Unilateral Construction Work Acceptance and Transfer Certificate: Protection or Risk? 

In the construction sector, it is not uncommon for work to be completed and the project to be in actual use, yet the contractor still has not received payment. The reason is that the client delays or refuses to sign the work acceptance and transfer certificate, thereby delaying final payment.

However, does such conduct mean that the contractor is left without legal protection? Lithuanian law provides a mechanism to protect a contractor who has fulfilled its obligations in good faith—the unilateral work acceptance and transfer certificate.

“A unilateral work acceptance and transfer certificate is not an exception or a loophole. It is a legal instrument designed to protect the contractor in cases where the client unreasonably delays acceptance of the work or payment. However, it may only be used in strict compliance with the requirements of the law,” notes Augustas Platūkis, a lawyer at AVOCAD.

Why is the work acceptance and transfer certificate so important?

In construction contracting relationships, the work acceptance and transfer certificate is one of the most important documents. It is this document that confirms that the contractor has delivered the results of the work and that the client has accepted them.

From this point on, significant legal consequences arise—the client is obligated to pay for the work performed, the warranty period begins, responsibility for the results of the work is transferred, and other rights and obligations provided for in the contract and by law come into effect.

Typically, such a document is signed by both parties. However, in practice, there are often situations where the client deliberately avoids accepting the work and thereby delays payment to the contractor.

How do clients delay the acceptance of work?

In practice, such situations take various forms. For example, a client:

  • ignores the work acceptance and transfer certificates sent by the contractor;
  • points out alleged or minor defects in the work;
  • claims that not all of the work specified in the contract has been completed;
  • begins to voice complaints—which had never been raised before—regarding the organization of work or safety violations;
  • refuses to sign the document on the grounds that the letters of guarantee, insurance documents, or other formal documents have not yet been submitted.

In such situations, a paradoxical situation usually arises—the work has in fact been completed, but due to the client’s actions, the contractor is unable to receive the compensation to which it is entitled.

For example, according to the lawyer, the engineering systems installed in the business center are already operational, and the building’s employees use them every day; however, the client has not signed the work acceptance and transfer certificate for several weeks or even months, citing ever-changing formalities as the reason. In such cases, it is important for the contractor to know that the law provides a means to protect their right to payment.

Unilateral Work Acceptance and Transfer Certificate – Legal Protection Granted to the Contractor

The legislature has established a mechanism that protects the contractor from unfair actions by the client. However, an AVOCAD attorney warns that one must exercise one’s rights prudently and proportionately. In a case heard by the Supreme Court of Lithuania, it was determined that the work performed by the contractor had quality defects, which did not relieve the client of the obligation to accept the completed work under Article 6.694(6) of the Civil Code, as the defects could have been remedied and the client used the work for its intended purpose. On the other hand, the contractor did not exercise its right to sign the acceptance certificate unilaterally and, having assessed the client’s conduct as a material breach of contract, unilaterally terminated the contract and dismantled the work product.

The Court of Cassation recognized that, in the case at hand, the contractor failed to receive payment for the work performed not only because of the client but also because of its own actions; therefore, it ruled that the termination of the contract was unlawful.

According to Augustas Platūkis, if one of the parties refuses to sign the work acceptance and transfer certificate, a note regarding the refusal is made on the certificate, and the other party signs it. This results in a unilateral work acceptance and transfer certificate.

In practice, there is still a view that such an act has no legal significance, but this is not true.

Does a unilateral act have legal effect? “The short answer is yes. Consistent case law recognizes that a unilateral work acceptance and transfer act that has been properly drafted and submitted to the client has the same legal force as an act signed by both parties. It remains valid until a court declares it invalid,” he says.

This means that, pending a court decision, the party that has not signed the document is subject to all the legal consequences that would have arisen had it signed the document. Therefore, if the client fails to pay for work transferred by a unilateral act, the contractor has the right to file a lawsuit and seek a judgment for the debt arising from the work performed. Properly completing the unilateral handover procedure significantly increases the contractor’s chances of successfully enforcing its right to payment.

“Case law is consistent—a properly drafted unilateral work acceptance and transfer certificate has the same legal force as a document signed by both parties. Therefore, both contractors and clients should understand that refusing to sign the certificate does not, in and of itself, negate its legal consequences,” says Augustas Platūkis, a lawyer at AVOCAD.

When can a unilateral act be signed?

It is important for the contractor to understand that a unilateral act is not a means of circumventing the standard work acceptance and handover procedure. This tool may be used only in accordance with the requirements established by law.

First, the contractor must properly notify the client that the work has been completed and that the contractor is ready to hand over the results.

There are two possible scenarios:

  • the client ignores the contractor's notice and fails to appear to accept the work;
  • The client refuses to sign the work acceptance and transfer certificate without providing a valid reason.

In both cases, the contractor may be entitled to draw up a unilateral statement, but only if the client’s refusal is not based on grounds provided for by law.

When does the client have the right to refuse to accept the work?

