other words, whether his actions fall within the offence of forgery of a document.

In assessing whether such an act is genuinely dangerous, it is important to take into account whether the provision of false information has led to real legal consequences - whether the rights or interests of others have been violated.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania noted that in this case only a formal situation had been created which gave the impression that the CEO was the sole shareholder. However, such an entry is not sufficient on its own - it did not produce any real effects. Although, in theory, such information could have been used, for example, in transactions with third parties, there was no evidence that the manager intended to harm or actually took advantage of it.

In conclusion, the court concluded that although the manager's application to the Centre of Registers contained incorrect information, it was not sufficiently dangerous or harmful to give rise to criminal liability. His actions did not cause real damage to other persons or to the legal system and did not therefore amount to falsification of a document.

Thus, when inaccurate shareholder data is entered in JADIS, the most common administrative liability is a fine of between €600 and €1,450. Meanwhile, criminal liability can only be imposed in exceptional cases where it is clear that the director has deliberately provided incorrect data and has used it to his advantage, for example, to enter into transactions or to deceive others.

 

 

Selling on Instagram or TikTok? You're already an entrepreneur - even if you don't think so yourself 

Social networks have become more than just a place to share photos - they are the new shop window. Increasingly, products are offered on Instagram, TikTok or Facebook, and orders go through messages. Simple, fast and no headache of setting up an e-shop. But there's a "but": if you're selling, it's a business. And there are clear rules for business. What are they? - Egidijus Kieras, attorney at AVOCAD, answers .

Not registered? That doesn't mean you're not an entrepreneur

According to the lawyer, if you offer goods or services on a regular basis, advertise, accept payments and ask your customers for a delivery address, you are a businessman. It doesn't matter whether you are trading as a small partnership, a limited liability company or as a natural person. If you meet the criteria of an entrepreneur, you are also subject to the requirements.

What is a must for every social media marketer?

Whether you find customers through Reels or Story, you need to ensure compliance with the law, for example:

  • Before the product is sold, provide the consumer with information about the product and its price,
  • who you are (name, title, contacts),
  • explain how the consumer can return the goods,
  • exercising the buyer's right to withdraw from the purchase within 14 days (in the case of a non-food item or individual product)
  • have at least a simple privacy policy if you collect any information (e.g. email, address);
  • inform you about the dispute resolution procedure.

Lawyer Egidijus Kieras stresses that even through Instagram posts, it must be clear to the buyer what they are buying, from whom and under what conditions.

Under the EU Consumer Rights Directive and Lithuanian law, e-commerce on social networks is not "special" - it is subject to the same rules as any other e-shop. And if you're still collecting customer names, phone numbers or addresses, welcome to GDPR territory.

"The Data Protection Inspectorate has repeatedly fined small businesses for collecting customer information without any clear policy or consent. And no, 'send us a message' is not a sufficient form of consent or contract," says the lawyer.

What are the real risks?

Sellers often say: "I'm too small to be of interest." But according to Kier, any dissatisfied buyer can complain. This could lead to an inspection by the Consumer Rights Protection Authority, possible fines or even blocking of the account for violations. You may also have to answer personally if you are not a legal entity.

Taxes are another risk. If you haven't registered your business, you could also face the IRS.

"Doing business through social networks is not a 'grey area'. The law has long since caught up with practice. The sooner you realise this, the less likely you are to move from consumer comments to the eyes of the Consumer Protection Authority and the Tax Inspectorate," warns an AVOCAD lawyer.

The question is - what if I just sell clothes on Vinted? Is that also considered a business?

The answer depends on the scope and systematicity. According to Egidijus Kieras, the one-off sale of a second-hand jumper is not really a commercial activity. However, if you sell a lot, on a regular basis and for profit, it can already be considered a business. In this case, there is an obligation to register the activity, to comply with consumer protection and data processing rules, and to declare income.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has clarified that even a natural person can be considered a "seller" if he or she regularly sells goods via an online platform, even if they are second-hand. Therefore, it is not what you sell, but how often and for what purpose.

 

Dividends: when are they illegal?  