The law provides an exhaustive list of cases in which a client’s refusal to accept the work is considered legitimate:

  • the contractor missed the deadline for completion of the work, and as a result, the work became meaningless to the client;
  • the results of the mandatory tests or control measurements are negative;
  • defects in the work have been identified that cannot be remedied and that prevent the building or other result of the work from being used for its intended purpose;
  • It is clear that the work has not been completed.

If the client’s refusal does not fall under any of the cases provided for by law, but the client still refuses to sign the document, the contractor has the right to sign it unilaterally and clearly note that the client refused to sign it.

Can a unilateral act be revoked?

According to the lawyer, the law ensures a balance between the interests of both parties. “If the client believes that a unilateral act was drawn up without justification, they have the right to go to court and request that such an act be declared invalid. However, it is important to note that it is the client who bears the burden of filing a lawsuit to challenge such a document,”

Thus, a unilateral work acceptance and transfer certificate is not a privilege of the contractor or a means of circumventing the client’s rights. It is a mechanism provided for by law, designed to ensure the fair performance of the contract and to protect the contractor from unjustified refusal to accept the work and artificial delays in payment.

Swiss arbitration tribunal upheld a basketball club's right to terminate a contract due to a player's concealed injury   

Can a professional athlete join a club while concealing a past injury, be unable to compete at full capacity, and still demand the full salary stipulated in the contract? The Basketball Arbitral Tribunal (BAT), based in Switzerland, provided a precedent-setting answer to this question.  On July 21, 2026, the international basketball arbitration tribunal completely dismissed a claim of more than 50,000 against the Jonava basketball club, which plays in the LKL , recognizing that the club had lawfully terminated the contract after it became clear that the player had concealed a knee injury he had sustained prior to his arrival.

What’s more, the arbitration panel ordered the player himself to cover not only all arbitration costs but also to reimburse the club for its legal expenses. This ruling may be significant in resolving similar professional sports disputes in the future. The Jonava Sports Club was represented in this dispute by attorneys Eimantas Čepas and Egidijus Langys of the law firm AVOCAD.

The injury became apparent after arriving in Lithuania

The dispute arose after the Jonava club signed a one-season contract with the American basketball player in the summer of 2025. Shortly after arriving in Lithuania, the player began complaining of knee pain. An MRI scan conducted at the club’s initiative revealed that the injury was not new—chronic knee damage dating back several months was detected.

An independent forensic medical expert’s report, commissioned by the club, confirmed that the injury had been sustained well before the contract was signed and before the player arrived in Lithuania. The expert also stated that, given the nature of the injury, the athlete could not have failed to feel pain, swelling, and knee instability, and therefore must have been aware of his condition. This conclusion became one of the most important pieces of evidence in the case.

Nevertheless, the player demanded that the club pay him the full salary stipulated in the contract for the season—45,000 U.S. dollars plus interest—claiming that the contract had been terminated without just cause.

The arbitration tribunal dismissed all claims

After several months of proceedings, the BAT issued a ruling that was entirely in the club’s favor—it rejected all of the player’s claims. Furthermore, the arbitration panel ruled that the claimant must bear all costs of the arbitration proceedings. He was also ordered to reimburse the Jonava club for the legal expenses it incurred.

Eimantas Čepas, an attorney at AVOCAD who led the club’s defense in arbitration, says that this case is significant not only because of its financial value. “In international sports law, clubs often find themselves in a weaker position when disputes arise over professional athletes’ contracts. In this case, we were able to prove a fundamental principle—a professional athlete must also act in good faith and may not conceal circumstances that are of decisive importance to the conclusion of the contract. “A professional athlete’s dishonest conduct may result in the athlete losing the right to rely solely on the formal provisions of the contract in the event of a dispute. This is an important message for the entire professional sports sector,” the attorney notes.

According to Egidijus Langis, managing partner at AVOCAD and attorney-at-law, this case is significant for the broader practice of sports law. “This victory demonstrates that meticulously gathered medical evidence, a professionally formulated legal position, and consistent procedural work make it possible to successfully defend the interests of Lithuanian clubs even in the highest-level international arbitration. It is likely that this case will be cited in the future as one of the most important precedents in assessing players’ obligation to disclose information about their health status,” he emphasizes.

Karolis Vaškevičius, head of the Jonava basketball club, which plays inthe LKL, emphasizes that this decision has far greater significance for the club than just the financial outcome. “We are sincerely grateful to the team of attorneys for their exceptional professionalism and principled defense of our interests. We believe this is a historic victory not only for the Jonava club but also for professional sports in Lithuania as a whole. The international arbitration tribunal has clearly confirmed that clubs have the right to expect honesty from professional athletes, and that concealing material facts is not permitted.”

This decision strengthens the legal protection of Lithuanian sports clubs in international disputes and sends a clear message to the professional sports community: fairness in contract negotiations is not a mere formality, but one of the most important rules of professional sports.

 

Warranty Service Turns into a Traffic Accident: What to Do If a Car Entrusted to a Service Center Was Damaged?

For many drivers, car warranty service is associated with safety and trust. It’s only natural to expect that a vehicle entrusted to an authorized dealership will be professionally inspected, repaired, and returned in the same condition as when it was dropped off. But what should you do if, while the car is in for warranty service, it is involved in a traffic accident and is damaged by a service center employee?

The Supreme Court of Lithuania recently examined precisely this type of situation. In the case, a consumer took a new car to an authorized service center for a warranty inspection of the brake system. During a test drive on the street, a service center employee was involved in a traffic accident, and the car was damaged. The consumer decided that he no longer wanted the car, unilaterally terminated the sales contract, and demanded a full refund of the purchase price as well as compensation for damages.

However, the court did not agree with this position. As Mantas Baigys, an attorney with the AVOCAD law firm, points out, this ruling clearly distinguishes between two situations that are often confused—the application of a guarantee and compensation for damages.

“If a car has a manufacturing defect or some other quality issue, the consumer can exercise the rights provided by the warranty. However, if the car was damaged after it was delivered to the buyer—even during warranty service—the warranty terms alone no longer cover such a situation,” says M. Baigys.

In this case, the courts determined that the car was delivered to the buyer in good condition. The defects that arose later were not related to a manufacturing defect or a defect covered by the warranty—they were caused by a traffic accident resulting from the actions of a service center employee. Therefore, according to M. Baigio, such a dispute should be assessed primarily not as a problem with the quality of the item sold, but as a matter of compensation for damages.

What can a car owner demand?

 Although the consumer in this case was unsuccessful in his claim to terminate the sales contract and recover the full price of the car, this does not mean that he is left without protection. The service center is liable for the actions of its employees; therefore, in such cases, a claim for compensation for the damages incurred may be filed. “The court essentially ruled that the service center cannot avoid liability. However, this liability arises not because the warranty was breached, but because damage was caused to another person’s property. In such cases, the consumer has the right to demand full compensation for the damages,” comments M. Baigys. In practice, this may include car repair costs, a decrease in market value, the cost of a rental car, or other losses incurred as a result of the incident. In each case, it is important to assess whether the proposed solution truly compensates for all the damages incurred, rather than just the most obvious repair costs.

According to M. Baigio, in such situations, one should not rush to sign documents confirming that there are no further claims against the service provider. “If this is a matter of compensation for damages, the consumer has the right to demand full compensation for their losses. Therefore, before accepting an offer from a service center or insurance company, it’s worth making sure that it covers not only the car repairs but also other actual consequences,” the attorney notes.

The most important thing is to choose the right way to protect your rights

 This ruling by the Supreme Court of Lithuania is significant because it serves as a reminder that the mere fact that a car was damaged during warranty service does not, in and of itself, entitle the buyer to rescind the purchase and sale agreement and demand a full refund of the price paid for the car. If the car was of satisfactory quality at the time of sale and the damage was caused by a subsequent traffic accident, the dispute should generally be resolved through a claim for damages.

On the other hand, this does not mean that the consumer must accept any offer made by the service provider. By entrusting their car to a professional service provider, the consumer has a reasonable expectation of getting it back safe, in good working order, and without any loss of value due to the service provider’s actions. Therefore, the damage caused by the service provider must be assessed realistically, and the compensation must be adequate. “In such situations, what matters most is not an emotional decision, but a carefully chosen legal course of action. A demand for a full refund of the car’s purchase price may seem logical to the consumer, but legally it may not necessarily be justified. Meanwhile, a properly formulated claim for damages can be significantly more effective,” concludes M. Baigys.

Could you face a harsher penalty if you appeal the fine?  

The Code of Administrative Offenses of the Republic of Lithuania provides that the investigation of administrative offenses and the adjudication of cases are based on fundamental procedural principles—the presumption of innocence, equality before the law, proportionality, due process, expediency, and the prohibition against worsening a person’s situation solely because they have appealed a decision (non reformatio in peius). This principle is one of the most important guarantees of the right to defense for a person facing charges. Its essence is that a person should not be afraid to defend their rights simply because filing an appeal might worsen their situation. If that were the case, the process itself would no longer comply with the principles of justice and fairness.

“The principle ofnon reformatio in peiusensures that a person is free to exercise the right to appeal a decision that they consider unlawful or unfounded. A person’s legal situation cannot be worsened simply because they filed an appeal,” notes Domantas Velykis, an attorney with the AVOCAD law firm.

This principle must be observed at all stages of the proceedings in an administrative offense case—in the court of first instance, on appeal, and during the reopening of the case, as well as when the case is remanded for a new trial. However, it is important to note that the prohibition against worsening a person’s situation is not absolute.

A court of first instance may only worsen the situation of a person subject to administrative liability if a complaint has been filed by the victim. In the appellate instance, this may be done only if the appeal is filed by the authority that issued the decision in the administrative offense case through non-judicial proceedings, the authority whose official conducted the investigation of the administrative offense, or the victim.

In other words, if only the person subject to administrative liability appeals the decision, the court may not, based solely on this appeal, impose a more severe penalty or otherwise worsen that person’s legal situation. However, if the victim or an institution also files an appeal, the court has the right to issue a harsher decision—for example, to impose a more severe administrative penalty or to overturn a more lenient sanction.