The end of the financial year is a good time to learn more about dividends. This is an important aspect of a company's financial planning, but according to lawyers, businesses often forget a fundamental rule: dividends should only be paid when the company is stable and the interests of creditors are not affected. If a company has outstanding debts that should have been paid, the payment of dividends may be considered unlawful.

According to Domantas Velykis, Associate at AVOCAD, the Law on Joint Stock Companies provides that dividends are a share of profit allocated to a shareholder in proportion to the value of the shares owned by the shareholder. Simply put, dividends are a share of profit distributed to shareholders according to the number of shares they hold. Normally, companies allocate only a portion of their profits to dividends and invest the rest in business development, innovation or other needs.

The distribution of profits takes place after the end of the financial year, when the company's annual accounts are approved. The General Meeting of Shareholders decides on the payment of dividends and their amount. Although dividends are usually paid once a year, the law allows companies to distribute dividends more frequently - for example, every six months.

Only those persons who are shareholders of the company at the close of business on the day of the General Meeting of Shareholders or who are otherwise legally entitled to dividends are entitled to receive dividends. In the event of a subsequent acquisition of shares, the new shareholder is not entitled to past dividends but may be entitled to future payments.

Dividends must be decided in accordance with the legal framework. "If dividends are distributed in violation of the law, the shareholder may be obliged to repay the amount received to the company," notes Domantas Velykis. The Companies Act provides that if a shareholder knew or should have known that dividends were unlawfully distributed, the company is entitled to recover the amounts paid.

According to AVOCAD's lawyer, there are three cases where a company cannot decide to pay dividends:

  1. If the company has outstanding liabilities that have already fallen due.
  2. If the company's distributable profit is negative, a loss has been incurred.
  3. If the company's equity is too low or would fall to a critical threshold after the payment of dividends.

The Supreme Court of Lithuania has stated that dividends should only be paid when the company is stable and such payments do not harm the interests of creditors. One of the indicators of the stability of an undertaking is its ability to pay its creditors. Therefore, if a company has outstanding debts which should have been paid, the payment of dividends may be considered unlawful.

However, case law recognises that if a company, after having declared a dividend, pays the outstanding debt before actually paying the dividend to the shareholders, the infringement is deemed to be eliminated. In such a case, the dividends paid to the shareholders would not be considered unlawful.

Another relevant situation, according to the lawyer, is if the company agrees with the creditor to postpone the payment of the debt by adopting new payment terms. Case law shows that in such cases the obligation is not considered to be in arrears and therefore the granting of dividends can be considered legitimate if the company complies with the new payment terms. In this way, the company can safeguard the interests of its shareholders without infringing the rights of its creditors.

Thus, the distribution of dividends is a delicate process that requires careful legal assessment. It is important for companies not only to comply with the law, but also to take a responsible view of their financial position and liabilities in order to avoid potential legal consequences.

Recruiting a manager: what are the biggest mistakes and what has changed since the New Year?

The recruitment of a CEO is a key element of an organisation's activities, requiring not only legal clarity but also a clear division of responsibilities. The manager of a legal entity is responsible for the day-to-day running of the company and his/her decisions have a direct impact on the success and reputation of the organisation. However, in practice, according to lawyers, there are often situations where the employment of a manager teeters on the brink of illegal employment.

Why this happens, what mistakes are made and how to avoid legal violations in this situation and how to properly organise the recruitment of a manager - answers AVOCAD Managing Partner, attorney-at-law Egidijus Langys.

The CEO is appointed by the company's board of directors or, if there is no board of directors, by the general meeting of shareholders. This body also approves the manager's remuneration, the job description and decides on bonuses or disciplinary action.

The Labour Code stipulates that a manager must have an employment contract, except for exceptions provided for by law. "This means that a manager's activity in a company without a properly concluded employment contract may be considered illegal employment," points out Langys.

While these requirements are clear, in practice companies often face situations where non-compliance leads to legal and financial consequences.

According to the lawyer, it is not uncommon for company managers not to be given employment contracts on the grounds that they are appointed by the shareholders, or not to be informed of their employment. This omission also leads to illegal employment, which has a number of negative consequences for companies.

The lawyer notes that a common mistake is the incorrect submission of information to Sodra. Failure to notify the manager's employment or late notification can not only lead to fines, but also hinder the provision of social security benefits to the manager. If the company's HR department fails to notice that the manager's employment contract must be registered in the Sodra system before the start of his/her employment. This exposes the company to administrative fines and the manager to temporary loss of insurance cover.

As of 1 January 2025, the Labour Code changes to provide that the conclusion of an employment contract and the recruitment of the head of a legal person must be notified to the territorial division of the State Social Insurance Fund Board at least one hour before the scheduled start of work.

"It is likely that this provision will not raise any questions about the proper recruitment of a manager, and that the amendment will be a help and a reminder to the company's accountants or HR representatives who perform the company's recruitment functions," notes AVOCAD's lawyer.

 

Actual and formal head of the company - who is liable for damages?

"I'm just a placeholder...", "I was only formally appointed here, the real manager was someone else...", "my friends asked me to be formally present...", "I didn't handle the money, another manager did". These and similar excuses often baffle lawyers when dealing with managerial responsibility.

"It may be the result of innocent naivety or blind trust, or perhaps a lack of basic understanding and knowledge, but sometimes these cases can also be the result of deliberate action," says Egidijus Langys, Managing Partner at AVOCAD. He says that the most important thing is not to blame, but to help managers avoid such situations or to get out of them as soon as possible. So, how can we protect ourselves from the potential risks that can arise from the formal performance of managerial duties?

Limits to the responsibilities of the actual and formal manager

Before the holidays, the Supreme Court of Lithuania (SCL) issued an important clarification that distinguishes between the formal, or in other words legal, and de facto liability of a company's manager. This clarification is of particular relevance for those who find themselves caught between formal duties and real managerial control.

"Today's leader, in my opinion, is either a hero or a madman," Langys wryly remarks. According to the lawyer, managers must work with the utmost care, competence and compliance with the law, because the limits of liability can be wide and sometimes very unexpected.

The mere existence of a de facto manager does not exclude the liability of a formal manager. If both managers committed illegal acts, the question is whether they acted as accomplices. "It must be assessed whether the managers acted jointly with the intention to cause damage (subjective complicity) or whether the interaction of several actions simply led to the consequences (objective complicity)," explains Egidijus Langys.

Liability for aiding and abetting in court

One of the most common cases is when a person agrees to become a formal manager out of friendship or a simple request. Such a manager may believe that nothing serious will happen: after all, he or she has done nothing but sign a few documents. "But even in this case, the liability remains because the activity was carried out in his name. The formally appointed manager who signs the documents often does not look into the details and relies on the actual manager, but in court all this proves subjective complicity," warns Langys.

It is therefore necessary to assess the risks if you are asked to become a formal manager, whatever the purpose. "If you are already a formal manager and blindly follow the instructions of others, you should step down as soon as possible. It is important to remember that leadership is not only a responsibility, but also a huge risk, so a responsible approach to this role is vital.

What liability can a manager face?

According to AVOCAD's Managing Partner, the manager may be subject to civil, administrative or even criminal liability depending on the nature and extent of the damage caused. "For example, if a manager signed documents without looking at the information contained in them and this caused financial damage, he or she may be liable for damages," explains Mr Langys. In cases of criminal liability, the manager can face fines, imprisonment or even imprisonment.

"That's why it's important not only to understand the limits of your responsibilities, but also to ensure that all actions are legal and justified. Leadership is not only an opportunity to develop your career, but also a responsibility for all the consequences that may arise from poor decisions," emphasises Langys.

Current ruling: order of the Supreme Court of Lithuania in civil case No e3K-3-243-403/2024 of 16 December 2024.

Laurynas Staniulis. The price of risk appetite

Recently, the market has seen a number of bond offers that have surprised the market with the level of returns offered. Investors have been offered bonds with yields as high as 12% or more. Integre Trans UAB, one of the fastest growing transport and logistics companies, was no exception.

In spring 2023, Integre Trans launched a €4,000,000 bond issue with an impressive interest rate of 12% + 6-month EURIBOR, to be redeemed in May 2026. However, already on 6 May 2024, the company announced its planned restructuring.

Very recently, the market received news that Integre Trans UAB's restructuring efforts were not successful and on 17 July 2024 the Vilnius Regional Court opened bankruptcy proceedings against Integre Trans UAB. Subsequently, the Court of Appeal of Lithuania annulled the decision and referred the matter for reconsideration.