How is it determined whether a person's situation has worsened?

When assessing whether the principle ofnon reformatio in peiuswas violated, the comparison is not between the theoretical possibility of reaching a different decision and the actual procedural decisions that were made.

The analysis examines whether the new solution:

  • restricts a person's rights to a greater extent;
  • imposes additional obligations or restrictions;
  • provides for stricter administrative liability;
  • imposes a more severe administrative penalty or administrative sanction;
  • finds the person, against whom the case was dismissed, guilty;
  • awards a higher amount of damages or otherwise worsens his legal position.

As D. Velykis points out, mere assumptions that the situation could have been worse are not enough—a violation of the principle must be established in practice by comparing the specific decisions that were made.

Lithuanian Supreme Court: The situation worsened even after one restriction was lifted

In a recent case before the Supreme Court of Lithuania, the court considered a case in which the police fined an intoxicated driver 800 euros, suspended his driver’s license for six months, and prohibited him from driving vehicles not equipped with alcohol-interlock devices for twelve months. The individual appealed this decision, requesting that the period of the driving suspension be reduced to three months and that the prohibition on driving vehicles without alcohol ignition interlock devices be lifted.

The district court overturned the ban but, at the same time, extended the period of the driving suspension from six to twelve months. The regional court upheld this decision. The Supreme Court of Lithuania ruled that the case had been heard solely on the basis of an appeal filed by the person subject to administrative liability, and therefore the court had no right to worsen his situation. Although one administrative sanction was overturned, the extension of the driving suspension to twelve months effectively constituted a more severe restriction of the person’s rights.

Consequently, the Supreme Court of Lithuania found that the principle ofnon reformatio in peiushad been violated, determined that there had been a fundamental violation of procedural law, and overturned the decisions of both the district and regional courts.

“This ruling reaffirms that the right to appeal a decision cannot result in the risk of facing harsher consequences. This is one of the most important procedural safeguards ensuring a person’s right to an effective defense,” concludes Domantas Velykis, a lawyer at AVOCAD.

A customer isn't paying: Is it really worth going to court right away?

Late payments in business are one of the most common problems faced today by service providers, contractors, manufacturers, and retailers alike. Some customers ask for a week, others for a month, and still others simply stop responding to emails and phone calls. In such situations, businesses often find themselves at a crossroads: should they wait patiently, try to reach an agreement, or go to court immediately?

Eimantas Čepas, an attorney at the AVOCAD law firm, notes that the biggest mistake is usually not taking legal action too quickly. On the contrary—businesses often delay taking any action, hoping that the situation will resolve itself. “It’s understandable that companies don’t want to damage their relationships with clients. However, in practice, we see that the longer a creditor waits, the weaker their negotiating position becomes. If a debtor has been failing to meet their obligations for several months, the likelihood that they will suddenly decide to pay up without any pressure is usually not very high,” says E. Čepas. According to the attorney, it is important to understand that debt collection does not begin in the courtroom, but much earlier—from the first signs that a client is beginning to fall behind on payments.

The first step is to file a clear and professional claim

Quite a few companies still believe that it is sufficient to send a reminder via email with the text “We would like to remind you of an unpaid invoice.” However, from a legal standpoint, such an email is often insufficient. A professionally drafted demand letter clearly states the basis for the debt, specifies the payment deadline, outlines the possible legal consequences, and demonstrates that the creditor is prepared to defend their rights. “A demand letter is not a mere formality. It shows that the situation has reached a stage where the creditor is actively defending their interests. In practice, many debts have been paid precisely after the debtor received a legally substantiated demand letter, because the debtor realized that further delay would only increase their costs,” notes E. Čepas, an attorney at AVOCAD. According to him, the demand letter also serves as important evidence if the dispute ultimately goes to court.

Not every debt is worth taking to court

Although going to court may seem to many like the only way to recover a debt, in practice it is not always the fastest or most cost-effective solution. If the debtor acknowledges the debt, communicates proactively, and presents a realistic repayment plan, it is often worth seeking an amicable settlement. Such a solution saves both time and litigation costs.

However, the situation changes fundamentally when the other party avoids contact, constantly promises to pay “next week” but nothing happens, or begins to dispute circumstances that were not previously disputed. “The most important thing is to assess not only what the client says, but also how they behave. If promises are repeated for several months without any real action, it’s likely that the delay is becoming a deliberate strategy,” says the attorney.

According to E. Čepo, businesses often pay too little attention to gathering evidence. Companies frequently believe that an issued invoice is sufficient. However, in the event of a dispute, all documents confirming that services were provided or goods were delivered become important—contracts, work acceptance certificates, waybills, email correspondence, order confirmations, photos of completed work, or even text message exchanges. “In court, it is not the one who shouts the loudest that they were not paid who wins. The one who can prove it wins. Therefore, every company should think about evidence even before a dispute arises,” emphasizes the AVOCAD attorney.