What lies ahead for bondholders.

It should be recalled that the bonds issued by UAB Integre Trans were not secured by pledges or other collateral. This means that, in the event of the company's bankruptcy, the bondholders are simply the company's creditors without any privileges.

In the event of insolvency, the bondholders would be included in the creditors' queue on a general basis and their claims would be jointly satisfied with other creditors, but only after the claims of the mortgage holders, the employees and the claims of the State Tax Inspectorate (VMI) and the Social Insurance Institution (Sodros) had been satisfied.

Thus, the 70% discount on UAB Integre Trans bonds is available today, which clearly reflects investor sentiment.

Of course, it is difficult to predict at this stage how the restructuring case will turn out and, if it does, whether it will be possible to restructure the business and avoid insolvency, but two things can already be said today:

  1. The bonds will not be redeemed on the due date.
  2. Investors will not get the promised 12% + 6 month EURIBOR return.

UAB Integre Trans bonds are currently available at a 70% discount.

So, once again, a bond is simply a debt security issued by a company or government. It is a document that gives the holder of the bond the right to apply to the entity that issued the bond at the end of the bond period. The entity that issued the bond is obliged to repay the money invested. In other words, the bondholder and the issuing entity are linked by an elementary loan relationship.

Sometimes it seems that underwriting bonds is a way of avoiding the requirements for informed investors by making it possible for people to invest - to buy bonds - who are not prepared to properly assess the risks involved. This is particularly the case when bonds are issued by collective investment undertakings for informed investors, commonly known as funds.

I have already mentioned that in recent years we have seen a trend towards very high yields and relatively short maturities. In the market, bonds with yields as low as 15% may, in fact, mean that, for one reason or another, traditional financing methods, such as loans from financial institutions or investment funds, are not available.

It is important to note that bonds offered on the market are usually not secured by mortgaged real estate, but rather by a pledge of the shares of the company that issued the bond as collateral. In terms of whether such collateral provides real protection, the answer is probably not.

If shares are pledged, it is likely that the issuer does not have any assets to pledge or that those assets are already pledged. This means that if the worst case scenario does occur and the entity is unable to redeem the bonds, the claims of the bondholders would only be satisfied after the claims of the mortgage lender have been satisfied and only if there is any money left would the claims of the bondholders be satisfied. I would therefore probably not be very far wrong in saying that such bonds are, in essence, simply a loan without any additional security for the bondholder.

It should also be noted that bonds can be placed to refinance an existing bond issue, while the source of redemption for a new bond is a future bond issue. This pattern of short-term high-yield bonds implies that the bonds are not issued to finance new activities that would directly result in a source of redemption, but rather to temporarily balance cash flows, build equity or the like.

The natural question is whether the issuer will be able to refinance the bonds at maturity and service even more expensive bonds if necessary. Probably not, which leads to the view that the bonds issued simply reflect the issuers' belief in a positive market development. But the question "what if..." remains unanswered.

Sometimes the answer to this question can be deduced, albeit indirectly, from the assessment of the issuer. If the issuer is a project company that is part of a large group of companies and the bonds are not guaranteed by the "parent" company, we may consider that the "parent" company is aware of the risks of the project and is not prepared to fulfil its obligations to the bondholders at any cost. Of course, these are only assumptions and one would like to believe that, in the event of the issuer's inability to meet its obligations, there would be a consolidation of the Group's forces to redeem the bonds. However, the reluctance to commit formally leaves the question open.

Bonds are not a new way of raising funds and are certainly not a threat in themselves. Bonds, like any other investment, involve risks that each investor has to assess individually according to his or her risk appetite. However, in any case, investing in bonds should not only involve a careful assessment of the issuer or the collateral, but also an understanding of the objectives of the bond issue. Better still, you should outsource the assessment of these risks to experts in the field - investment funds.

What can we learn?

Perhaps the main idea is that the rate of return is proportional to the investment risk.

Bonds are a complex investment product that is not designed for "household" investors.

 

Disagreements between shareholders: can a manager restrict information?

One of the fundamental rights that shares give their holders is the right to participate in the management of the company. In order to participate in the management of a private limited liability company, a shareholder naturally needs to have access to the company's documents and information that may be relevant to decisions relating to the management, development and investment of the company. When relations between shareholders and the company's management bodies are good, based on trust and the pursuit of common objectives, everything is simple. But what about when the relationship is complicated - does the company's CEO or board of directors have the ability to restrict shareholders' right to information? Sandra Mickienė, Associate at AVOCAD, talks about this .

Although shareholders invest their own funds in the company's capital and should, for this reason alone, seem to have a right to all information relating to the company's activities, the reality is that shareholders' right to information is not unlimited. The law provides for three types of information that shareholders may request:

First, a shareholder is entitled to information of a general nature specifically listed in the Law (such information includes: the Articles of Association, the annual and interim financial statements, the minutes of the general meetings of shareholders and any other documents of the company that are required to be made public by law). As this information is publicly available, it should not be classified as a company's business or trade secret or confidential information and should not be refused by the company to a shareholder. This means that the company is obliged to make this information (these documents) available to the company's shareholders at all times.

Second, a shareholder is entitled to other information and documents that are specifically set out in the company's articles of association. In other words, if the company's articles of association specify additional company documents to which shareholders are entitled to have access, the company will be obliged to make these documents available to shareholders if they so request.

Third, the information and documents that the shareholder needs to comply with other legal requirements. This category includes all documents relating to the company's business secrets and confidential information. A shareholder seeking this type of information from the company should justify the legal requirements for which the information is needed. If the shareholder does not demonstrate (justify) the need for the confidential information to fulfil the legal requirements, the company may refuse to provide the shareholder with this information.

Therefore, the answer to the question whether the director of a company has the possibility to restrict the shareholders' right to information is as follows: the law provides for the possibility for companies to refuse to provide information and documents when the latter relate to the company's commercial or industrial secrets or confidential information.

Probably the most serious problems with the implementation of the shareholders' right to information arise when companies operate in accordance with the model articles of association. First of all, the model articles of association do not provide for any additional documents to be made available to the shareholder on request. Although the Model Articles of Association provide that the shareholder is entitled to have access to all documents of the company, they also provide, in another sentence, that the company may refuse to give the shareholder access to and/or copies of documents relating to the company's business secrets or confidential information. In other words, the Model Articles provide for the same restrictions on the provision of information to shareholders as the Act. Therefore, a shareholder would only be able to receive publicly available documents without restriction under the Model Articles, and in respect of all other information, the company has the right to refuse to provide the shareholder with the additional information and documents requested.

So, if a company operates under the model articles of association and there are only two shareholders (one of whom is not only a shareholder, but also a director of the company with, for example, a larger or equivalent shareholding), whose relationship is in a state of disrepair, it is obvious that, such model articles of association, on the basis of which the company operates, enable the shareholder, who is also the manager, to manipulate the situation by withholding from the other shareholder all the information he has requested under the pretext of the protection of confidential information, including trade/production secrets. A shareholder with a minority/equivalent shareholding does not even have the possibility to remove such a manager from office. Obviously, such shareholders are in an unequal position: one shareholder, being also the manager of the company, has access to all the company's data, including financial documents, trade secrets, etc., whereas the other shareholder may be (reasonably or unreasonably) restricted in this respect.

How can you protect yourself from such situations?

In particular, we would suggest that companies should not be set up on the basis of model articles of association, but on the basis of individualised articles of association, which could extend the list of information or documents that must be provided to shareholders. Individualised articles of association would not only benefit shareholders in this respect, but also in order to limit the powers of the manager, which are quite broad under the model articles of association (for example, the manager of a company may, on the basis of the model articles of association, enter into any contract for the transfer, investment, lease, acquisition, mortgage, pledge, hypothecation, guarantee or warranty of fixed assets, irrespective of the carrying amount or the selling price of those assets, without the need for the approval of a general meeting of the shareholders).