The delay almost cost us the entire debt

In one case advised by AVOCAD, a company operating in the construction sector performed work under a contract and issued an invoice for more than 80,000 euros. The client acknowledged the debt but kept asking for a little more time, explaining that it was waiting for payment from its partners. In an effort to maintain good business relations, the company took no active steps for nearly nine months. It was only after consulting with lawyers that it became clear that the debtor’s financial situation had already deteriorated significantly, and some of its assets had been transferred. “Fortunately, in this case, we were still able to take action and protect our client’s interests. However, this story clearly illustrates that preserving business relationships should not mean passivity. The sooner you begin to manage the situation, the greater the chances of protecting your money,” comments E. Čepas.

The attorney emphasizes that every situation is unique, but waiting should not become a strategy. Some debts might not arise at all if contracts paid more attention to risk management. According to Eimmantas Čepas, in practice, it is common to encounter contracts that lack clear payment deadlines, late fees, interest rates, payment milestones, or even procedures for resolving disputes.

A properly drafted contract should provide for: clear payment terms, late payment penalties and other penalties, the right to suspend the provision of services or the supply of goods if the client fails to fulfill their obligations, the application of advance payments or other measures to secure obligations, and a clear dispute resolution procedure.

“A good contract isn’t necessary when both parties are working together smoothly. Its true value becomes apparent when a conflict arises. The clearer the terms agreed upon in advance, the less room there is for interpretation and disputes in the future,” says the attorney.

In summary, E. Čepas identifies the five most common mistakes made by companies:

  • waits too long and fails to take active steps;
  • does not submit a properly prepared claim;
  • does not collect sufficient evidence of services rendered or goods delivered;
  • enter into contracts that are not sufficiently clear;
  • People turn to lawyers only when the situation has already become critical.

Although every situation is different, there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Sometimes the most effective solution is constructive negotiation; in other cases, it is necessary to take immediate legal action. The most important thing is not to ignore the early warning signs and not to let the debt “resolve itself.” “Businesses often think that lawyers are only needed once a case has already reached court. In reality, we can add the most value much earlier—by helping to assess risks, choose the most appropriate course of action, and avoid situations where debt collection becomes significantly more complicated or even impossible,” summarizes Eimantas Čepas, an attorney at AVOCAD.

 

Court: One Cannot Benefit from Repairs to Joint Property and Refuse to Pay for the Work Performed

Disputes over the costs of repairing common areas in apartment buildings often go beyond the mere issue of debt. Arguments frequently raised in court concern procurement procedures, the organization of tenders, the contractors selected by the homeowners’ association or the building manager, the reasonableness of work prices, or even payments to the companies that performed the work. However, a recent ruling by the Vilnius Regional Court shows that in such cases, it is important not to lose sight of the fundamental question: whether the work was actually performed and whether the unit owners who benefited from it can refuse to pay for it.

Karolina Laura Briliūtė, a senior attorney at the AVOCAD law firm, notes that in practice, debtors’ arguments often stray from the substance of the dispute itself. “In cases involving debts for repairs to common-use areas, we often see arguments that no competitive bidding process was organized, that procurement rules may have been violated, that there is insufficient data on the association’s or administrator’s payments to the contractor, or that payment documents have not been provided. Sometimes it is precisely these circumstances that form the basis for dismissing claims, even though they are not directly related to the main issue of the case—whether the work was performed and whether the owners are obligated to contribute to its financing,” says K. L. Briliūtė.

In the case at hand, the court of first instance had dismissed the claims, emphasizing, among other things, circumstances related to the procedures for organizing the work, the justification of the cost of the work, and payments to the contractor. However, the appellate court reached a different conclusion. The court noted that the evidence in the case suggests that the repair work was in fact performed and that the condition of the common-use facilities was improved. In the court’s view, a situation in which the direct beneficiaries of the work performed fail to pay for the work at all is inconsistent with the principles of justice, reasonableness, and good faith.

According to K. L. Briliūtė, it is precisely this point emphasized by the court that is particularly significant. “The court stated very clearly that one cannot ignore the fact that the work was performed and that all co-owners benefit from the results. If a common-use property has been repaired, procedural issues alone do not mean that the owners can be completely exempted from the obligation to cover their share of the costs,” the lawyer notes.

More importantly, the appellate court directly addressed the arguments that are raised particularly frequently in cases of this nature. The ruling states that the circumstances regarding compliance or non-compliance with procurement rules, as well as questions regarding the extent to which the homeowners’ association or the administrator has settled accounts with the selected contractor, are not of material significance in this case when determining the owners’ debt. In the court’s view, the case did not concern the issue of mutual settlements between the homeowners’ association or the administrator and the contractor, but rather whether the owners are obligated to pay for the repair work actually performed and to what extent these expenses are justified.