If shareholders find the model articles of association convenient due to simpler procedures for amending them (amendments can be made electronically through the self-service system of the Centre of Registers) and lower costs (amendments do not need to be notarised when made through the self-service system of the Centre of Registers), another option to expand the list of information to be provided to shareholders would be the conclusion of a shareholders' agreement. It could not only extend the list of information to be provided to shareholders, but also regulate the procedure for the disposal of the information, establish the division of shareholders' competences, limit the manager's competences by specifying which decisions require the approval of, for example, all shareholders, provide for the specific conditions of the procedure for the replacement of the manager to enable those shareholders who have a smaller or equivalent shareholding to take action, etc.

If the drawing up of both the individualised articles of association and the shareholders' agreement is not possible due to conflicting shareholder relations or other circumstances, if the company refuses to provide the shareholder with the information requested by the shareholder, the shareholder has the right to apply to the court and ask the court to oblige the company to provide the information he or she requested.

When to go to court?

In this context, the Supreme Court of Lithuania has provided significant interpretations that are worth considering when deciding whether to apply to court and whether to protect one's rights as a shareholder:

  • Although the law gives the company the right to refuse to give a shareholder access to and copies of documents relating to the company's trade secrets or confidential information, this right is not absolute. It is not sufficient to state declaratively that the documents requested by the shareholder relate to trade secrets or confidential information. The company bears the burden of proving that the information or documents which the shareholder requests to be disclosed relate to its trade secrets or confidential information. The courts will assess in each case whether the information is reasonably capable of being classified as a trade secret or confidential information.
  • The data constituting the content of confidential information are not always trade secrets. Information that can be classified as a trade secret is essentially subject to three requirements: secrecy, value and reasonable efforts to preserve the information. Information shall be regarded as a trade secret if it has actual or potential commercial value by reason of the fact that it is not known to third parties and cannot be freely accessed by the owner of the information, or by any other person to whom the owner has entrusted the information, by reason of the fact that he or she has made reasonable efforts to preserve the secrecy of that information. Thus, for confidential information to qualify as a trade secret, it must first have some value and the fact that the information is not made public does not mean that it has commercial value.
  • The company should also justify that such provision of copies of information or documents relating to its trade secrets or confidential information to the shareholder would be prejudicial to the company or otherwise prejudice its legitimate interests.
  • The term 'compliance with the requirements of the law' includes the shareholder's interest and need to obtain information also for the purpose of exercising his right as a shareholder to participate in the management of the company, and therefore the claimant, when applying to the court for an order to require the company to provide the information he has requested, may simply refer to his right to participate in the management of the company as a basis for his claim in the abstract, in other words, it is not necessary to specify the specific provision of the law on which he is requesting that the company provide the information he has requested.

The modern company director: legal challenges and risks

Endless geopolitical tensions and military conflicts, shifting trade patterns and significant economic fluctuations are the challenges of modern business. Maximising profits without serious legal concerns is the ultimate goal of today's managers. Does everyone manage to break even and where are the biggest risks? Egidijus Langys, Managing Partner of AVOCAD, talks more about this and the limits of a manager's responsibility .

The Chief Executive Officer is the decision-maker who first organises the day-to-day running of the company. He or she hires and fires employees, concludes and terminates their contracts of employment, gives them incentives and imposes penalties. The manager acts on behalf of the company and has the right to conclude transactions, except where the company's articles of association provide for quantitative representation of the company. In short, he/she is responsible for the organisation of the company's activities and the achievement of its objectives.

Must act honestly and reasonably, with loyalty and confidentiality

As well as ensuring the day-to-day running of the company, a manager must also fulfil fiduciary duties of loyalty and care. "This means that a manager must act honestly and reasonably towards the legal entity and other members of the legal entity's organs, be loyal to the company and observe confidentiality. He must avoid situations where his personal interests conflict or may conflict with the interests of the legal person. A director should not confuse the assets of the legal entity with his or her own assets, use them or information obtained in his or her capacity as a member of an organ of the legal entity for personal benefit or for the benefit of a third party without the consent of the members of the legal entity, etc. The duty of a director is to act solely in the interests of the company," the lawyer stresses.

According to Mr Langis, a company's CEO must meet the objective criteria of a careful and qualified businessman. According to the lawyer, the duties of care and loyalty will not be breached if the decision is made in good faith - without conflict of interest, after having investigated the information about the possible consequences of the decision, after having been provided with all the necessary information, and after having evaluated whether the business decision does not exceed a reasonable commercial risk. In making decisions, the manager must also consider the normal business and commercial activities and the nature of the business of the company, taking into account the degree of risk tolerance of the company.