This position may be significant for many homeowners’ associations and property managers who face situations where some owners refuse to pay their share of repair costs, citing circumstances unrelated to the performance of the work itself. “It is important to understand that the maintenance and repair of common areas are the responsibility of all co-owners. Therefore, when evaluating such disputes, the focus should be on whether the work was necessary, whether it was actually performed, and whether the expenses are reasonable. Otherwise, a paradoxical situation arises in which common-use areas are repaired, all owners benefit from them, yet some of them refuse to contribute to covering the costs,” says K. L. Briliūtė.

The court also took into account the broader context of such disputes. The ruling emphasized that the opposite situation would negate the obligation of the owners of the premises themselves to maintain the common areas and would not ensure a final resolution of the dispute. In other words, the legal system cannot encourage a model in which co-owners benefit from the results of repairs but avoid covering their costs.

According to a senior attorney at AVOCAD, this ruling contributes to the development of a more consistent body of case law and may serve as an important guide in future cases. “The appellate court reiterated a fundamental rule: when evaluating such disputes, the most important thing is to determine whether repair work on common-use areas was actually performed and whether the co-owners benefited from it. It is precisely these circumstances that must be at the center of the dispute, rather than secondary issues that do not necessarily determine the existence of the obligation to pay itself,” summarizes K. L. Briliūtė. The ruling of the Vilnius Regional Court once again confirms that in cases initiated by homeowners’ associations and property managers regarding the recovery of repair costs, the most important factors remain the actual performance of the work, its results, and the co-owners’ obligation to contribute to the maintenance and upkeep of the common property.

Access to the courts should not be a privilege: what you need to know about reimbursement of attorney's fees

The right to access the courts is one of the most important guarantees of the rule of law. However, this right is not merely the opportunity to file a complaint or respond to one. It is inseparable from the parties’ ability to seek professional legal assistance from an attorney or legal assistant and to recover reasonable litigation costs incurred in doing so.

This is precisely why the new case law being established by the Supreme Court of Lithuania regarding the reimbursement of legal fees is significant for anyone defending their rights in court. Until now, when a party was unable—even for objective reasons—to fully settle the bill with the attorney and submit supporting documents by the end of the trial, even though it was evident that legal services had been provided and the obligation to pay for them existed, the courts would rule that such costs did not meet the criterion of reality and therefore would not award them against the losing party.

According to Julius Sakalauskas, an attorney with AVOCAD, a law firm specializing in litigation, this approach did not always ensure an effective right to judicial protection. “The right to access the courts cannot be viewed in isolation. It is directly linked to a person’s ability to have professional representation and, upon winning the case, to recover reasonably incurred litigation costs. If this possibility becomes too formalistic, the right to a fair trial may remain merely theoretical for some people,” says the AVOCAD attorney.

Recent case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania has noted that the approach under which reimbursement of litigation costs cannot be awarded solely because a document confirming payment of the invoice was not submitted before the conclusion of the proceedings, and that the party must therefore reapply to the court for an additional decision, does not always comply with the essence of the right to an effective judicial remedy.

The court noted that such a formal application of the requirements is not entirely consistent with the principles of justice and reasonableness, the principles of procedural concentration and economy, and the purpose of civil procedure—to effectively protect individuals’ violated or disputed rights and legitimate interests. Therefore, the Supreme Court decided to revise the existing practice regarding the reimbursement of attorneys’ fees, clarifying that the mere fact that a party to the case failed to submit documents confirming payment of attorneys’ fees by the end of the proceedings cannot be interpreted as precluding the parties from agreeing to defer payment of legal fees, nor as preventing the court from ruling on the award of such deferred fees against the opposing party.

“Thus, based on the latest interpretation of the provision of the Code of Civil Procedure establishing a party’s right to reimbursement of attorney’s fees, a party seeking to recover these costs must submit to the court a request for reimbursement of litigation costs, along with documents allowing the court to determine what specific legal services were provided and what their cost is. If these services have not yet been paid for by the end of the proceedings, it is sufficient to submit an agreement with the attorney confirming the party’s obligation to pay these costs in the future. It is also important that the individual no longer needs to provide additional justification for the reason why the representation costs have not been paid by the end of the proceedings,” notes J. Sakalauskas.

According to the attorney, this interpretation has significant practical implications for both individuals and businesses. “In litigation practice, I have repeatedly encountered situations where people hesitate to go to court not because they doubt the validity of their position, but because they fear they cannot afford the costs of the proceedings, especially when the dispute involves a financially much stronger opponent. A clear understanding that reasonable legal fees may be reimbursed even if they have not yet been paid—with payment scheduled in installments and even in the future—strengthens confidence in the legal system and the effective exercise of the right to a defense,” he states.

According to an AVOCAD attorney, today, as legal proceedings become increasingly complex and professional legal assistance is, in many cases, a prerequisite for effectively defending one’s rights, the emerging case law underscores a fundamental principle: the right to a fair trial must not be theoretical or illusory, but real and effective. This means that the possibility of recovering reasonably incurred litigation costs must be assessed not merely formally, but in light of the true purpose of civil proceedings—to ensure the effective protection of violated rights and the fair resolution of disputes.

 

An organized tour didn't meet expectations: what rights do travelers have? 

Vacations are usually associated with relaxation, new experiences, and a carefully planned itinerary. Advertisements for organized tours also often promise a clear package of services—a specific hotel, excursions, guide services, places of interest, or additional entertainment. However, in practice, it is not uncommon for the actual trip to fall short of what was promised: some excursions are canceled, planned activities are replaced with inferior alternatives or not replaced at all, services are of poor quality, and the overall travel experience fails to meet the traveler’s reasonable expectations.

In such cases, the question naturally arises: is it possible to defend one’s rights and receive compensation for a ruined vacation? Karolina Laura Briliūtė, a lawyer at the law firm AVOCAD, notes that the traveler’s expectations in such situations are, after all, legally significant. “The traveler’s legitimate expectations are shaped by the travel advertisement, itinerary, information provided by the organizer, and promises made. Therefore, a package tour contract is evaluated not only formally but also based on the content and quality of services the consumer reasonably expected,” she explains.

The organizer is responsible for the entire trip

According to Karolina Briliūtė, a tour operator must ensure the proper provision of all services specified in the package tour contract, regardless of whether they are actually provided by the operator itself or by third parties—such as hotels, tour guides, transportation companies, or local partners.

This means that the traveler is not required to determine which specific service provider is at fault for the inadequate services provided—the tour operator bears full responsibility.

Case law emphasizes that tourists have a legitimate expectation of receiving services of adequate quality, accurate and comprehensive information, and smooth travel arrangements. As a professional service provider, the organizer is required to carefully select its partners, monitor their activities, and assume the risk of improper performance of the contract.

When can you claim compensation?

An AVOCAD lawyer notes that, according to case law, in cases where an organized tour does not meet expectations, the consumer may claim compensation for both pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages or a reduction in the price of the tour.

According to K. L. Briliūtė, determining the amount of damages is not difficult in simpler cases—for example, when a specific tour does not take place or a flight is canceled. However, more complex situations arise when the entire trip is organized in a chaotic manner, the itinerary is only partially carried out, and the quality of the vacation is clearly compromised.

In such cases, the traveler may request:

  • a reduction in the cost of the trip;
  • compensation for property damage;
  • compensation for non-pecuniary damages for disruption of vacation plans, inconvenience, or loss of travel value.

According to the lawyer, when determining the amount of compensation, the following factors are taken into account: what portion of the services was not provided at all, how many were provided in a substandard manner, how significant the deviations from the promised quality were, and what proportion of the total trip cost was accounted for by the services that were not provided or were of poor quality.

In practice, significant violations may include failure to visit the sites specified in the itinerary, long waits due to organizational issues, inadequate transportation conditions, malfunctioning air conditioning or heating systems, vehicle breakdowns, or negligent service.

What is important for travelers to do themselves?

Although consumers enjoy enhanced protection in such situations, the burden of proving the violations and the damages incurred falls on the traveler. For this reason, it is particularly important to properly document all deficiencies.

An AVOCAD lawyer recommends:

  • immediately notify the tour guide or tour operator of any violations;
  • photograph and film defects;
  • save the correspondence;
  • have promotional materials and an itinerary;
  • collect documents supporting the additional expenses.

Upon returning from the trip, it is recommended that you submit a written complaint to the tour operator, clearly stating the violations that occurred, your claims, and the amount of compensation you are seeking.

If the tour operator refuses to meet the claims or offers inadequate compensation, the traveler may contact the State Consumer Rights Protection Service and, subsequently, take the matter to court.

“Case law shows that travelers’ rights are defended quite vigorously in such cases, especially when the consumer can provide clear evidence that the trip did not meet the promised conditions. Even established but unmet expectations of the traveler can be a significant criterion when deciding on compensation,” notes AVOCAD attorney Karolina Briliūtė.

An insurance payout cannot be reduced on the basis of “implied” obligations

Many people choose insurance hoping for one very simple thing—that in the event of a disaster, they won’t have to fight for basic fairness. In practice, however, even after paying substantial premiums, consumers often find themselves in situations where the insurer refuses to pay the full claim based on rules or obligations about which the policyholder was not actually clearly informed.

This is precisely the situation that the Supreme Court of Lithuania recently examined in a case involving a reduced comprehensive auto insurance payout.

In this case, the insurer had reduced the payout by 50 percent, arguing that the car owner had lost the car key prior to the theft but had not taken additional security measures or notified the insurer of this. However, the courts found that such obligations had not been clearly specified in the individual terms of the insurance contract, and the insurance policy terms had not even been properly provided to the consumer.

Commenting on the latest case law of the Supreme Court of Lithuania, Mantas Baigys, an attorney with a law firm, says that this ruling is particularly important in the context of consumer protection. “An insurer cannot rely on obligations about which the consumer was not clearly informed when the contract was concluded. If certain circumstances under which the payout could be reduced are not clearly discussed, the consumer is not required to anticipate them,” the attorney notes.