The manager and the creditor do not have a direct contractual relationship, and the manager's fiduciary duties to take into account the interests of creditors when taking decisions relating to the company's business activities only arise when the company's financial situation deteriorates. "The manager's liability to creditors arises only if the company is unable to satisfy the creditor's claims on its own," notes Langys.

Creditor's right to bring a direct action for damages against a company's director

A creditor can bring a direct action against the directors and shareholders of a company in two cases: where there is direct damage to the creditor and where the bankruptcy is declared intentional and the directors or shareholders are found to be guilty of intentional bankruptcy.

Liability of the manager can only arise if it is established that the manager of the company has acted unlawfully in order to infringe the rights of a particular creditor (misrepresentation, misrepresentation in the conclusion of a contract between the company and a particular creditor, or other unfair acts directed at a particular creditor). A director is also liable where those acts have caused damage to the creditor and the company is unable to meet the creditor's claims itself. Moreover, damage does not include the general insolvency of the company or a reduction in its solvency, which affects the individual creditor and other creditors of the company equally.

According to the lawyer, if a direct action against the manager is brought by the tax authorities, the unpaid taxes can be considered as damage caused to the creditor, as the taxes are only legally due to the creditor. If the manager evades the payment of tax, his actions must be regarded as directed against the creditor in question. "A very important point in such situations is whether the company would have been able to pay the tax at the time when it should have been calculated and paid," points out Mr Langys.

Risks and legitimacy of business decision-making

Langys points out that a business transaction that ends in a loss does not automatically mean that the manager has acted unlawfully. Liability is not for the negative economic result of the action, but for the legality of the actions taken at the time of the decision. "A business decision taken without breaching the duty of care and loyalty is considered lawful, even if it is detrimental to the company", says the lawyer.

The lawyer points out that all managers must be aware of the possible consequences of their decisions, which can range from damages to disqualification from holding the office of manager of a public or private legal person or from being a member of a collegiate management body for a period of 1 to 5 years. Improper decisions by a manager may also lead to administrative and criminal liability.

 

 

 

 

­­­

 

 

Lawyer's tips for e-business: how to sell not only profitably but also legally

Often, businesses only become interested in the legal requirements of their business when they encounter problems, but law is not just about solving disputes, it helps prevent them from happening in the first place. "Those who know this rule are much less likely to face legal challenges, which cost much more to resolve than to prevent," says Egidijus Kieras, an attorney at AVOCAD. He highlighted the most important international legal aspects of e-commerce for the participants of the GlobalShop "Innovation Agency" Academy, which are essential for e-business developers.

According to the lawyer, anyone starting and running an e-business should be aware that non-compliance with the law is punishable by a fine of up to 4% of annual turnover. "If fines don't scare you, be aware that if the infringements are repeated, your e-marketplace could simply be blocked," warns Egidijus Kieras.

What is important for an entrepreneur to do with e-commerce?

According to Kier, almost every action has a legal expression, so the rules of trade are set out in law. Acts come in two flavours: national law and international law.

Each country makes laws that apply only to itself, regulating the activities of individuals, their requirements, etc. For example, there may be differences in terms of return periods, delivery, etc.

The rules and requirements for e-commerce are, in most cases, laid down in directives issued by the EU, but they are not directly applicable in the country and each country has to incorporate the provisions of the directives into its national legislation, i.e. issue laws, e.g.: after the adoption of a directive, the Civil Code or other laws in Lithuania are revised.

"Trade rules need to be harmonised according to the rules of the specific country where the goods are sold to consumers. A website is tailored to the consumers of that particular country if it is available in their language, the presentation of the website is automatically adapted to the consumer's country (with appropriate extensions), and there are other clear indications that the offer of the goods is a targeted act in that particular territory," says the lawyer.

Distance Purchase Agreement - what must be included in it?

The legal relationship between the consumer and the trader is established by the sales contract. What must it contain?

  • Key product features. Although, according to the lawyer, it seems to be very clear to everyone, there are a number of fines for this. Last year, the State Office for Consumer Rights Protection fined €45,624 to a company" that operates an online shop. The Office found that the information published by the portal was incomplete and that the goods presented to consumers differed from their description, for example, they were scratched, there were certain irregularities, etc. Thus, the bottom line is that the description of the product must be specific and not mislead the consumer.
  • Trader's identity: name, address, telephone, email;
  • The total price of the goods or services, including taxes and other costs. If the total cost cannot reasonably be calculated in advance, the method used to calculate the price must be indicated. "The important thing to understand here is that if you don't specify the total price including all taxes, you won't be able to collect them from the buyer later," notes Kieras.
  • If you apply personalisation of the price, this must be stated. The buyer must understand that you have personalised the price he sees according to certain automated criteria. What problem does this rule solve? Businesses can use algorithms based on a consumer's purchase history or the websites they visit to determine whether a consumer is interested in a particular product, and if the answer is yes, they increase the price of the product or service. So, if you have personalised the price, you need to make that clear to the buyer.
  • Payment, delivery, the procedure for performance of the contract and the period by which the trader undertakes to deliver the goods.
  • If a right of withdrawal applies, the conditions, time limit and procedure for exercising this right, as well as a model withdrawal form. If there is no possibility to withdraw, this must also be stated. If applicable, it shall state that the consumer must bear the costs of returning the goods after withdrawal. If you do not specify this beforehand, you will not be able to claim later.
  • A reminder that there is a legal guarantee on the goods (2 years).
  • Commercial warranties (warranties provided by the manufacturer or seller).
  • Illegitimate dispute procedures.

And these are just some of the conditions required for a contract.

What is unfair trading?

Egidijus Kieras also points out which actions are considered unfair in all EU countries and which should be avoided. A commercial practice is unfair if it prevents the consumer from making an informed decision or influences his free economic behaviour:

  1. Illegal indication of the reliability and quality mark.
  2. Fraudulent claiming of a licence (authorisation), or product approval.
  3. You make an offer with a price, but you know that you won't actually sell the goods on those terms.
  4. Misleading claims that the product will only be available for an extremely short period of time.
  5. Specifying the consumer's statutory rights as an exclusive condition of the offer.
  6. Fraudulent closures by announcing sales.
  7. Deceptive claims that the product cures.
  8. Offering to enter a competition or receive a prize, but not giving the prizes or their equivalents specified.
  9. Including an invoice or similar payment document in marketing materials.
  10. Creating a pyramid distribution system.
  11. Inappropriate labelling of advertising.
  12. Rating.

What is important to know about ranking on an e-marketplace?

E-Commerce operators that allow consumers to search for products offered by different sellers must inform consumers of the main criteria that determine the ranking of the products provided to the consumer as a result of his search query. For example, it may indicate that products are ranked on the basis of price, the ratings of the customers who have purchased the product, popularity, or a combination of different criteria. If the ranking of a product in the search results is based on paid advertising or other payments received from the relevant merchants, this information should also be clearly indicated to users.

Genuineness of feedback, who guarantees it?

Where a trader makes product reviews available to the consumer, information on whether and how the trader ensures that the reviews published are from consumers who have actually used or purchased the product shall be considered essential. The aim is to better inform the online shopper so that he is not misled and makes a correct, informed decision.

It is up to the entrepreneur to ensure that the review is genuine. "Usually the authorities ask for clarification and then you have to provide evidence that the reviews are written by your real customers, as well as how the reviews were obtained, whether the users have the possibility to make negative comments as well, and whether they are visible to the public," notes Kieras.

In his view, these questions must be answered, as failure to do so could result in sanctions.

The delivery deadline must be taken seriously

Delivery must be made within 30 days. If the consumer does not receive the goods within this period, he has the right to terminate the distance contract and the seller must immediately refund any money paid by the consumer. "In practice, the deadline depends more on the consumer's wishes. However, this time limit should be taken seriously, as many of the fines imposed are because of this", says Kieras.

The lawyer advises that, in any case, businesses must cooperate with both the consumer and the authorities. "The fines are then much lower, even if infringements are found. Remember that the most common sanctions are those for failure to refund funds on time and failure to respond to consumer complaints on time," notes Egidijus Kieras.