In its ruling, the Supreme Court of Lithuania very clearly distinguished between two situations: the general duty to act with due care and the insurer’s right to reduce the insurance payout. The court noted that the mere abstract argument that a person “should have acted more cautiously” is insufficient. If an insurer wishes to limit its liability or reduce the payout due to certain circumstances, such cases must be clearly and individually addressed in the insurance contract.

The court also clarified that the provision of the Civil Code regarding the duty to mitigate damages had been incorrectly applied in this case. The Supreme Court emphasized that this rule applies when the insured event has already occurred or is occurring, i.e., when the insured fails to take action to mitigate the damage after the event. In the case at hand, however, the insurer attempted to apply this provision to the situation prior to the theft—when the person had lost the key.

According to Mantas Baigys, what is even more important is that the Court clearly emphasized that if an insurer seeks to rely on gross negligence on the part of the insured as a basis for reducing the payout, such cases must be specifically provided for in the insurance contract itself. “This is required by the Insurance Law. The Court found that in this case, specific obligations—such as replacing the car’s locks or parking the car in a secure lot—had not been individually discussed with the consumer,” the lawyer comments.

The ruling also reiterates a very important rule: insurance terms and conditions that have not been properly disclosed to the consumer do not become part of the contract and cannot be enforced against the consumer.

The court also paid particular attention to the principles of consumer protection. The ruling drew on the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union, emphasizing that consumer contracts must not only be formally clear but also genuinely understandable to the consumer. A person must be able to understand in advance what circumstances may lead to a limitation of insurance coverage and what economic consequences a particular contractual term will have for them.

According to Mantas Baigys, an attorney at AVOCAD, this case sends a very clear message to the entire insurance market. “Insurance contracts cannot be interpreted in such a way that the consumer only learns of additional requirements or consequences after an incident has occurred. If an insurer wishes to limit its liability, such conditions must be clear, understandable, and individually negotiated,” he states.

In its final ruling, the court awarded the policyholder the entire remaining portion of the insurance proceeds as well as the costs of the proceedings.

Illegal building permits: Businesses shouldn’t be the only ones to pay for the authorities’ mistakes 

Who is liable for the consequences when construction is carried out under a building permit that was officially issued but later deemed unlawful? Does the entire risk automatically fall on the builder, even if the builder acted in accordance with municipal decisions and documents issued by state authorities?

It is precisely these issues that the Supreme Court of Lithuania has addressed in detail in its most recent case law, as commented on by Viktorija Dubovskienė, an attorney with the law firm AVOCAD .

The court heard the case regarding the municipality’s decisions to lease a plot of state-owned land and issue a building permit for the construction of tennis courts and related infrastructure, even though the plot had been transferred to the municipality for a specific purpose—the construction of administrative and service facilities for the airfield.

The most significant part of this ruling is not the revocation of the permit itself, but—according to an AVOCAD attorney—the Lithuanian Supreme Court’s clarification regarding the allocation of costs for remedying the consequences of unlawful construction.

“The court emphasized that in cases where construction was carried out based on officially issued permits, liability cannot automatically be attributed solely to the builder. When determining who must cover the costs of demolishing the structures, restoring the site, or remedying other consequences, it is necessary to establish what role both public administration entities and the builder themselves played in the specific situation,” notes Viktorija Dubovskienė.

The ruling notes that the issuance of building permits falls specifically within the purview of public administration authorities, which are responsible for conducting preliminary construction oversight and ensuring that permits comply with the law.

The Supreme Court also relied on the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and emphasized that errors made by public authorities cannot be rectified by imposing a disproportionate burden on a private entity alone. “The court clearly stated that, before deciding on the removal of the consequences of the construction, it is necessary to identify the specific individuals or institutions whose actions led to the issuance of the unlawful permit and the illegality of the construction,” says the lawyer.

AVOCAD attorney Viktorija Dubovskienė notes that this practice could have a particularly significant impact on future disputes regarding illegal construction. “This case very clearly shows that courts will assess not only the formal existence of a permit, but also what actually created the situation that led to the consequences of the illegal construction. If a private entity acted in reliance on decisions by state institutions, the allocation of liability becomes much more complex,” she notes.

Until now, the prevailing view in practice has often been that the primary risk falls on the developer, but this ruling clearly reinforces the importance of the principle of proportionality. “In this case, the Supreme Court of Lithuania very clearly emphasizes that the role of public administration bodies cannot be ignored. If a municipality or other institution itself makes unlawful decisions, issues permits, and creates the conditions for a project to be implemented, the entire financial burden cannot be automatically shifted to the business alone,” says V. Dubovskienė.

The attorney also notes that this ruling could have a significant impact on the investment climate and business confidence in the state. “Businesses reasonably expect that permits issued by state institutions are lawful and enable them to carry out projects safely. Therefore, courts will increasingly assess not only the formal fact of a violation, but also the responsibility of the authorities and the investor’s own good faith,” she says.

This ruling by the Supreme Court of Lithuania establishes an important precedent regarding the proportionate allocation of liability in cases where construction is carried out on the basis of building permits that were later found to be unlawful, and clearly reiterates that the consequences of errors by state institutions cannot be automatically shifted to a single party—a private entity.